Articles (2020)

A “Speshul” Hiker: Junaid Dawud and the Colorado 14ers Thru-Hike

Junaid “Speshul 41” Dawud may have cut his teeth on the Pacific Crest Trail – twice – but he earned one of the top ten FKTs of 2013 for completing his “14ers” thru-hike. This route links all 58 of the 14,000-foot peaks in Colorado.

58 peaks. 72 days. 1350 miles. 300,000+ feet of elevation gain.

Junaid Dawud may have cut his teeth on the Pacific Crest Trail – twice – but he earned one of the top ten FKTs of 2013 for completing his “14ers” thru-hike. This route links all 58 of the 14,000-foot peaks in Colorado.

Dawud gives hundreds of pack “shakedown” presentations, guides trips in the desert southwest, teaches for the Leave No Trace Center for Outdoor Ethics, and even co-hosts a podcast.

I first met “Speshul 41” (Dawud’s trail name; Speshul, for short) just before the 14ers thru-hike began, and he’s been a mentor of mine as I continue on my journey of lightweight backpacking – a mentor deeply invested in and connected with the communities he serves.

A Speshul Hiker Jameson 1
Speshul 41 approaching Missouri Mountain Summit. Photo: 14ersthruhike.com

Pacific Crest Trail: Obsession

Speshul started hiking during his time as an undergraduate at the University of Hawaii at Mānoa, where he studied Geology and Geophysics.

Day-hikes and the occasional multi-day backpacking trip to places like Haleakalā were a good start, but after a roommate gave him a pile of magazines that included a National Geographic Adventure magazine with an article about the Triple Crown, his heart was set on hiking the Pacific Crest Trail. “I pretty much went from curiosity to obsession to planning. Within a year of finding out about the PCT, I was buying gear, planning my hike, buying the guidebooks, and joining the next year’s online discussion forums,” he smiles, remembering. “And before I knew it, it was the beginning of April [2006], I was quitting my job, I was packing my world away, and getting ready to head out on the trail.”

While Speshul made it 2,420 miles in 2006 – just past Snoqualmie Pass – winter’s arrival stopped him short of Canada. He and another hiker went to Seattle to acquire some better gear and then returned to the trail. The two hikers waited out a white-out blizzard before attempting a few more miles in knee-high drifts the following day.

The excruciatingly slow and difficult snow travel convinced them that the thru-hiking season was over.

“We ended up quitting on October 30th, so that gives you an idea of how late we had pushed the season,” he recounts, amusement in his voice. “Even if we had the equipment, we didn’t have the experience to be able to navigate the last 230 miles to the border safely.” He returned to Snoqualmie Pass in 2007 to finish his miles, and was ultimately glad he’d called off his 2006 hike: “There were some sections where I was like, man, if we had tried to push through in this section, it would have been dangerous.”

Completing what amounted to a two-year section hike of the PCT wasn’t enough for Speshul. “When I got off the trail in 2006, I pretty much knew at that time that I was going to try to hike the whole thing again. It was just a matter of when. I didn’t know if that was going to be the next year, two years, five years, ten years, twenty years, but I knew that I was at some point going to try to hike the whole PCT again.” So in 2010, taking a friend’s determination to attempt the PCT as motivation, Speshul set out from Mexico towards Canada once more – to great success, arriving in Canada on September 14th.

Rocky Mountain High: Colorado

After returning home to Colorado in the wake of his success, Speshul soon felt that familiar disquiet within – a disquiet urged on by a fresh idea.

“I moved to Colorado to climb 14ers, but I had only climbed [Grays and Torreys]. So for me, the 14ers thru-hike was a way to go ahead and climb the fourteeners and scratch that itch for a thru-hike.”

Planning involved two main issues: which order to hike the peaks in, and then which routing between peaks and groups of peaks to take. It wasn’t until after he and his hiking partner Luke DeMuth had finished the route that they learned that another group had done a similar hike encompassing the traditional 54 fourteeners in the mid-80s – so no routing information from that trip was available to them. Culebra, Longs, and Pikes Peaks added extra routing difficulties, as all three peaks sit off on their own; given the necessity of permits to climb Culebra, and Speshul’s proclivity for going northbound on trails, he opted to start at Culebra in the south and end at Longs in the north.

A Speshul Hiker Jameson 2
Map of the 14ers thru-hike route in blue. Source: 14ersthruhike.com

The route that Speshul designed involved some trails, some cross-country travel, and some roads, both paved and dirt.

Over the course of the 1350-odd mile trek, he and DeMuth hiked what they estimate was about 350,000 feet of elevation gain, though having to reset the GPS every 100,000 feet made exact calculations difficult.

In the 72 days it took them to complete the route, they took four zeros (no hiking days), some for pleasure, some for sickness.

Much of their hike is documented in detail at 14ersthruhike.com. The stories Speshul told me not only center around amazing or concerning on-trail experiences but also around other people and displays of human kindness. Stories included the gift of a freshly-caught fish and a woman who tracked down Speshul and DeMuth at the top of Mount Evans to give them sandwiches.

A Speshul Hiker Jameson 3
Speshul (front) and DeMuth, at the summit of Longs Peak, the finish of the 14ers thru-hike. Photo: Junaid Dawud

Teacher, Guide, Trainer: Giving Back

Speshul has experienced many such kindnesses on all of his trail experiences and has made it his mission to pay those kindnesses forward. “The only reason I’ve been able to have the experiences I’ve had is that other people built the trails and other resources I’ve used,” he reasons. “You’ve got to find a way to give back somehow.”

And he’s found several ways to give back over the years.

After attending the Annual Day Zero Pacific Crest Trail Kick Off (ADZPCTKO) before both his 2006 thru-hike attempt and 2010 thru-hike, he returned in 2011 wanting to give back. He found a way in 2012 by bringing like-new thrift-store upgrades and distributing them to current-year hikers as a part of pack shakedowns given by the Wolverines of the PCT, a hiker community that supports PCT Trail Angels.

2013 saw the “Shakedown Shack” become an official part of the event, with not only more thrifted gear but also brand new gear to distribute, with donations coming in from both companies and individuals. A few years – and hundreds of shakedowns – later, the ADZPCTKO organizers voted Speshul onto the event’s board for his work at the Shack and dedication to the community.

The ADZPCTKO is now defunct. However, Speshul still finds ways to work with outdoor communities, whether introducing others to the desert southwest through guiding, speaking about his 14ers thru-hike for ALDHA-West at events like the Gathering and the Rockies Ruck, or, most recently, working for the Leave No Trace Center for Outdoor Ethics.

His year-long position as a Subaru/Leave No Trace Traveling Trainer saw him traveling the US in 2017, teaching outdoor recreationists in 18 states various ways that they can make a difference in the outdoor spaces they love. He hopes that his efforts will lead to people leaving our trails and public spaces as good or better than they found them – a goal he takes seriously as well as, collecting trash whenever he finds it on the trail.

The Trail Show

Though he’s serious about his involvement in outdoor pursuits, Speshul has a sly sense of humor, best exemplified in his exploits as a co-host on the monthly, Boulder, Colorado-based podcast The Trail Show. Speshul co-hosts the podcast with Triple Crowners Lawton “Disco” Grinter, Felicia “POD” Hermosillo, and Mike “D-Low” DiLorenzo, talking “less about gear and more about beer” (the podcast’s official slogan). The podcast provides the perfect venue for hearing Speshul’s passion for and pride in our outdoor community.

A Speshul Hiker Jameson 4
Speshul at the New River Gorge. Photo: Amanda Jameson

The Future of the 14ers Thru-Hike

That pride, of course, extends to his planning of and execution of his 14ers thru-hike. “I’d love for it to be an established, sanctioned route,” he mentions – though for that to become a reality, other hikers need to succeed in their attempts. While he’s been consulted by several other hikers about attempts, no one, it seems, has been able to complete the route. He’s awaiting the day that backpackers with the requisite skills not only hike his route but improve it. “Someday,” he grins.

Contact Speshul at 14ersthruhike.com.

Vancouver Island: Trauma on a West Coast Trail Backpacking Trip

Vancouver Island and I are on a collision course for a rematch. Here’s a story about my recent trials on a West Coast Trail backpacking trip.

Introduction

Nine years ago, a hike through British Columbia’s West Coast Trail (WCT) left me battered, bruised, missing toenails, limping and using trekking poles as crutches. During the first five kilometers of the trip, I slipped and fell resulting in a sprained ankle, and unbeknownst to me, a stress fractured metatarsal. After 71 kilometers of limping through mud and tree roots, I had developed permanent nerve damage. To this day, the limp is still present, and a high-mileage trek can bring excruciating pain to the surface. Now almost a decade later, my friends convinced me to return and hike this bucket-list trail. I surprised myself by agreeing to the 76-kilometer venture.

The West Coast Trail and I are on a collision course for a rematch.

A decade ago, I paid minimal attention to pack weights. I was young, muscular and naturally athletic, which carried me through backpacking. Though most would argue I am still all of those things, I need to plan with more care now. In addition to watching my ounces for my nerve damaged foot, I must pay close attention to how much stress I place on upper body joints and ligaments (see My Journey from Injury to the Canadian Rockies for details.)

Trip Logistics

Planning and Preparation

  • The WCT requires strong planning skills. Transportation to Vancouver Island is necessary, and the trailheads can be challenging. Almost all transportation needs advanced booking or flex days included in the itinerary. The trail requires a permit. Book permits well in advance, or they will be sold out. (I booked in January of 2016 for my hike in September of 2016.)
  • Parks Canada provides an updated planning guide each year. (WCT Planning Guide)
  • The book, Blisters and Bliss, Trekkers Guide to the West Coast Trail, is an invaluable resource which is updated by the author semi-regularly, if not annually.

Travel Style

  • The West Coast Trail 2016 is a team trip. Gear sharing and team planning are crucial. The WCT requires heading out with companions with similar trekking style and speed. For this trip, I’m heading out with some good friends. We’ve done long treks together before and never shared so much as an irritated glance between us.

Logistical Notes

  • Travel to Vancouver Island is the most difficult logistical challenge. The island is reachable by ferry, bus, private vehicle and or plane.
  • We will fly into the nearest airport and bus from the nearest terminal to the trailhead.
  • As we are flying, we will be unable to travel with items like fuel. I will order a hiker box from the local outfitter.
  • Clean up gear for the return flight (the other passengers appreciate it). Clean clothes and toiletries can be left with the bus company for a fee.

