Tent Dilemma

Does it really need to be freestanding? Having owned a BA Seedhouse SL1 back in 2005 (that shares a similar style to the copper spur) and it wasn’t really freestanding, but I am not sure it buys you much anyways.

https://backpackinglight.com/forums/topic/freestanding-or-trekking-pole-shelters/

+1 on Brad’s comments. You’ll likely find much feedback on BPL along these lines. List out the reasons you feel you need a free standing tent for a trail like the JMT in summer, then challenge those presumptions and see what conclusions you come up with.

Have never owned a BA tent, though bought one with the Copper Spur design years ago, and returned it because it exceeded the spec weight considerably. They have a new one out with this design that is very light. Sorry to hear about the complaints relating to leakage and durability.

Guessing that you want what you say you want, and as light as possible without sacrificing function and durability. Was wondering why you did not consider a larger Nemo Tent, like the Dagger. You might also look at the Tarptent Bowfin 2, spec’d as a free standing double wall. The Trekkertent Phreeranger is a similar design, but you’d need to contact them to get full specs, and would have to order well ahead.

Then there are the current offerings from the larger companies, like Marmot, Mtn Hardwear, Sierra Designs and MSR, that you can review on line, and probably be able to see in person at larger outfitting stores in your locale. Hope this is helpful.

Thanks to all for your feedback!

DS

The Henry Shires Tarptent Rainbow and Double Rainbow each require about 4 stakes but are relatively “freestanding.” See the videos on line on how to erect the tents.

In terms of room they are very long.  There is also some headroom. My wife and I can sit up and read in the Double Rainbow.  You can also leave the side doors open and enjoy the view.

Otherwise I would suggest a tarp or mid erected with hiking poles.

Cheers

https://www.aliexpress.com/item/NatureHike-2-Person-Tent-210T-Plaid-Fabric-Tent-Double-layer-Camping-Tent-Lightweight-4-seasons-Tent/32323447078.html?aff_platform=product&cpt=1522144623136&sk=mYJeYrn&aff_trace_key=9076e42ff205417298ba90d1220dbcc4-1522144623136-04904-mYJeYrn&terminal_id=316abd6016304d24ab81b9e9e04a8d8a

I still love the BA fly creek ul1 tent that I have. On the JMT I’m only in my tent to sleep. I don’t need a lot of room. The Fly Creek is bombproof in wind and weather and double walled. And light. So there’s all of that. the complaint about the entrance allowing rain to come in when entering or exiting is true, strictly speaking. I’ve never even really noticed it in fact. The tent certainly never leaked, but I seam sealed it in addition to the tape. Again, it’s totally bombproof.

The Bowfin looks pretty cool for a double wall tent. More room inside I believe.

that said I’d carry a Hexamid or other lighter hiking pole set up tent instead since I have the option.

Good info on the previous threads listed.

I have moved from a Big Agnes Seedhouse SL2 (mostly freestanding) to a ZPacks Solplex.  Nothing freestanding about that, but I’ve not had any trouble finding a spot to get a decent if not perfect pitch.

Whatever you decide, get it soon if ordering from one of the non-cottage manufacturers.  There is a good deal of concern over potential looming tariffs, which could potentially add 25% to the cost of your tent.  The outdoor industry is worried, since so much gear is made in China.  Fun times.

there’s a MLD solomid on sale on this site right now. That’s a great looking shelter (preferable to the Hexamid, probably.) But it’s just the tarp. But you can improvise a number or inner bug nets and floor if you want.

I don’t know why the Solomid doesn’t get more love. (although I’ve never used one!)

Tarptent Moment DW with optional crossing pole.

Can’t complain about my BA Fly Creek HV UL2. Mostly free standing. The two sides of the foot end need to be staked to fill out the interior, without question. Been a good tent so far, after a year or so of use.

Kelly

Big Sky Revolution 2. Too heavy? I have it and it is very roomy, bomber construction.

About 1.5 kgs, will go up with 2 pegs (either porch side) unless there is real wind.

Then 4 more in the corners to start. Up in about 1.5 mins if that.