Topic

SMD Lunar Solo E misinformation/copyright infringement

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 51 through 75 (of 106 total)
EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 11:32 am

Yes Dave, we'll have the conversation because you want to. But anything that you aren't interested in or just tired of — you scream "hey this is the gear forum!". Just sayin'…

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 11:32 am

"I would think its cool that a manufacturer used my pic."

Me too.
If they asked me, gave me credit and didn't turn Lapland into Alaska. That isn't too much to ask for.

The one who went public when he should have contacted someone first wasn't Mr Alvehus in this case.

And as for our need of the pics: pics on Utsidan.se are indexed by Google, and easy to find.

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 11:36 am

"Dan….the impression I got was your condemnation of him for something that he didn't actually do. Pretty strongly worded IMO"

You're right. My bad. I got overly worked up thinking about other similar experiences in the past (related to my scooter site) which got a lot crazier than this.

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 11:57 am

Interesting thread. I wonder if the same sentiment would hold if the photographs were posted on the North Face Website.

Jeffs Eleven BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 1:29 pm

You're right. How DARE he see a snapshot of mountains and not be able to identify them.

I'm never buying SMD again!

AND he has the gall to wear that pseudo- mtn man beard!

but seriously, when's the Cuben Lunar Duo coming out?

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 4:10 pm

And now you can see why its no wonder the Swedes just rolled over and let the Germans invade Norway by train.

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 5:30 pm

"That is one idiotic comment!"

Only one of many in this thread, methinks.

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 5:45 pm

> Me too.
> If they asked me, gave me credit and didn't turn Lapland
> into Alaska. That isn't too much to ask for.

I'd guess it an easy mistake, there are a lot of similarities between Lapland and Alaska, and Greenland and Kamchatskiy, …

I don't think Ron's or his people's intentions are bad.

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 5:46 pm

Just want to make one comment about copyrights.

It doesn't matter how and with what kind of tool you use, be it a top-level professional camera or a plastic toy camera, if you create an original image or object, no matter how crappy it is or lacking in artistic quality, and you don't sign away the rights to it, it is yours. There is a whole other can of worms concerning "value to society" (in other words artwork belongs to the community rather than the individual), but in a nutshell "you produce the artwork, it is yours".

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 5:52 pm

"There is a whole other can of worms concerning"

You said it there. Actually, copyright law in almost every country in the world is extremely murky water. Especially so as it relates to use across borders, international copyright law is about as interpretive as it gets.

This is a pointless argument guys. How about the old adage: "No harm, no foul." ?

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 5:59 pm

>This is a pointless argument guys. How about the old adage: "No harm, no foul." ?

Word.

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 6:26 pm

No, YOU need to get real — that's theft. Being a professional photographer, I'd be charging a license fee for the use of my images in marketing materials — depending on the usage, exclusivity, and duration of the license, that could be as much as five thousand dollars.

Note — since they took down the image after a simple request, Six Moon did the right thing in the end… so had it been my image, I wouldn't have threatened them with a suit… and granting permission for them to use the image is the creator's right, it's a fine way IMO to support a company you like.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 6:30 pm

Who the heck is Rakesh screaming at 'to get real'? Someone left the looney ward open today?

PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 6:34 pm

No, I just expected that replying to a specific post would include that post as a quote, since that's common in most forum software… and you just made the folks that gave me such a warm welcome and spoke so highly of the community look like liars.

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 6:49 pm

>"and you just made the folks that gave me such a warm welcome and spoke so highly of the community look like liars"

Woah. Easy. In some respects this is a very tight-knit community, and many of us know each other quite well. I've said this on a completely unrelated thread a few months ago: you can't just come into a conversation a whoopin' and screamin' at people and expect a "warm welcome." Even if you've got a justifiable point, don't expect hugs and kisses with a post like that. You've got 6 posts. Often you've gotta have earned your keep around here to come in guns a blazin'. Just a friendly heads up.

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedFeb 9, 2010 at 8:07 pm

If you read through the thread, there are only a few of us here who are professional photographers. You may notice that each of us knows a little about copyright law, although very few know much about the Sweden vs. USA angle.

I've had my photos stolen before and used in print. Naturally, the boss in charge pleaded "sorry, my fault, I didn't know, yada yada". However, those are easy words to plead, very easy. It's the philosophy that it's easier to ask for forgiveness than it is to ask for permission.

I think it was appropriate for Johan to make a stink about it, because he probably didn't have any other forum. I've had managers simply ignore my emails, and if they don't feel any customer or legal consequences, they brush it off, too busy, executive privilege, etc.

Ron or whoever else at the company needs to avoid hassles like this in the future. If he is in charge, then he should make a company policy. Then whoever is assembling their web site must follow company policy or face consequences. The company policy will probably state something to the effect that there must be a release form on file for each photo used in the commercial web site. The release form simply identifies exactly what photo is at issue, and that the photographer can prove, if necessary, that he is the copyright holder on that photo. The photographer can release the photo for specific uses, or just sort of a universal release to use it for anything. Then the photographer signs it. The company holds that paper in their files as long as they have the photo file in their possession, because they might use it this year, skip a year, or whatever.

Now, many companies do not want to go through this hassle, so they get their own employees to shoot product photos. That's a different deal, and the rights go to the employer immediately, no questions asked.

It was stated that the photographer should embed his own IPTC (identification) into the photo file. Yes, that is a good idea, and all of mine that are publicly accessible are identified. But it is not Johan's burden to do that. Maybe his software does it, and maybe it doesn't. If the company can't easily find the owner of the photo, then they simply shouldn't use it. Simple. There are millions of photos available.

You know, many organizations that ask my permission in advance may be granted it for use of one or two of my photos. But, when they don't ask and just do it, watch out!

I hope that ends Copyright Law For Dummies.

–B.G.–

Viewing 25 posts - 51 through 75 (of 106 total)
Loading...