Equipment Notes

  • The western edge of BC’s Vancouver Island is a coastal rainforest: saying the area is “damp” is an extreme understatement. In September, weeks of rain can be expected. Footing on this trail is treacherous at best – a slip and fall can be wet and unpleasant or painful and deadly. I recommend a synthetic sleep system, quick-dry layers, a wind- and rain-resistant tent, and footwear that provides stiffness and traction for edging on steep, wet, and muddy terrain. Although not ultralight, most experienced users of the trail wear a proper hiking boot, gaiters, full rain gear, and river crossing shoes.
  • The trail has up to seventy sections of wooden-laddered cliff faces. Some laddered sections are close to a hundred feet in height. The rainforest and the Pacific Ocean have frequently attempted to reclaim the trail. Though a maintained trail, trail damage is common. In some areas, the damage creates unsafe conditions, so your footwear choice is of utmost importance.
  • Approximately 8000 hikers a year attempt the trek. Eighty to 100 backpackers will be medically evacuated, and 200 will sustain injuries. Ropes and other safety equipment are sometimes found on the trail but are not maintained. Be prepared to test any equipment and come up with an alternate technique for climbing difficult sections. Many trail users recommend a heavy length of climbing rope, especially if attempting difficult surge channels and beach crossings.
  • Bears, cougars, and other wildlife frequent the trail and proper techniques for bear country are mandatory. The trail offers food storage lockers, but they can be full during peak season. Be prepared to bring a bear bag or canister if traveling during peak season.

Photo Journal

Murphy’s Law

When September 17, 2016, finally arrived, I was a frantic mess of last minute details and snags. Despite an overwhelming craving to cancel the trip, I knew I needed a vacation from my life and the inordinate ongoing pressures. A family emergency and heavy workload seemed to eat up all the time I thought I had left to finish all the last minute planning details. Thank goodness, true to my word in my best practices article; though harried and frayed, I had the major details worked out. The only planning steps left: a meal plan, quick pack stuffing, and some optional bookings.

My friends arrived at just after 7 am to pick me up, and I knew we were going to be pushing time limits. There was nothing any of us could do about it except grin, bare it and hope for the best at the airport. Once at the airport, we struggled to find parking, a detail I had neglected to arrange in the chaos which had been my life for several weeks. Arranged parking can save a few dollars and a few minutes when time counts. As it happened, booking parking could not have prevented us from a near catastrophe.

Best Laid Plans

After rushing to the airport and standing in the check baggage line, we were five minutes too late to check any bags. I could get on the plane if I left my gear behind. My team exchanged glances, and we knew there was no point getting on a plane without gear. Thank goodness for West Jet’s wonderful service team. The baggage check attendant rebooked us for a flight leaving for Comox, BC, Canada. The flight was boarding ten minutes later than our current flight to Nanaimo, BC, Canada which still had time to check baggage. She didn’t charge us a dime for the flight change, and we solved one minor snag of many to follow.

Getting us and our gear to Vancouver Island was helpful. However, we would land in the wrong city. Having enough time to pick up supplies and get to our bus on time was going to be an issue. The bus was departing from Nanaimo at 2 pm, and we were landing in Comox (an hour and a half from Nanaimo) at 11 am. We needed a rental car and needed one fast when we landed. I have never bailed out of a plane so fast in my life! I ran across the tarmac to the rental car kiosk. If I wasn’t one of the first in line for a rental car, we might miss the bus. We also had to face reality; we may not be able to obtain our box of supplies in time.

Hop, Skip and a Jump

As fate would have it, I made it to the kiosk second in line. I sighed with relief, and we loaded our gear into the last remaining SUV. I had ordered a hiking box of supplies, but we were well out of the way to pick it up at Valhalla Pure Outfitters in Nanaimo. After some Google Map searching, we found a Valhalla Pure in Courtney, BC which had the supplies we needed and was directly on our route. Next door to the Valhalla, we found a Canadian Tire which had the remainder of the supplies we needed.

We actually made it to Nanaimo with time to spare! After grabbing a quick lunch and dropping the rental car off, the staff at the rental car agency was able to drop us off at Departure Bay Terminal. When the bus arrived, I sank into the seat with a sigh. The details were mostly handled from this point forward.

The scenic bus terminal in Departure Bay. The West Coast Trail, Canada’s Wild Coast (below).

1 P9170221

2 P9170222

All around Departure Bay there are signs of industry and transport (above).

The Wheels on the Bus…

The bus ride is several hours through rough, winding, logging roads. I was thankful I had remembered to take some Gravol (nausea relief) before I climbed aboard. By the time we all staggered off the bus, we were all grateful for solid ground.

In addition to not booking parking, I also did not book accommodations at the trailhead. I should mention here that accommodations are mandatory if you arrive at the trailhead after 2 pm. To hike the WCT, every hiker is required to attend the orientation at the trail office at 10 am or 2 pm. Mandatory attendance is easy for the Parks Canada Staff to enforce. If you don’t go to orientation you won’t get a trail permit. Without a permit, a ferryman will not take you to the trailhead.

The WCT Office is about a one hour walk to the edge of the nearest town, Port Renfrew, BC. Five minutes away is the Pacheedaht First Nations Campground. Having stayed at the beach here in 2006, I wanted to camp here again. Prices are reasonable, and in late September there are usually enough campsites, but it was something of a gamble not to book in advance.

3 P9170234

Above: After several hours on a plane, in a rental car and eventually a bus, I finally reached my beloved West Coast Ocean Vista at Pacheedaht Campground, Port Renfrew, BC, Canada.

Wild Renfrew

As it happened, my gamble paid off and I got a spot near the ocean. Once we had set up camp and changed into some rain layers, it was close to 7 PM. With a lack of motivation to cook, we opted to hike into Port Renfrew for dinner. After an hour of trekking along the narrow logging road into Port Renfrew, we reached the edge of town. Forty-five minutes later, we walked into the heart of town. From there, we walked to the best restaurant in town: The Coastal Kitchen. We all knew it was going to be a long couple of days before we would have hot, fresh food and a fresh gourmet pizza was impossible to resist.

Welcome to the Coast

We order a Big Kahuna pizza and the specialty ice tea and wait for what I describe as the best pizza I have ever had in Canada. While we are eating, we are reminded we are in the middle of the rainforest in a remote coastal town. Torrential rains pound on the tin roof of The Coastal Kitchen. I exchange glances with my companions. We have rain gear, but two hours of hiking back to our tents in the pouring rain and pitch-dark night on a narrow coastal road is unappealing.

I call the server and ask if there is a cab in town who might be willing to take us back to Pacheedaht.

Her: “A cab? No. Well, there is Evan.”

Me: “Evan?”

Her: “Evan, he runs the hiker parking lot at the trailhead, but he only helps hikers.”

Me: “We are hikers, we start tomorrow.”

She smiles and says she’ll call him. “Yup, they are hikers.” I overhear her say from the kitchen. Although Evan’s service has closed for the season, he will pick us up anyway.

A Short Trip Down a Long Road

A few moments later, Evan pulls up in front of The Coastal Kitchen. We scurry from underneath the awning through the blinding rain and climb into the exceptionally clean interior of a well used but serviceable minivan. Evan looks back at us and says “Mind the back seat; I just had it cleaned and took the hiker tarps out.”

“Good news! We haven’t started hiking yet,” I reply.

Evan eyes our damp but clean clothes and says, “Best news I’ve had all day.”

Evan says if we had been fishermen he would have left us to walk. In his experience, the entitled fisherman in the area cause issues, but he likes hikers. Hikers appreciate the local help.

On the drive back to Pacheedaht, I talk with Evan to obtain trail information he knows from talking to backpackers all summer. Evan’s trailhead parking lot has been empty all week, but today it filled up.

When we arrive at Pacheedaht, we pay Evan and leave a good tip for coming out this late at night in the rain to bring us back. We scramble from the van and stumble our way through the narrow dark paths to our dry and waiting tents.

P9170239 1 728x546 As wet and cold as the Pacheedaht campground was, my Above: Nemo Equipment Blaze 2P tent was warm and dry after sitting out in the sustained rain for several hours.

Once I settled into my tent for the night, I am disturbed to find that I’m camped next to a large group of partying surfers. I put in my earplugs and wait several hours for some peace. Not even the pouring rain and ocean waves can drown out a stereo that loud. So much for an early bedtime.

An Early Morning

With dawn, my morning begins and I realize I didn’t plan a breakfast for this morning. I was able to scrounge some plain tortillas and cheese out of my meals. It is not gourmet, but it beats being hungry. I thank my lucky stars; I usually have a few extra bits and bites in my pack for emergencies.

After what I can consider breakfast, I wrap my knee for the tendonitis which has been bugging me all summer. The stiffness wears off when I use the knee, but it aches until it warms up. I pack some extra first aid supplies in case the tendonitis gets worse.

5 P9170223 1Above: I collapse my tent, pack up my gear and take a short walk up the beach. This place is as beautiful as I left it ten years ago; perhaps even more beautiful. Years of experience make me crave the simplicity of this place often. For a decade, this place, these beaches, have been the quiet place my mind’s eye goes to for an anchor.

6 WCT September 2007 82

Above: I hiked here in 2007; it’s been my anchor point in stormy times in my life. During some of the worst times of my life, I have returned to Vancouver Island to refresh my memory of a place which resonated deeply with my soul. Isak Dinesen once said, “The cure for anything is salt water: sweat, tears or the sea.” For me, this remains true, and I usually seek all three in this place. – Photo 2007

And so it Begins…

We shoulder packs and trudge down the road to the West Coast Trail Office in Port Renfrew for registration and orientation. Since this trail has seen many accidents, and fatalities, every hiker is required to attend orientation. Big fines will be incurred if you are caught on the trail without a permit (the permit is also required by every ferryman on the trail). You could try to swim the channels, but I would suggest taking the ferries.

I sit through the orientation and I can only half focus. The weather is almost perfect for this trip. Fortunately, there isn’t any new information that I haven’t already learned through my research and experience here.

My mind is drawn to the location of my injury on my first trip. I sprained my ankle (third-degree sprain) and unknowingly damaged a foot bone and a nerve passage on the first day. I limped myself up the trail for the next five days, in what I call, the best-worst experience of my life. The foot still has nerve damage, and I wear prescription insoles in full trek boots to compensate for this day. The memory causes some angst.

Map of the West Coast Trail

On the trail again…

I show my permit to the ferryman; he’s a friendly but private fellow. I remembered him from my last trip.

7 P9180244

Above: Sea otters sun themselves on the dock; I barely catch a glimpse before the ferryman’s dog chases them into the water.

8 P9180248

Above: The ferryman’s dog is charismatic and makes me wish he could come with me. I know well, the trail is impassible for his kind, but I can’t help but wish for such a stalwart companion.

Up and Away…

The Ferryman ushers us to the other side of Gordon River and then leaves us on the beach and to our own devices at the edge of Port San Juan.

9 P9180254

Above: The Ferryman backs the ferry away from the shore at the Gordon River Trail access point and leaves us with only one option: climb.

10 P9180259

Above: The small beach here has a sign marking the trail and the first of many ladders. Parks Canada information and a welcome from the first nations people, the Huu-ay-ahi, Ditidaht, and Pacheedaht, welcome travelers to the trail. The first nations Trail Guardians repair and build the facilities found on the trail. Without them, the ladders, boardwalks, bridges, and outhouses would be reclaimed and destroyed by winter tides and rainforest in a matter of months.

