Part of the problem working as an artist (I am an illustrator, graphic designer, photographer, and writer) is that too many people who have never made the effort to learn the skills of being an artist assume that the work artists produce is useless, easily replicable, and something anyone can do… until they have to produce the artwork themselves. Then suddenly the artist becomes valuable, but a lot of people don't want to pay for the skills that artists have. I was once offered 30 cents for a graphic design that took me three weeks to produce!
I don't want to get into the debate about whether SMD was wrong or not, but I do want to insist that the discussion about artwork belonging to someone who made it is very important and shouldn't be pooh-poohed as being childish or whiney. Just think if someone had taken one of SMD's (or any other company's) shelters without the producer's permission and used it on their website for marketing purposes, what do you think the reaction would be?
The point I'm trying to make is not about who was wrong, but about the relevance of the conversation. Why is a shelter legitimate to get outraged about, but not a photograph? To my mind they are both valid and respectable creations. I think the degree of relevance is often left to the vagaries of people's sense of proportion; to some people a shelter just seems worth more than a photograph, to others, vice versa. Unfortunately the people who decide the laws about such things tend to place much more value on a shelter and nonchalantly brush off the artist as "irrelevant". It's been like this a long, long time, and the reason why there are so many "starving artists"!

