Topic

SMD Lunar Solo E misinformation/copyright infringement

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 76 through 100 (of 106 total)
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 8:35 pm

Part of the problem working as an artist (I am an illustrator, graphic designer, photographer, and writer) is that too many people who have never made the effort to learn the skills of being an artist assume that the work artists produce is useless, easily replicable, and something anyone can do… until they have to produce the artwork themselves. Then suddenly the artist becomes valuable, but a lot of people don't want to pay for the skills that artists have. I was once offered 30 cents for a graphic design that took me three weeks to produce!

I don't want to get into the debate about whether SMD was wrong or not, but I do want to insist that the discussion about artwork belonging to someone who made it is very important and shouldn't be pooh-poohed as being childish or whiney. Just think if someone had taken one of SMD's (or any other company's) shelters without the producer's permission and used it on their website for marketing purposes, what do you think the reaction would be?

The point I'm trying to make is not about who was wrong, but about the relevance of the conversation. Why is a shelter legitimate to get outraged about, but not a photograph? To my mind they are both valid and respectable creations. I think the degree of relevance is often left to the vagaries of people's sense of proportion; to some people a shelter just seems worth more than a photograph, to others, vice versa. Unfortunately the people who decide the laws about such things tend to place much more value on a shelter and nonchalantly brush off the artist as "irrelevant". It's been like this a long, long time, and the reason why there are so many "starving artists"!

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 8:35 pm

@ Joshua:

I see. Thanks. All the way back to page 1 — and then such a violent outburst! Delayed reaction I guess. :)

Tom Caldwell BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 8:49 pm

The pictures didn't even look in-focus to my eye. Very mediocre snapshots in my opinion. What's the big deal?

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 9:09 pm

>>>Fine, Bob — except for the last line. Sigh.<<<

+1

It's like a little kid who has to get in the last word.

Jason Elsworth BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 9:15 pm

Perfectly said Miguel – my thoughts exactly. However as you can see from Tom's comments some people are just never going to get it. If I get any slightly out of focus shots of Elvis wrestling a big foot I will delete them immediately as worthless.

Ken Thompson BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 9:26 pm

This could have all been avoided if the manufacturer would only use photos that were submitted for use. And who amongst us wouldn't like to see our gear in use on their site?

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 9:39 pm

ben, you win again.

17 posts to my 3.

maybe NOW the thread can end? :)

oops, now i have 4.

p.s. this all could've been avoided if the OP just talked with Ron privately. just sayin'.

Bruce Tolley BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 10:01 pm

When I saw the title of this thread, I thought somebody had stolen SMD's intellectual property. Now that would have been an interesting thread.

Konrad . BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 10:10 pm

You guys realize that bob's comment about "copyright law for dummies" is in reference to the series of books such as "carpentry for dummies", "camping for dummies", or "beet farm growing for dummies." Considering that those books are general and broad overviews of particular topics, and the fact that Bob did give a general overview of copyright law, I think his comment was appropriate. I just hope no one took it out of context or as a personal jab at their intelligence.

Jason Elsworth BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 10:10 pm

p.s. this all could've been avoided if the OP just talked with Ron privately. just sayin'.

Absolutely agree – private is the way to go on these matters.

D S BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 10:10 pm

Used to be a decent underwater photographer and had my images show up in Asian dive publications without my permission or knowledge (no offense to Asia- just where they surfaced). Never saw a dime–even had a couple cover shots. Anything submitted to websites seems to me fair game for use unless a query letter is accompanied for commercial use of said images.

A few backpacking pics of gear and gear owner seem pretty innocuous. Ben, keep your pics posted…I always get to the dance a day late after you've edited them out.

p.s. how 'bout that BPl calendar folks…stunning and on topic.

couch

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 10:12 pm

I actually read this entire thread. It's sort of like a train wreck……want to look away but you can't help yourself.

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 11:07 pm

Yeah my gf reads celebrity gossip all day, like perez hilton type crap, and now I can't really give her grief anymore.. Thx guys. You've ruined my life. Next stop, Jerry Springer. I feel like I'm riding the white trash train.

PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 2:54 am

I think the OP has handled this very badly. He should have let Mr. Moak respond privately and have sorted it out privately. It has no place on this forum, despite the OP's explanation.

I've had similar things happen as a professional photographer for over twenty five years. They've all been resolved in a dignified way between me and the guilty parties.

I think the OP was rude to involve Mr Moak in a public humiliation without giving him the chance to privately make good for the error first.

Bad judgement, poor manners, and poor business skills, especially as the OP says he didn't want any money for the images anyway.

I can understand the anger the OP must have felt, I've been there too. Pure over reaction to behave like this in a forum that carries much weight in a tight community.

I have some SMD gear, which does a great job for me, and I'll buy from them again.

fred

John S. BPL Member
PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 6:22 am

I thought I was reading the whiteblaze forum for a minute.

t.darrah BPL Member
PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 6:44 am

I'm going to purchase something from Ron Moak to 1) show my support and my appreciation in his manner of handling this and to 2) add a quality item to the gear closet inventory.

Ron keep up the good work.

Henry Blake BPL Member
PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 8:56 am

I had a small smile on my face as I read this entire thread. Like others, I had to see what would come next. A reference to Sweden and Norway over 65 years ago was even brought up again, as if Johan might somehow be responsible.

People came at Johan from both directions, warranted or not. Having lived overseas, cultures differ greatly. Shouldn't we strive for greater empathy and understanding between all peoples of the world? We needn't be deliberately unkind to others.

I appreciated hearing more on copyright law, from those to whom it matters most. I can also understand those at the other end of the spectrum who don't much care about it. As humans, we often behave irrationally. Some who wouldn't shoplift a CD, would download the same music without paying.

I have often wondered what the cottage makers think about some of us knocking off their designs in cuben or sil, (perhaps slightly modified), and then sharing our experience and photos on the MYOG forum. Ron? Henry?

P.S.— It's not too hard to see how wars get started, even when everyone openly admits that they don't want a war. No one can seem to keep war from happening. I sent this to my Dad only a week ago—Carl Jung on "war". http://www.gla.ac.uk/~dc4w/laibach/jungwar.html

PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 10:26 am

> I have often wondered what the cottage makers think about some of us knocking off their designs in cuben or sil, (perhaps slightly modified), and then sharing our experience and photos on the MYOG forum. Ron? Henry?

Where do think I get all my ideas ;-) Seriously, this whole thread is pretty amusing. For me it all comes down to profiting (or not) from the work of others. The notion that Ron's intent was to steal someone's IP photo for profit is just laughable (and going public without at least trying to resolve any misunderstanding privately is, in your words, "deliberately unkind") . Anyway, to answer the question, I'm gratified when a do-it-yourselfer makes something inspired by my work. And I'm gratified when someone sends in a photo for publication in our gallery. I did notice the MYOG Rainbow thread which made me smile because it reminded me of all the pain I went through trying to get that design correct. Hats off to anyone who can whip up a MYOG Rainbow. My head still hurts from beating it against the wall a few years back.

-H

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 10:35 am

What did you get Tom? One of the new packs? A shelter?

>Hats off to anyone who can whip up a MYOG Rainbow.

HA! I can't even sew a rectangle silnylon tarp without it getting all lopsided.

PostedFeb 10, 2010 at 12:11 pm

"For me it all comes down to profiting (or not) from the work of others. The notion that Ron's intent was to steal someone's IP photo for profit is just laughable (and going public without at least trying to resolve any misunderstanding privately is, in your words, "deliberately unkind")"

That is my view too. No profit, no harm, and the issue was dealt with promptly once the 'accused' was aware of it. Making the 'accused' aware of the issue in this forum would not be my first approach, but we all deal with our little strifes in life in different ways. It would have been nice for Ron to have acknowledged the owner of the photo, but obviously this was not an easy task. I'm sure Ron has learned plenty from this forum flogging, and won't be making that mistake again!

Arapiles . BPL Member
PostedFeb 11, 2010 at 1:48 am

Some complex and difficult issues here … but Ron's been to Kamikochi so I'm on his side.

Viewing 25 posts - 76 through 100 (of 106 total)
Loading...