Hello, Cardiovascular System, aka WCT Ladders

If climbing ladders doesn’t make your heart race, then looking down likely will.

11 P9180258

Above: My hands are shaking as I wait my turn to climb the first ladder of the West Coast Trail.

12 IMG 3874

Above: I taste blood as my heart races, and blood pressure soars. I’m afraid of heights. In 2007, I did all of the ladders on this trail with my eyes closed and never looked down once.

Rules of the Rungs

The rules about the ladders here are simple:

  1. One person on the ladder at a time.
  2. A three-point touch is required on the ladder at all times.
  3. Do not stand directly underneath a ladder.

13 IMG 3879 1

Above: I have a three-point touch on the ladder here, two feet and one hand; the right hand is reaching upwards for the next rung. They are wet, slippery and not frequently maintained. Be cautious; the West Coast Trail is no place for cavalier thinking.

The encroaching rainforest rusts the nails and rots the wood of structures at an alarming rate. Only one person at a time keeps the weight stress on the ladder lower. A three-point touch (moving only one hand or foot at a time while the other three stay anchored on the ladder) ensures the climber can rebalance should a rung come loose. If the climber cannot rebalance and falls off the ladder, no one aside from the climber is injured from the fall as long as no one is standing below.

14 IMG 3875

Above: There is no shortage of ladders, and we have not even reached ladder purgatory at Logan Creek yet.

The First Five

The West Coast Trail has distance markers every one kilometer or so. The five kilometers from Gordon River to Thrashers Cove is the roughest and most rugged on the entire trail. This section can take up to ten hours, depending on the hiker. I am a decently fast hiker, but my trepidation about this section in light of my previous injury here, makes me obsessively watch my foot placement. In case, dear readers, you think I’m overly dramatic, please review this news article titled: How Not to Die on the West Coast Trail. It is that bad.

The trail here is heinously rough – do not underestimate it – especially if you have the misfortune of rain.

15 P9180279

Above: Mud is plentiful on the West Coast Trail. Combine a rainforest with tidal shelf, and a game of “slip sliding away” is bound to follow. Trying to avoid the puddles by walking on their mud-fringed edges usually results in compromised footing anyway – stick to the path.

16 P9180274

Above: Aside from mud, there is also a game of “Snakes and Ladders” climbing the extensive root system of the rainforest floor.

The Law of the Jungle

Rules of engagement for rainforest sections include:

  1. All wood surfaces (including roots, ladders, and platforms) are slippery.
  2. Rocks are most likely loose and slippery.
  3. Avoiding stepping in mud and water puddles is the most likely cause of a fall or injury.

In short, conduct a slip test foot placement before climbing. Don’t save your boots at the expense of soaking your pack or getting an injury. Your footwear will be wet and muddy, slog on through those puddles, fewer falls and injuries will be experienced.

Slogging Upward

The section of trail between Trail Marker 75 and Thrashers Cove is unforgiving and mentally and physically taxing. Everything about this section is technical and frustrating. Each footstep requires intention. This year I have hiked several hundred miles and still, I am struggling with the mental focus this requires. I remembered my travails through this section in 2007 – careless foot placement cost me an injury which has had long-lasting ill effects on my physical well-being.

17 P9180268

Above: The boardwalk-and-ladder terrain is undulating and rugged.

I swore I would never hike this wet, soupy, godforsaken section of the world again (at least for the first five years after 2007!) But here I am, almost wishing I wasn’t here.

18 P9180267

Above: There are sections of the trail which have seen some environmental improvements to prevent erosion and improve safety. 

Born of Blood, Sweat, and Tears

At Marker 72, near the highest elevation on the trail, rests an old donkey engine. It’s a remnant of a bygone era of logging and steam engines; things once moved by the sweat and blood of men and horses.

19 P9180283

Above: The massive engine and steep incline make me think the men that moved this donkey engine were made of iron and steel themselves. I cannot even imagine the hardship it would have been to move the large metal engine. It would be a feat even today.

20 P9180285

Above: The derelict donkey engine was a steam-driven logging force. The work here was hard and rough and shaped a country of tough, hardy people with a will for making a way into the untamed wilderness. My Grandfather ran a sawmill when I was a child. I still love the smell of wood shavings and remember the hot tea and coffee which are a part of what seems an evaporating culture in Canada.

21 P9180286

Above: Something about the history here resonates with me. Curiosity about the people who worked her compels me to explore every angle of the artifact.

22 P9180291

Above: Now near the highest point of the trail and with the donkey engine behind me, I stop for a rest leaning against one of the forests fallen giants.

Homeward Bound

The downward spiral to Thrashers Cove finds the footing wet, slippery and gnarled with the roots of ancient standing giants. Looking up I cannot see the top of the cedars surrounding me here. I feel hemmed into the depths of the forest. Now mid-afternoon, it is humid and claustrophobically warm. I crave an ocean breeze and some cool open air.

23 P9180289

Above: Despite the heat, I still enjoy looking at and finding banana slugs. They come in colors: black, yellow with black spots and brilliant bright yellow. There are slugs bigger than my thumb everywhere in the rainforest. I’ve heard they are edible but they don’t look particularly appetizing to me. I’ve also heard they will make your mouth go numb. Mind your hands on the ladders; you may have the misfortune of squishing one of the poor little things.

24 P9180295 e1498096720105

Above: The heat cannot dampen my enthusiasm. I feel much lighter, knowing that the place I injured my foot on my initial trip is far behind me.

25 P9180296 e1498097274728 1

Above: A trail marker shows I am now five kilometers (3.1 miles) from the trailhead. It only took all day (six hours, give or take.) As a point of reference, earlier in the summer, I hiked 37 kilometers (22 miles) of a rough mountain trail in 14 hours.

A Place My Soul Calls Home

A final hard push down the trail to Thrashers Cove and the rainforest opens to a place that I have craved seeing for almost ten years.

26 P9180300

Above: I haven’t seen Thrashers Cove since my previous trip. For some reason, it was always my favorite. I have heard complaints of Thrashers Cove being crowded. In September, Thrashers Cove is almost empty, and it has a bohemian atmosphere. The other campers are quiet and respectful, and everyone has an optimistic outlook for the rest of the trail.

27 P9180316

Above: Once my feet were firmly on the sand, my interest in dinner, water or any other immediate physical concern disappeared. I settled into quiet solitude until twilight enveloped me and an evening chill settled in.

Once I had lingered on the beach for a time, my companions and I set up tents, filtered water for the next day, made our meals and settled in for the night.

As darkness gathered, one of the hikers from further down the beach ran up. “So that you know, two cougars just crossed the beach by the bear box. They were following a solo hiker who just got in from Camper’s.”

Concern was readable on everyone’s face. I have the utmost respect for bears; they are honest and behaviorally consistent as a bear. Cougars are another matter; cougars are one beast I have no interest in meeting. I am thankful for my friends because cougars are uninterested in people in groups.

In spite of my fear of cougars, the sound of waves lulled me to sleep with morning adequately far off.

On the Trail Again

I woke up feeling refreshed and hearing the sound of rain on my tent fly. Rain this early in the morning does not bode well for my day of tidal shelf crossings, or visibility of the ocean for sea life watching. I wait as long as possible for the rain to stop. As it starts to slow, I bail out of my tent and make some coffee and oatmeal. Not long after breakfast, I shouldered my pack, and we headed down the beach.

My companions and I took the beach route across the tidal shelf. It’s slippery but one of the premier sights on the trail. Bouldering this section was my favorite day of my first trip in ’07. This section is also one of the most dangerous of the entire trail. Rogue waves, impassible headlands, and slick sea-scum-covered footing combined with incoming tides make this one of the most technical portions of the entire trail.

Everything Was Going All Right

After a kilometer of hiking along the beach, the sun was out in full force and the sea breeze was tugging at my strawberry curls. It was a perfect day for crossing the tidal shelf. Each footfall and handhold required a slip test and cautious placement. We climbed over boulders and through ocean gullies. Half the time this shelf is covered by the tide. Starfish, barnacles, urchins, and crabs were everywhere. If I didn’t know the tide would be coming in and covering the shelf, I could have spent hours examining all the little creatures.

All was going well until I slip-tested a gravel bed with my left foot. The footing seemed solid, but as I put my full weight on the gravel, it slipped sideways, dragging my foot and knee out from under me and jamming it underneath a boulder. I felt a sudden pop in my knee and felt excruciating pain. My foot was wedged underneath the boulder and my knee disjointed.

One Way Home or Drown

With a scream and pull with both hands, I popped my knee back in place and dislodged my foot. For a moment the pain stopped and my knee looked normal again.

Perhaps I hadn’t injured myself as badly as it looked?

I placed my weight back on my left leg and blinding pain rushed through my knee and straight to my brain. By the time my friends climbed to me, I knew I couldn’t go forward on the trail. Dread filled me as I realized that I had to go back.

The tide was coming in, and I certainly could not wait here and risk drowning.

Out of Options and Time

I tape, splint and medicate. As I dig through my first aid kit, I question its contents in the context of ultralight philosophy. However, today I have exactly what I need, even for a severe injury.

While one of my friends takes my pack, I use trekking poles as crutches and crawl over boulders on my hands and knees. From time to time, I accidentally put weight back on my knee and let out a blood-curdling scream. Occasionally, someone offers a hand or a shoulder through the gullies to help get me off the shelf before the tide comes in.

As we cross the shelf, we meet two of our fellow beach mates from the night before. I fill out the emergency evacuation card, and they compassionately wish me the best and promise to carry the card to the nearest radio station, two days ahead of them.

On the Run, an Inch at a Time

As my adrenaline wears off, pain is a constant companion. Light-headed and nauseous, but with my iron will intact, I inch along the shelf. In the back of my mind, I want to send my friends on ahead and make sure they are off the shelf before the tide comes in. Even if I asked, they wouldn’t leave me and if situations were reversed, I wouldn’t go on without them either. I always have said, when backpacking, go with people you can trust with your life. I have made a good choice in companions. To me they are heroes and with humility have refused to let me mention them by name. That will not stop me from getting sentimental and calling them out.

A Haven of Safety

Though I am inching along, I can finally see Thrashers Cove. I have seen Thrashers three times, and though I have always been happy to see it, I am overjoyed to see it now.  A haven of safety. Once on the beach, my friends help me get into warm layers, set up a shelter and start a fire before heading into the rainforest to continue without me. They have missed the tide to go back toward the sea caves at Carmanah Point, and I can go no further.

There are several groups of hikers on the beach that will be spending the night. Several backpackers offer to look out for me while I wait for the evacuation crew from Parks Canada. A pair of gentleman heading down to Port Renfrew take my information and promise to get it to the radio station six hours ahead. Others on the beach, bring by chocolate and other hiker treasures and offer condolences. Anyone who has planned this trip knows the idea of not finishing is mildly devastating.

My Favorite Beach

Ironically, the beach I missed the most, is the beach I spend the rest of my day on the West Coast Trail.

28 P9190340

Above: Storms blow overhead, but none decide to stay. I stay warm and dry and wait.

29 P9190346

Above: I am grateful my doctor is an outdoorsman himself, he has been instrumental in giving me ideas of what things should be in my first aid kit. Pain management is crucial at this moment.

30 P9190350

Above: Despite the swelling and pain in my knee, the view is still stunning.

Paramedics are Life Savers

After about five hours of sitting on the beach and enjoying the view, I am a little disappointed to see the Parks Canada Rescue Boat. It didn’t take the medics, Dave and Sebastien, long to find me. Suddenly, I find myself in a rather large crowd.

Dave sends everyone away to talk to me alone while he checks my pain level, and looks at my splinting job. “I couldn’t splint you better myself out here,” Dave laughs, “and what kind of painkillers did you say you had?” My doctor had given me some stronger NSAID’s in case my spinal injury caused trouble during the trip, but they seemed like a good idea on the beach when I was screaming bloody murder and racing the tide.

Dave continues, “I have two casualties on the beach, but I can only take one of you right now. You have the worst injury, (the other is a sprained ankle) but you are the best prepared to be out here if I don’t make it back tonight. The other thing is I think you should be taken by ambulance to Victoria hospital; it takes two hours for them to get to the dock. I’ll take the lady with the sprained ankle first and come back for you as soon as I can. I feel bad, but I think that is the best option for us both.”

And the Wait Continues

Personally, I do not feel bad about it. I have painkillers, a sunny beach, a fire and nowhere I need to be. My knee ligaments are either torn and/or my knee joint has dislocated. I am pretty sure it is torn, but I think I popped it back into the joint back on the shelf. What I know for sure is that my leg cannot bear weight. Left with no other choice, I wait and enjoy my little slice of beach.

31 IMG 3873

Above: Dave and Sebastien return for me in record time.

Dave practically has to carry me off the beach because my leg has gotten so stiff and sore. It is time to go for sure. The circulation is starting to get cut off in my leg but loosening my makeshift splint now is going to be excruciatingly painful. The medics whisk me across the bay in the Parks Canada Rescue boat, and I find two more paramedics (Aspen and William) waiting for me on the other side with a land ambulance.

32 IMG 3868

Above: Once loaded inside and my splint removed, in seconds my knee swells to twice the size it should be.

Aspen advises me to take some anti-nausea medication if I have it. The ride is long and rough. I take her advice and am thankful again for my med kit. Several hours and another ambulance transfer later, I arrive at Victoria General Hospital.

A Night in the Hospital

33 IMG 3871

Above: Alonzo is the nurse in the Emergency Room when I arrive. He makes sure I have a painkiller and that I am as comfortable as possible as I am whisked from the x-ray room to another room while waiting to see a doctor.

Near midnight, a doctor and two nurses arrive in my room. As the doctor examines my x-ray, he explains that my knee is in the right place, but some odd bruising around it looks like it was dislocated. His biggest concern is that my ligaments around my knee are likely torn, and when I get home I should have an MRI, physiotherapy and consult with a surgeon. For now, the doctor sends in the physiotherapist who wraps my knee and sizes me for crutches.

A Unique End to a Unique Journey

Once out of the hospital, I catch a cab to the nearest hotel, book two nights and try to get my bearings.

34 IMG 3870

Above: After spending two days exploring Victoria, British Columbia, Canada on crutches, I find an Owner Direct room and a rental car and spend the remainder of my holiday reading a book, crutching down the beach and visiting friends in Qualicum Bay, British Columbia, Canada.

Finally, I catch my flight from Nanaimo, British Columbia and head back to Alberta. The MRI showed that I have a complex tear in my ACL, but I am off crutches and the knee is strong again. I will be meeting with a surgeon to discuss possible surgery and may make plans to see Thrashers Cove again in the future.

Gear Lists

Group Gear

ItemWeightNotes on Field Use
Nemo Equipment Blaze 2P Tent2 lbs, 5 oz (1.1 kg)product in review
Woods Cypress Kettle9.1 oz (258 g)
First Aid Kit9.9 oz ( 281g)
Repair Kit7.6 oz ( 216 g)
MSR Pocket Rocket2.9 oz (82.2 g)
Silva Ranger Compass2.3 oz (65.2 g)
Parks Canada West Coast Trail Map 20162.3 oz (65.2 g)
SOL Mylar Blanket11.3oz (320g)custom cut for Nemo Equipment Blaze 2P Tent

Individual Gear

ItemWeightNotes on Field Use
Osprey Aura AG 50 L XS3 lbs 13 oz (1.7kg)
Medium Exped Downmat UL 71 lbs 6 oz (623.7 g)
Enlightened Equipment Prodigy 26.50 oz (751.2 g)
Platypus 1.8 Liter Big Zip Hydration System5.4 oz (153.1 g)
Carbon Water Flavour Filter0.1 oz (2.8 g)
2 Mini Carabiners0.3 oz (8.5 g)
Spork0.3 oz (8.5 g)
Black Diamond Spot Headlamp3.3 oz (93.6 g)
Black Diamond Women's Ultra Mountain FL Z-Poles 110 cm9.5 oz (269.3 g)single pole only
not carried
Cactus Creek Nylon 225g Bear Spray Holster1.4 oz (39g)
Tru Flare Bear Banger Launcher1.3 oz (37g)
Frontiersman Bear Spray 1% 225g Canister7.9 oz (225g)consumable
Olympus OM-D E-M5 Mark II16.5 oz (469 g) includes batteries
Olympus M. Zuiko Digital ED 12-40mm f/2.8 PRO Lens13.5 oz (382g)
Joby Gorillapod1.6 oz (45.4 g)

Layers

ItemWeightNotes on Field Use
Woman's Zamberlan Voiz GT Gore-Tex Backpacking Boots and Prescription Insoles3 lbs 4 oz (1.4 kg)not carried
Outdoor Research Women's Verglas Gaiters6.5 oz (184.3 g)not carried
Merino WrightSocks2 oz (56.7 g)not carried
2 Pairs of WrightSocks2.2 oz (62.6 g)
MEC Hydrofoil Rain Pants9.3 oz (263.7 g)
Purple Rain Adventure Skirt4.3 oz (121 g)product in review
not carried
IceBreaker Siren Bikini1.10 oz (31 g)not carried
Seg’ments Merino Wool Base Layer4.8 oz (136.1 g)not carried
Smart Wool Bra2.9 oz (82.2 g)product in review
not carried
Outdoor Research Womens Helium II Jacket5.1 oz (144.5 g)
The NorthFace Thermoball Jacket7.9 oz (224g)
Liner Gloves (synthetic dollar store mini mitts)0.8 oz (22.7 g)
Outdoor Research Kensington Visor Beanie2.4 oz (67 g)
Outdoor Research Echo Ubertube.7 oz (20 g)product in review

Summary

A few weeks after the incident, Parks Canada Paramedic Dave calls me to see how I’m doing. According to Dave, it’s been a tough season on the trail. On top of a trio of rogue cougars stalking hikers and a habituated bear being too friendly at Thrashers Cove; the day Dave and Sebastien rescued me off the beach, there had been nine other evacuations. That’s about 10% of the yearly evacuations in a single day.

Dave tells me he is rescuing unprepared hikers daily. Unfortunately, he thinks it’s a trend. The more popular the trail becomes, the more inexperienced hikers attempt it. Dave tells me my evacuation was shockingly well-equipped and more organized than others this year. Not only did I have the right tools to treat a fairly significant injury, but I had also managed my pain and prevented shock. In Dave’s experience as a rescue medic with Parks Canada, he notes that many hikers are either physically unequipped or mentally unprepared to handle a medical evacuation.

Ultralight hikers can’t afford to be unprepared at the expense of saving weight. Preparation is not only the act of packing a first aid kit but mentally memorizing each item in it, where it is and imagining all its possible uses. Practicing “what if” scenarios can help us mentally and physically prepare for emergencies. Talking to medical professionals, who share outdoor enthusiasm, about useful items in a wilderness first aid kit can make a meaningful difference.

Special Thanks

It’s been more than a year since I set foot on the West Coast Trail. While I do regret tearing my ACL and not putting on my crampons, I do not regret attempting this hike. I also do not regret a single ounce I had in my first aid kit as I used almost all of it. I’m grateful for the Parks Canada Staff, the BC Emergency Medical Team and the marvelous doctors, nurses and staff at Victoria General Hospital. Lastly, I’m grateful for good friends, who wouldn’t leave me behind.

Though I’m half convinced the trail spirit is trying to kill me, I’m currently trying to decide if I will book the West Coast Trail again in 2018.

35 IMG 3869

Synthetic Insulated Jacket Review & State of the Market Report

This comprehensive State of the Market Report presents more than a dozen synthetic insulated jacket reviews and performance comparison to evaluate their durability, warmth, weather resistance, breathability, and features.

You don’t have access to view this content.

Podcast 001 | Synthetic Insulation

In this episode of the Backpacking Light Podcast, Ryan and Andrew take a deep dive into synthetic insulation: its technology, strengths, weaknesses, and applications.

Stream:

Subscribe:

Summary:

  • In this episode of the Backpacking Light Podcast, Ryan and Andrew take a deep dive into synthetic insulation: its technology, strengths, weaknesses, and applications.
    • How is synthetic insulation manufactured?
    • Have recent advances been made in modern synthetic insulation fiber manufacturing?
    • What are the limitations of current manufacturing technologies?
    • How do synthetic fibers compare to down plumules?
    • Why choose synthetic over down?
    • How does moisture absorption into insulation compromise its insulating ability?
    • Is rain (precipitation) really the threat to insulation, or are there other moisture sources to consider?
    • Why should synthetic insulation be considered more seriously by ultralight hikers?
    • Should synthetic insulation be considered by hikers who spend most of their time in dry climates?
    • Are synthetic insulations more sustainable than down from a green manufacturing standpoint?
    • How close is the Patagonia Micro Puff Hoody to a down jacket of similar weight?
    • What’s the difference in compressibility between down and synthetic insulation?
    • What type of gear can benefit from synthetic insulation?
  • Adventurer, alpinist, backpacker, packrafter, ski mountaineer – and pain aficionado – Max Neale joins them to talk about the Synthetic Insulated Jackets State of the Market report recently authored here.
    • Max talks about risk, uncertainty, and suffering and discusses a trip where the suffering was just a little bit too much while attempting a traverse across the world’s largest mountain.
    • When to use synthetic insulated jackets with active insulation vs. more traditional wind-resistant styles.
    • Windproof vs. waterproof vs. highly air-permeable (active insulation) jackets.
    • Fleece + wind shirt vs. active insulation (synthetic) jacket systems.
    • How to interpret CFM values and why they’re important (or not!) – high vs. low CFM jackets for breathability vs. weather resistance.
    • What is Max’s favorite synthetic insulated jacket, and why?
    • Purpose of synthetic insulating jackets: in-camp use vs. sleep system use vs. hiking use.
    • Are cottage brands really able to compete with big brands with more polished designs and more state-of-the-art technology?
    • Continuous filament vs. short-staple insulation – warm when wet? Durability? How do they compare?
    • Is there a perfect insulated jacket that doesn’t yet exist, and what does it look like?
    • Weight, comfort, breathability, durability, degradation – where are we with technology advancement?
    • Debunking #skurkamyths?
    • Let’s talk about synthetic jacket compression durability/degradation confusion.
    • How does sleeping in your jacket impact insulation durability?
    • What’s the go-to “tough” synthetic insulated jacket (durability?)?
    • At what point do you decide that it’s time to retire your synthetic insulated jacket? Is the answer different for low-permeability vs. active insulated jacket? How can we measure it?
    • What types of compression damage synthetic insulated fibers?
    • What are Max’s big plans for 2018?
  • Listener Questions & Tips
    • Is synthetic insulation really warm when wet? Warm when damp, maybe?!
      • Is synthetic insulation loft maintained when small amounts of moisture enter it?
      • What about wearing wet insulating clothing to bed? And what about inside a down quilt? Ack!
      • The problem with compressing a damp sleeping bag/quilt.
    • With the advent of water-resistant down tech, are the advantages of synthetic insulation negated?
      • Description of the down-proof tech.
      • Does it really work? Is it a scam?
      • Where does it work?
    • What’s the best synthetic fiber insulation for moisture transport?
      • The answer lies in the batt construction and batt integration with the overall garment.
    • Why and how to use a synthetic quilt layered over a down quilt/bag for optimal moisture management in inclement/cold conditions – how to use a 2-layered, 22-oz down/synthetic quilt system for an indefinitely long trek in inclement conditions. How about a thru-hike?
  • Featured Gear
    • TarpTent Notch Lithium
      • Silnylon vs. DCF (“Cuben Fiber”)
        • Durability?
        • Declining temperature stretch?
        • Performance:weight?
        • Condensation resistance?
      • “Big Pad / Big Fella” suitability?
      • Usability: how Ryan uses two doors/two vestibules
      • Wind resistance experience (sand / wind) by Ryan in Canyonlands NP
      • The overlapping door issue in high winds – Velcro closures – sufficient?
      • Next up: severe winds! Silnylon vs. DCF versions / condensation resistance! Long term durability / expedition usability.
  • Here and Now
    • Ryan is planning another trek in the Idaho Wilderness – with *little kids* and *way off trail!*.
    • Andrew is researching his upcoming BPL story on the Organ Mountains-Desert Peaks National Monument – fatbiking, craters, community support – *huuuge* topographic relief (! ;) – petroglyphs and archeology!
  • BPL News!
    • Our editorial & events calendar.
      • Instructional skills webinar series.
      • Wilderness Treks courses – guides & summer courses in Montana wilderness!
      • 2018 Film Festival info/submissions! (+ 2017 youtube replay!)
    • Website updates!
  • Podcast
    • Who sponsors this – full disclosure!

Mentioned in this Show

Feedback, Questions, Tips?

Credits:

  • Backpacking Light – Executive Producer
  • Ryan Jordan – Director and Host
  • Andrew Marshall – Producer and Host
  • Max Neale – Guest Interview
  • Look for Me in the Mountains – Music

Sponsors:

  • This episode of the Backpacking Light Podcast is supported and kept advertising-free by Backpacking Light membership fees. Please consider becoming a member which helps support projects like this podcast, in addition to a whole slew of other benefits!

Contact:

You can contact us at podcast@backpackinglight.com, or follow us on social media –

Patagonia Micro Puff Hoody Review

Our Patagonia Micro Puff Hoody Review features one of the highest-performing synthetic jackets we’ve ever evaluated. It’s performance- and feature-to-weight ratio is extremely high and should be a top pick considered for ultralight backpacking.

You don’t have access to view this content.

Nunatak Skaha Apex Review

The Nunatak Skaha Apex is our highest rated windproof synthetic insulated jacket. Even though the jacket costs less than its closest competitors, it is custom-made in Utah. We highly recommend the Skaha Apex to anyone who wants the either the best fitting jacket or the highest warmth to weight ratio.

You don’t have access to view this content.

Patagonia DAS Parka Review

The Patagonia DAS is our highest rated synthetic insulated winter-weight parka. Frequent revisions have created a stunningly effective jacket for expeditions that cross multiple climates and for overnight alpine climbs and backcountry trips where a wet down parka would force you to bail, or worse.  Despite a suite of expedition features, the premium insulation and light fabrics keep the DAS lightweight at only 22 oz. in men’s medium. This parka performs so well and is offered at such a reasonable price that we feel it’s the only warm synthetic insulated parka worth buying.

The DAS was replaced by the HyperPuff in 2017

Patagonia discontinued the DAS parka in 2017. They worked with a supplier to develop a new proprietary insulation, HyperDAS, that is warmer for its weight and more durable than the two Primaloft insulations used in the DAS parka. The new jacket is called the HyperPuff.

We chose not to test the HyperPuff because three believable people (Colin Haley, Patagonia Ambassador; Casey Shaw, manager of advanced research and development; and Walker Furgeson, field testing manager) told us that the old DAS has (had) a higher warmth to weight ratio than the HyperPuff. The HyperPuff, however is more durable than the DAS. What happened was: a variety of small tweaks to the insulation, fabrics, and construction resulted in a jacket that was heavier than the prototypes. Colin still has a prototype and loves it.

That said, the HyperPuff continues to evolve and in its current (2018) iteration, its weight is now less than 19 oz and is lighter than the original DAS. Unfortunately, this version of the HyperPuff was not yet available when this review was conducted.

As we describe in our original DAS review below, we have found very few occasions to own a traditional synthetic insulated parka that weighs more than a pound. In most cases, a superior combination is an active insulation jacket paired with a lightweight windproof synthetic insulated jacket. (Our two highest rated active insulation jackets are the Patagonia Nano Air Light (for when every ounce counts) and the Arcteryx Proton LT Hoody (more versatile and more durable).)

If you’re interested in a toasty warm synthetic insulated parka with the highest warmth to weight ratio, we recommend the Nunatak Skaha Apex with 5.0 oz/yd (142g/m) insulation, and if you’re looking to save as much weight as possible while retaining a fully featured jacket with a full zipper, large handwarmer pockets, and large interior stash pockets, consider the Patagonia Micro Puff Hoody.

Which is warmest? Answer: right to left. 9.9 Nunatak Skaha Apex, 9.3 oz Patagonia Micro Puff, 9.9 oz Arcteryx Nuclei FL.

 

Three of our highest rated synthetic insulated jackets. From warmest to coldest (left to right): Nunatak Skaha Apex (281g), Arcteryx Proton LT Hoody (408g), Patagonia Nano Air Light (295g)

Introduction

The Patagonia DAS is our highest rated synthetic insulated parka. Frequent revisions have created a stunningly effective jacket for expeditions that cross multiple climates and for overnight alpine climbs and backcountry trips where a wet down parka would force you to bail, or worse.  Despite a suite of expedition features, the premium insulation and light fabrics keep the DAS lightweight at only 22 oz. in men’s medium. This parka performs so well and is offered at such a reasonable price that we feel it’s the only highly-insulated synthetic parka worth buying.

As we describe in detail below, synthetic insulated parkas (as opposed to less-insulated hooded jackets more suitable for layering or temperate weather) are only ideal for a small portion of winter activities. For the vast majority of multi-day trips, and almost all day trips, a down parka offers superior performance and is a better long-term value. However, if you do a lot of expeditions and/or committing alpine routes, we highly recommend the DAS.

The only synthetic parka we know of that’s better than the DAS is the $625 Arcteryx Dually Belay Parka, which is warmer and more durable (due to its 100% continuous filament insulation that’s laminated to the face fabric for added stability). Max used the Dually in 2014 and 2015. He also met with its designers and toured Arcteryx’s North Vancouver factory, where the parka is made. As much as we respect the Dually, we excluded it from this comparative evaluation because we feel its increased performance is not commensurate with the 2x+ price compared to the DAS!

Features

  • Uses a combination of durable continuous filament insulation and high warmth to weight ratio short staple insulation
  • Two interior drop-in pockets, two handwarmer pockets, and a chest pocket
  • Huge, helmet compatible hood
  • Excellent lightweight fabrics

 Specifications and Performance Scores

 

Field Testing

Luc used the DAS for a 150-mile ski and skate trip and a month-long ski mountaineering trip. After we finished testing, he bought a DAS for his annual Alaska ski mountaineering expeditions that dip from wet valleys to frigid, high elevation peaks. Max has used several versions of the DAS in the past. He took this version on a two-week climb-ski-packraft trip and for a handful of climbing and skiing day trips.

Is it Worth Buying a Synthetic Insulated Parka?

You can’t go wrong with a synthetic parka, but using it as your primary parka will cost a lot more than owning both down and synthetic and using the synthetic only when needed.

The three most important factors to consider when choosing between a down and synthetic parka are: humidity, trip duration, and sleep setup. Down parkas are best for nearly all day trips because they’re more durable and can dry out at night. Increasing trip duration and humidity increases the probability of needing synthetic insulation. Similarly, sleeping in a confined, poorly ventilated bivy tent for five days or making an unplanned, exposed bivy might warrant synthetic insulation. Expeditions that cross multiple climates, i.e. travel through rainy valleys and up to frigid, high peaks are one of the few times when a synthetic parka is definitely the best choice.

We spent at least a month on multi-day trips (backpacking, alpine climbing, skiing, etc.) testing down and synthetic parkas side-by-side. Though the synthetic insulation was nice for cooking dinner outside in a storm and when a water bottle leaked a little inside a drop-in pocket, we never encountered a situation when it was necessary
We spent at least a month on multi-day trips (backpacking, alpine climbing, skiing, etc.) testing down and synthetic parkas side-by-side. Though the synthetic insulation was nice for cooking dinner outside in a storm and when a water bottle leaked a little inside a drop-in pocket, we never encountered a situation when it was necessary.

When is a Synthetic Parka Best for Climbing?

Patagonia built the DAS as a belay parka. However, both Max and his friend Chris (Chris previously led synthetic parka testing for another outdoor media publisher), both moderately experienced alpinists, almost never use a synthetic parka for technical climbing. Why not? Because down performs better for the vast majority of routes.

We see a lot of climbers and mountaineers wearing synthetic parkas when they’d be better served by the long-term value of a down insulation. For most climbers, we don’t think it’s worth buying a synthetic parka. The nature of climbing has changed significantly over the past couple of decades such that the probability of a parka becoming harmfully wet is vastly less. This is due to much lighter gear, heaps of pre-climb information, lightweight satellite communication devices, and better access. In most cases and places, people wait for a weather window and launch with a down parka.

We asked Colin Haley, a Patagonia Ambassador and cutting-edge alpinist, when he uses a synthetic parka. He said,

Whether I bring a down parka or a synthetic parka is dependent mostly on climate. Some places are simply much more humid than others. For example, March in the Cascades is much more humid than October in Nepal, so I’m more likely to carry a synthetic parka. Sometimes there can be a noticeable climatic difference across a very small distance. For example, in Patagonia, I always use synthetic parkas when climbing on the Torres (which are right against the South Patagonian Icecap) and down parkas when climbing in the ChaltĂŠn (Fitz Roy) Group, which is only a few kilometers further east, but much drier.

The DAS works fine in high alpine environments, where precipitation comes only as snow, but our tests show that the higher warmth to weight ratio and vastly better long-term durability of down parkas makes them a smarter choice there. In addition to the good selection of more weather resistant down parkas (Rab Neutrino Endurance, Feathered Friends Volant, Western Mountaineering Snojack, Crux Magma, etc.), we’re seeing a trend toward increasing down parka water resistance. Patagonia’s Grade VII Parka has welded baffles in key areas and Arcteryx’s Firebee AR parka uses a fully seam-taped Gore Thermium (more water resistant than Windstopper) fabric. We recommend a down parka with a durable, water-resistant fabric for all day trips and most multi-day trips in winter.

Luc Mehl (right) used the DAS as his only insulating layer, and didn’t bring a tent or sleeping bag, on the 2016 Alaska Wilderness Classic adventure race.

Performance Evaluation

Warmth

Patagonia aced the warmth to weight balance in the DAS. It uses 4.23 oz. (120g) PrimaLoft Silver Hi-Loft insulation and has an additional layer of 2.12 oz. (60g) PrimaLoft Gold in the torso. This is a smart combination that provides both durability (due to the continuous filament Hi-Loft) and good performance when wet (according to Primaloft, Gold’s wet clo value is 0.9 oz/yd while Hi-Loft’s is 0.6 oz.yd). The tiny fibers of Primaloft Gold also give the parka a soft, smooth hand.

With very warm mid layers underneath, the DAS is warm enough for a late June or July ascent of Denali. Down parkas, of course, work better on that mountain but the point is: this parka is pretty darn warm. Luc and Sarah compared the DAS and Patagonia’s Fitz Roy (down parka) on a week-long Nordic skating trip in Alaska’s Yukon Delta and found the DAS to be warmer. (The Fitz Roy doesn’t have enough down in the arms). Max and Eric compared the DAS and the Feathered Friends Hooded Helios on a 13-day climbing-ski mountaineering-packrafting trip in the Alaska Range and also found the DAS to be warmer. (Even after being extended an inch in 2014, the Hooded Helios is significantly shorter than the DAS; lacks a waist drawcord and has no interior drop-in pockets). Thus, we’re confident the DAS is warmer than most 18 oz. (510.29 g) down parkas. It is not as warm as down parkas that weigh a bit more than the DAS; we’ve found the Feathered Friends Volant (through extensive use) and Western Mountaineering Snojack (through trying it on once) to be warmer. We also expect the forthcoming Firebee AR and Grade VII to be warmer than the DAS.

The Montane Spitfire One, which weighs a whopping 31.4 oz. (890.18 g), is the warmest synthetic parka we tested in this review series.

Max, shaken up in the Patagonia DAS parka, after being hit in the face with chunk of ice. Shaken, not Stirred, Moose's Tooth, Alaska Range.
Max, shaken up in the Patagonia DAS parka, after being hit in the face with chunk of ice.  Shaken, not Stirred, Moose’s Tooth, Alaska Range.

Weather Resistance

The DAS has a 1.2 oz. (34.02 g) 20-denier Pertex Endurance PU coated ripstop nylon shell. This is sufficient for resisting light moisture. Primarily because it keeps the parka in the appropriate weight class, we think it’s a great fabric choice.

The Arcteryx Nuclei AR and Kappa Hoody use seam-taped Gore Thermium fabrics that are significantly more water resistant, and also warmer because the fabric traps a lot of air. The Montbell Thermawrap Guide’s fabric is also more water resistant than the DAS. It would be amazing, and considerably more expensive if Patagonia built the DAS with a lightweight seam-taped Gore Thermium fabric.

Breathability

The DAS is not intended to be highly breathable.

Sarah Histand in the Patagonia DAS, Yukon Delta, Alaska.
Sarah Histand in the Patagonia DAS, Yukon Delta, Alaska. Photo: Luc Mehl.

Durability

Patagonia sacrifices some durability by using a 60g layer of Primaloft Gold insulation over the 120g layer of Silver Hi-Loft. This very fine microfiber insulation makes the jacket feel soft to the touch, increases its warmth when wet, and slightly increases the overall warmth to weight ratio. Unfortunately, it also significantly decreases durability. Over the long-term, the DAS would retain more loft if it were made exclusively from a continuous filament insulation.

Previous versions of the DAS had extra tough fabric on the arms and shoulders. We’re glad Patagonia did away with this. Our testing shows that most synthetic insulations degrade faster than their enclosing fabrics when used for multi-day, frequent compression activities. Thus, there’s no need for a tough fabric on the DAS. (We do, however, prefer tougher fabrics on high wear areas of down parkas because their insulation lasts much longer.) If you rip the DAS fabric, just cover it with some repair tape. No big deal.

Comfort

We give the DAS 10 out of 10 points here because Patagonia did a splendid job with all of its features. Unlike the Arcteryx Kappa, the chest pocket is well insulated. The handwarmer pockets are well-insulated. The interior drop-in pockets are huge and set high, so they don’t sag beyond the hem when loaded with goodies and are made of stretchy mesh that allows you to see what’s in them. The hood is big and provides a lot of coverage for the neck and chin. The length is long enough to cover your butt. The two-way zipper lets you unzip to better use a belay device. Fantastic work, Patagonia.

Note for people with excessively long arms: The DAS’ sleeves may not be long enough for you. Max (6’1” with a +2” ape index) found them about 2” too short. Consider sizing up or going with a different brand if your arms are longer than Max’s. (Max didn’t find the length to be problematic because glove and mitten gauntlets covered the small gap between the hand and the sleeve).

All of the DAS features, including the two interior drop-in pockets, are very well designed.
All of the DAS features, including the two interior drop-in pockets, are very well designed. Here, one pocket holds gloves and the other a DIY insulated water bottle parka (tyvek + climashield apex).

Weight

Our men’s medium weighs 22.0 oz. (623 g).  This is surprisingly light for how warm the parka is. The included stuff sack, which we rarely use, weighs 0.2 oz. (5.6 g).

Summary: Patagonia DAS Parka Review

Strengths

  • Highest warmth to weight ratio of all synthetic insulated parkas
  • Excellent design, construction, and materials – our highest rated synthetic insulated parka

Limitations

  • Parkas made exclusively with continuous filament insulations, e.g. Arcteryx Dually Belay and Black Diamond Stance Belay, are more durable. However, the DAS is half the cost of the Dually and significantly better than the Stance Belay; the DAS receives our highest recommendation.

Recommended Uses

  • Expeditions that cross multiple climates
  • Humid multi-day trips
  • Longer duration (3+ day) alpine climbs
  • Anything with a high probabilty of an unplanned bivy in bad weather

Compared To

At $300 retail, and available for 40% off at Patagonia’s bi-annual sales, the DAS is a very good value. It’s at least twice as warm as their $300 Nano Air Hoody.

 

DSC00705_Andrew_Holman_Photography-2
Max Neale carrying the Patagonia DAS parka, Valdez, Alaska. Photo: Andrew Holman

Related Content

This review is part of a comprehensive State of the Market survey of synthetic insulated jackets that has been ongoing for the past two years. Included in this survey:

Disclosure

The manufacturer provided a sample of this product to the author with no agreement, requirement, or obligation for media coverage of any kind. Some links are affiliate links, which means if you click through and make a purchase, Backpacking Light gets a small commission on the sale. This comes at no extra cost to you and helps support Backpacking Light’s efforts to publish authoritative and valuable information about lightweight backpacking gear and techniques, inspiring stories and film festivals, and remain an active member of the outdoor industry to promote and protect opportunities for public outdoor recreation.

Arcteryx Nuclei FL Jacket Review

Arcteryx Nuclei FL Jacket Review: one of the best lightweight windproof synthetic insulated jackets on the planet. It weighs a mere 9.9 ounces.

Introduction

In this Arcteryx Nuclei FL Jacket Review, we highly recommend the Nuclei FL for wet weather backpacking and overnight alpine rock climbing when there’s a good chance the jacket will accidentally or unavoidably get wet.

This was our highest rated lightweight windproof synthetic insulated jacket in our Spring 2016 comparative tests. However, Arcteryx discontinued the Nuclei FL in 2017 and several other manufacturers have since released superior products. We left our original review unchanged below in case you find this jacket on sale.

This Arc’teryx Nuclei FL Jacket review features the best lightweight synthetic insulated jacket we’ve tested. It weighs a mere 9.9 oz. (281g) in men’s medium, packs down to the size of an orange, and has a suite of refined features that make it our top choice for backpacking and three-season climbing. It also works well as a mid layer in frigid temperatures. We much prefer the Nuclei FL to the Rab Xenon X, the longstanding champion in this class, because it’s 20% lighter, similarly warm, has an adjustable hood that’s more comfortable for use with and without a helmet, has higher handwarmer pockets that lie above a hipbelt, and the waist drawcord tucks up and away from a harness. The Nuclei FL is a shining example of minimalist design. It wins our highest recommendation for an all-purpose lightweight synthetic insulated jacket.

Features

  • Highest warmth to weight ratio of all lightweight jackets tested
  • Packs to size of an orange
  • Doubles as a mid-layer in frigid temperatures
  • Adjustable hood is comfortable with and without a helmet
  • Handwarmer pockets lie above the hipbelt

Performance Evaluation for the Arcteryx Nuclei FL Jacket Review

A lightweight synthetic jacket, such as the Arcteryx Nuclei FL, is ideal for most three-season conditions.
A lightweight windproof synthetic insulated jacket is great for wilderness travel in three-season conditions.

 

Arc'teryx Nuclei FL Jacket Review: Max in the Chugach mountains, AK.
Winter hiking in the Arc’teryx Nuclei FL. The jacket can be worn when for active use in colder temperatures.

Warmth

The Nuclei FL has 2.82 oz.(80g) of Coreloft insulation in the body and 2.12 oz.(60g) in the side panels and sleeves. Most lightweight jackets, including the Xenon, use 60g insulation throughout. Though this might lead one to believe the Nuclei is wholly warmer than 60g jackets, we found the Xenon’s arms to be slightly warmer than the Nuclei’s. Overall, we rate these jackets equivalent in warmth.

Unfortunately, the industry lacks a standardized method for measuring CLO values and some manufacturers don’t release their internal test results. Thus, unlike down, we don’t have reliable lab data to evaluate insulation performance. In our field tests, we found Coreloft to be slightly less warm for its weight compared to Primaloft Gold. Perhaps by 10%?

We spent at least a month on multi-day trips (backpacking, alpine climbing, skiing, etc.) testing down and synthetic parkas side-by-side. Though the synthetic insulation was nice for cooking dinner outside in a storm and when a water bottle leaked a little inside a drop-in pocket, we never encountered a situation when it was necessary
Max and Eric wait under a tarp for a storm to clear so they can travel down Backside Glacier in the Alaska Range. Max used the Nuclei FL (blue) in order to test it more. Active insulation jackets, however, are more breathable and perform better for variable winter conditions.

Weather Resistance

The Nuclei FL’s fabric does not have a water resistant PU coating or membrane such as Gore Windstopper. As with all similar fabrics, water saturates it quickly once the DWR coating wears off. Unlike highly breathable synthetic insulated jackets, the Nuclei FL’s fabrics are windproof. Thus, the jacket is great for stop-and-go activities like hiking and climbing, where you carry a waterproof shell that can go over the jacket if necessary.

Max scrambling in the Arcteryx Nuclei FL
Scrambling in the Arc’teryx Nuclei FL
Max in the Nuclei FL during a failed attempt to traverse the perpetually wet Baranof Island, Alaska.

Breathability

The Nuclei FL is only breathable enough for use as an active mid layer if it’s very cold. For example, Mark and Janelle Smiley used it as an outer layer and under a hardshell for their successful third attempt of Denali’s Cassin Ridge.

Mark speaks highly of the Nuclei FL: “We were sponsored by Rab in 2012 and the Xenon was my favorite piece of theirs. The Nuclei is so much better. It’s the piece I have on or in the pack year round.”

Janelle says, “It is perfect, I don’t own fleece anymore because of its warmth and versatility. I have not worn it while ski touring in the Tetons, just at breaks or on the descent, or when a storm rolls in. I did wear it a bunch on the Cassin and on Middle Triple, and almost the whole climb of the North Face of Edith Cavell in October, so it works great in cold climates.”

The Smiley’s experience also supports our finding that the Nuclei FL is best for active use in cold weather. In most cases, and with most bodies, active insulation jackets like the Patagonia Nano Air Hoody and Arc’teryx Proton LT Hoody perform better in winter and are more versatile as midlayers. Ultimately, it comes down to how much heat you generate (some people are a lot sweatier than others) and what you’re doing (walking fast on a trail generates less heat than climbing a vertical face).

Durability

Fabric

This jacket uses an ultralight 10D fabric that is not as tough as the Rab Xenon X’s 20D fabric. This is a good thing. We strongly believe that a very light fabric is the best type for the amount of insulation in a lightweight jacket like this. Here’s why: In testing other similar jackets for the long-term, primarily the original Rab Xenon (10D Pertex Quantum GL fabric), we found that the insulation wore out faster than the fabric. If the Nuclei FL’s fabric tears, wipe the area with alcohol and stick on some Tyvek tape. No big deal.

Insulation

We don’t know if the Nuclei’s Coreloft is more durable than Primaloft Gold. Thicker fibers usually last longer than superfine fibers. Coreloft combines 1 and 3 denier fibers and Primaloft Gold might combine 0.5 denier and 4 denier fibers. (Primaloft won’t disclose the exact fiber size. They say their fibers are typically about 98% smaller than the diameter of a human hair.) The reality is that all highly compressible short staple synthetic insulations breakdown quickly. Try to use a synthetic insulated jacket only when you actually need their moisture management properties.

A continuous filament insulation would be more durable than Coreloft. Unfortunately, at the time of writing, we don’t know of any lightweight windproof jackets with continuous filament insulation. Both ZPacks and As Tucas say they intend to make one in the future.

Max celebrating his escape from ski boots.
Max celebrating his escape from ski boots.

Comfort

The Nuclei FL has a trim, athletic cut. The same size Rab Xenon X is boxy and bulky and is a better choice for wearing lots of layers underneath or perhaps for people with stockier builds (you could also size up with the Nuclei FL).

Arc’teryx did a fantastic job with the Nuclei FL’s features. In comparison to the Rab Xenon, the hood (adjustable with one cinch at the rear) is far more comfortable with or without a helmet, the handwarmer pockets are set above a pack’s hipbelt instead of low by the waist, the waist drawcord stows inside the jacket so you don’t accidentally clip it when climbing with a harness (instead of the Xenon’s two easily clippable drawcord loops). Though these are minor features, they add up to a significantly more comfortable jacket. The Xenon’s only comfort advantage is its exterior chest pocket, which we very much appreciate, but would not trade for the Nuclei’s features.

Weight and Compressibility

The Nuclei FL is the lightest and most compact synthetic insulated jacket we tested. It weighs 9.9 oz. on our scale. This is extremely light–20% lighter than the Rab Xenon and LLBean Primaloft Packaway.

The Nuclei FL stuffs into an included sack with a clippable loop. We prefer this to the pocket-turn-stuff sack that the Xenon and many other jackets use because the dedicated stuff sack is much smaller and takes up less room on your harness. We’ve also found that, unless you’re always patient and careful, the zippers on pocket stuff sacks can catch and tear fabrics.

Size in their included stuff sacks, left to right: Patagonia DAS, Arcteryx Nuclei AR, Rab Xenon, LLBean Primaloft Packaway Hoodie, arcteryx Nuclei FL
Size in their included stuff sacks, left to right: Patagonia DAS, Arc’teryx Nuclei AR, Rab Xenon, LLBean Primaloft Packaway Hoodie, Arc’teryx Nuclei FL

Value

At $239 retail, this is a good value if you do a lot of wet weather backpacking or overnight alpine rock climbing and highly value the 2.4 oz. weight savings compared to its closest competitors.

The $159, 12.3 oz., LLBean Primaloft Packaway Hooded Jacket is the best value lightweight synthetic insulated jacket we know of.

We’d be remiss to not mention that down jackets are a vastly superior long-term value because they’re warmer for their weight and are many times more durable.

Performance Highlights

Hiking: This is our favorite synthetic insulated jacket for mild to moderately wet backpacking in warmer temperatures, where we occasionally wear it under a rain jacket. For soaking wet and colder (less than 50F) conditions, a high-loft hooded fleece performs better because it’s warmer when wet, more breathable, more comfortable when soaked, and dries faster.

Climbing: The Nuclei FL excels at warmer weather alpine and big wall rock climbing when there’s a decent chance of precipitation or when precipitation would force you to bail if a down jacket got wet.

Aerobic activities: This jacket and those similar to it are a poor choice for most highly active pursuits because the fabrics are insufficiently breathable. Windproof jackets work well when you’re moving, and it’s frigid. Some people that don’t sweat much can wear them when charging hard. But not many. Max soaked the jacket with sweat when ski touring. Luc found it far too warm. Fleece and active insulation jackets are ideal for use as a mid-layer for aerobic pursuits in cold conditions.

Summary: Arcteryx Nuclei FL Jacket Review

Strengths

  • Highest warmth to weight ratio of all lightweight synthetic insulated jackets
  • Most versatile type of synthetic insulated jacket

Limitations

  • Active insulated jackets are more breathable and perform better as mid layers in winter
  • The short staple insulation is relatively fragile. However, we don’t know any company that makes a similar jacket with continuous filament insulation. We expect Arcteryx to update the Nuclei FL with their Coreloft Continuous in the next year or two, which will increase durability.

Recommended Uses

  • All types of multi-day three-season trips
  • As a mid layer in frigid temperatures (but active insulation jackets generally perform better in winter)

Market Comparison

A comprehensive Synthetic Insulated Jacket State of the Market Report will be released on March 25, 2018. When that report is published, we’ll update this review with a comparison summary of this product with other notable products in the review.

Related Content

This review is part of a comprehensive State of the Market survey of synthetic insulated jackets that has been ongoing for the past two years. Included in this survey:

Disclosure

The manufacturer provided a sample of this product to the author with no agreement, requirement, or obligation for media coverage of any kind. Some links are affiliate links, which means if you click through and make a purchase, Backpacking Light gets a small commission on the sale. This comes at no extra cost to you and helps support Backpacking Light’s efforts to publish authoritative and valuable information about lightweight backpacking gear and techniques, inspiring stories and film festivals, and remain an active member of the outdoor industry to promote and protect opportunities for public outdoor recreation.

Black Diamond Heat Treat Hoody Review

Our Black Diamond Heat Treat Hoody Review determined that the jacket is an all-purpose winter jacket for around town and some winter sports.

This jacket has been discontinued

Black Diamond discontinued this jacket. We’ve left our original review unchanged below in case you find this jacket on sale. In addition, we hope the information provided here is useful in the context of today’s broad offering of synthetic insulated jackets.

UPDATE: As of March 2018, this jacket can be found in inventory and on sale up to 50% off at Amazon, Moosejaw, and Outdoor Gear Exchange. At 25-50% off, it could be a very good buy for an all-purpose winter insulated jacket.

Review Rating – Average

The Heat Treat is an all-purpose winter jacket for around town and some winter sports. It is a midweight winter parka with a durable fabric. Due to the lower warmth to weight ratio, the jacket is better suited to resort skiing than lightweight climbing and backcountry applications. We have two other small complaints about its design: (1) the hood’s ineffective closure lets in lots of cold air around the sides of the face; and (2) in order to provide a unique look, the main zipper’s interlocking area is half that of standard parka zippers. This bothered Max when he first used BD apparel in summer 2013, but it wasn’t until winter 2014 that his Stance Belay Parka zipper broke (by the neck, where the zipper curves). Though the Heat Treat’s zipper didn’t break during our test period, and one person in BD’s warranty department said they don’t see this often, we wish BD would use standard issue, tough zippers.

The Heat Treat’s main competitor is the $400 Arcteryx Kappa Hoody, which uses even more durable 70D and 80D Windstopper fabrics, has more insulation, and better features such as a four-point adjustable hood, a chest pocket, and two larger drop-in stash pockets. The $300 Patagonia DAS is our favorite synthetic insulated parka.

Performance Evaluation of the Black Diamond Heat Treat Hoody Review

Warmth

Max used this for a five-day January backpacking trip in Utah canyon country (temperatures in the upper teens) and would have been happier with a warmer jacket. The vast majority of the Heat Treat’s weight comes from the fabric. We don’t recommend this jacket for overnight trips or activities that benefit from a high warmth to weight ratio. As we mentioned earlier, the hood is ineffective at sealing the face area. Luc removed this jacket from consideration based on this reason alone.

Max in the Black Diamond Heat Treat Hoody, Escalante, UT. Note how the hood closes doesn't close completely around the face.
Max in the Black Diamond Heat Treat Hoody, Escalante, UT. Note how the hood doesn’t close completely around the face.

Weather Resistance

We love Windstopper! Unlike the other Windstopper jackets tested here, the Heat Treat will not be updated for fall 2016 with a Gore Thermium membrane. Using Thermium would increase the weather resistance by taping the seams, which would boost performance for most winter activities. Even so, the existing design provides ample weather resistance for most applications.

Breathability

Less insulation facilitates use for mobile, aerobic applications in very cold weather. But this is not a highly breathable jacket. Our favorite highly breathable jacket currently on the market is the Patagonia Nano Air Hoody. BD will be releasing a similar model, the First Light Hoody, this fall.

Black Diamond Heat Treat Hoody on a January backpacking trip in Capitol Reef National Park, Utah.
Black Diamond Heat Treat Hoody on a January backpacking trip in Capitol Reef National Park, Utah.

Durability

The Heat Treat uses a 50D fabric that’s likely many times (it hard to quantify this without a lab) more durable than the sub 14 oz. (397g) jackets we tested. For this reason, we recommend the Heat Treat primarily for day trips and specifically for resort skiing, where daily use requires little compression (unlike climbing and overnight backcountry trips where the jacket is largely used at rest) and puts lots of wear on the fabric (because it’s used in motion).

As we mentioned above, the Heat Treat’s zipper prioritizes aesthetics over durability. Though we didn’t break the zipper during our test period, the identical zipper on Max’s Stance Belay Parka broke in 2015. The photo below shows it’s half as thick as the standard parka zipper.

Many of Black Diamond's zippers sacrifice durability for aesthetics. The top zipper (Black Diamond Heat Treat) is half as thick as the standard parka zipper, below (Arcteryx Kappa).
Many of Black Diamond’s zippers sacrifice durability for aesthetics. The top zipper (Black Diamond Heat Treat) is half as thick as the standard parka zipper, below (Arcteryx Kappa).

Comfort

We mentioned the hood already. Black Diamond could improve the handwarmer pockets by moving them higher up, so they’re not covered by a backpack’s hip belt. There’s also a fleece lining against the chin area that’s detrimental in winter because moisture from your breath can turn the fleece into an uncomfortable, icy sheet. (For this reason, very few winter parkas, down or synthetic, have this feature).

Black Diamond Heat Treat drop-in pocket. Placig the pocket even higher up, like most other brands do, prevents heavy items from sagging out the bottom. This illustrates the problem poorly because the water bottle is empty.
Black Diamond Heat Treat drop-in pocket. Placing the pocket even higher up, like most other brands do, prevents heavy items from sagging out the bottom. This illustrates the problem poorly because the water bottle is empty.

 

Black Diamond Heat Treat Hoody in Nebraska.
The Black Diamond Heat Treat Hoody’s tough face fabric makes it a great choice for abrasive activities like carrying dogs. Again, note the ill-fitting hood. Nebraska in December.

Weight

20.4 oz. (578.33g) is heavy for overnight trips. The much warmer Patagonia DAS weighs 22 oz. (623.69g) but is too warm to serve as a versatile resort skiing jacket.

Summary: Black Diamond Heat Treat Hoody Review

Strengths

  • Durable fabric and insulation

Limitations

  • Low warmth to weight ratio
  • Poorly fitting hood

Recommended Uses

The Heat Treat Hoody performs poorly for overnight backcountry trips but might be great for resort skiing.

Market Comparison

A comprehensive Synthetic Insulated Jacket State of the Market Report will be released on March 25, 2018. When that report is published, we’ll update this review with a comparison summary of this product with other notable products in the review.

Related Content

This review is part of a comprehensive State of the Market survey of synthetic insulated jackets that has been ongoing for the past two years. Included in this survey:

Disclosure

The manufacturer provided a sample of this product to the author with no agreement, requirement, or obligation for media coverage of any kind.  Some links are affiliate links, which means if you click through and make a purchase, Backpacking Light gets a small commission on the sale. This comes at no extra cost to you and helps support Backpacking Light’s efforts to publish authoritative and valuable information about lightweight backpacking gear and techniques, inspiring stories and film festivals, and remain an active member of the outdoor industry to promote and protect opportunities for public outdoor recreation.

Outdoor Research Uberlayer Review

This Outdoor Research Uberlayer Review features an active insulation jacket that weighs about four ounces more than similar jackets but does not make up for the extra weight with added comfort, durability, warmth, or lower cost. The Uberlayer performed reasonably well in our tests.

You don’t have access to view this content.

Rab Xenon X Review

The Rab Xenon X used to be the best all-purpose lightweight synthetic insulated jacket on the market. Over the last seven years, the author has used the Xenon and Xenon X for some fantastic outdoor adventures: a 35-day traverse of Alaska’s Brooks Range, climbing Denali, Half Dome, and El Cap, and other things. Though the Xenon X performs above average in our tests, a variety of other jackets now offer superior performance.

You don’t have access to view this content.

Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody Review

This Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody Review features a jacket with high levels of durability and inclement weather resistance, but a mediocre warmth:weight ratio.

Update March 6, 2018 – A preliminary review of the Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody was originally published here in November 2016. That review has been replaced by this more up-to-date version, which is based on extensive field use.

Overview

The Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody is a high-loft synthetic insulated hooded jacket with a highly water-resistant, seam-taped outer shell. Its highly durable fabric makes it a good choice for resort skiing, use around town, and working outside in cold weather. Due to its lower overall warmth and low warmth to weight ratio, other jackets and parkas perform better for human-powered outdoor activities when saving weight and/or being toasty warm.

Arc'teryx Kappa Hoody Review: a durable, weatherproof insulated outer jacket for winter climbing, skiing, and hiking.
The Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody isn’t warm enough for cold winter climbing. A similar jacket with a lighter fabric and more insulation would be great.

Features

  • Large, helmet-compatible hood with laminated brim stiffener and cord adjustments for temperature and volume adjustment;
  • Two interior stash pockets;
  • Two handwarmer pockets;
  • One exterior chest pocket;
  • Fit type: hip length, regular fit (as opposed to slim / athletic).

Specifications

  • Review Sample Size: M;
  • Back length: 31.5 in (80 cm);
  • Manufacturer’s Claimed Weight: 25.9 oz (735 g);
  • Insulation: Arc’teryx Coreloft 140 gsm (4.1 osy);
  • Shell Fabric: Gore Windstopper (Gore Thermium starting Fall 2016) – 70 denier main fabric, 80 denier reinforcements.

Description of Field Testing

We tested the Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody in mild winter conditions at temperatures above 10 deg F (-12 deg C). Our activities included done-in-a-day trips (alpine and ice climbing, ski touring, and resort skiing) and one overnight trip to a remote cabin in Alaska’s Chugach Mountain Range.

Both testers (myself and Luc) are 6 ft (1.8 m) tall and weigh 150-160 lb (68-73 kg).

Performance Assessment

Warmth

I used the Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody for winter ice and mixed climbing. I found it to be too light (not warm enough) to be a versatile parka for multi-day trips. A warmer parka would be a better choice for multi-day trips because a user needs to stay warm while stationary for longer periods of time.

Luc found the Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody warm enough for day trips and resort skiing simply because he was moving continuously. When donning the jacket at short breaks, the light insulation was plenty to stave off a chill.

Like all windproof synthetic insulated parkas we tested, the Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody is intended to be used as an insulating layer for stationary activities (e.g., around town, sledding, general winter use) or low output activities like resort skiing. The low air permeable fabrics make it too hot for high output activities unless it’s frigid (perhaps below 0 deg F / -18 deg C). To increase the versatility of the jacket, we wish Arc’teryx would increase the amount of insulation from 140 gsm to 180-200 gsm so it could be warm enough for overnight trips in winter.

Weather Resistance

The Gore Windstopper (which will change to Gore Thermium, which is more water resistant, in the fall) outer shell is highly water resistant and seam-taped. As a result, this is one of the most storm-resistant insulated jackets we’ve tested. The Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody is virtually impervious to wind, rain, and snow.

Breathability

The highly weather-resistant shell fabric limits breathability of the Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody. Thus, the jacket is suitable as an active layer only in extremely cold conditions.

Durability

The Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody is the toughest synthetic insulated jacket we’ve tested. Its 70 denier main fabric and 80 denier reinforcements are burly! This fabric weight seems excessive for most lightweight hiking, climbing, and skiing applications. That said, it offers a level of durability that will protect the shell in some situations that may be of interest to the backcountry traveler. For example, the Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody should hold up well when thrashing through thick brush, hauling a load of firewood back to camp, or scrambling and scraping against mountain rock.

Comfort

The Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody does not have a minimalist feature set. It offers five pockets (two handwarmer pockets set high above a waist belt, two large inside stash pockets, and a chest pocket). In addition, a large (helmet-compatible) four-point adjustable hood and a roomy “expedition” fit allow for layering over any reasonable multi-layer clothing system.

Our only complaint with the features is the chest pocket. We felt that it should be insulated better so it can keep electronics, sunscreen, and other small essentials warm in cold temperatures.

The Arcteryx Kappa Hoody's two-way zipper and snap closure make it easier and warmer to use a belay device.
The Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody’s two-way zipper and snap closure make it easier and warmer to use a belay device.

 

Beautiful drop-in pockets on the Arcteryx Kappa Hoody.
Interior drop-in pockets on the Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody. Placing the pockets high prevents heavy items from sagging below the waist.

Weight

Our men’s medium Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody weighed 25.4 oz. (720 g), which is 3.4 oz (96 g) more than the Patagonia DAS. The Patagonia DAS is also quite weatherproof, but uses a lighter shell fabric and more insulation.

Arcteryx Kappa Hoody
Max wearing the Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody on a backcountry cabin trip in the Chugach Range of Alaska.

Strengths & Limitations

Strengths

  • Highly durable exterior fabric;
  • Highly weather resistant;
  • Outstanding fit, finish, and construction quality.

Limitations

  • Low warmth to weight ratio (due to high weight of shell fabric);
  • Breathability inhibited by weatherproof shell fabric laminate.

Review Rating: Above Average

The Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody is a durable and weather-resistant synthetic insulated parka. We hoped that this jacket would be warmer for its weight – perhaps the most important performance metric for those of us interested in keeping our pack weight down on multi-day trips. But Arc’teryx spends the weight of this jacket on a durable shell fabric, instead. As such, we find the Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody best suited for done-in-a-day winter activities (e.g., resort skiing comes to mind).

Many other synthetic insulated parkas in the same weight class are much warmer for their weight and perhaps better suited for multi-day trips where weight is an important consideration. However, impeccable construction quality and a highly weather-resistant and durable shell set the Arc’teryx apart from this crowded apparel genre – but only slightly. So we rate it “Above Average” – conceding that if durability and weather resistance are higher priorities than warmth or weight for you, you may very well consider the Arc’teryx Kappa Hoody to be among the best in its class.

Where To Buy

Related Content

This review is part of a comprehensive State of the Market survey of synthetic insulated jackets that has been ongoing for the past two years. Included in this survey:

Disclosure

The author purchased this jacket with this own funds. Some links are affiliate links, which means if you click through and make a purchase, Backpacking Light gets a small commission on the sale. This comes at no extra cost to you and helps support Backpacking Light’s efforts to publish authoritative and valuable information about lightweight backpacking gear and techniques, inspiring stories and film festivals, and remain an active member of the outdoor industry to promote and protect opportunities for public outdoor recreation.