Topic

Best Solo Backpacking Tent – 1P Tarp – MLD Trailstar

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
Christine H BPL Member
PostedNov 26, 2016 at 10:26 am

The Mountain Laurel Designs Trailstar is a simple, ultralight, roomy shelter for one person — and it passes the wind test!   I hate flapping tents!  The Trailstar hardly makes a sound.  The pentagon shape hugs the ground.  You can pitch it with the center pole down to 90 – 110 cm, and it barely moves in the wind due to its aerodynamic, bomber design.

It’s roomy!  I use it for solo camping, sleep in the back half, and have the whole rest of the inside for gear.  I’m short, 5’2″ so I can sit upright next to the center pole, no problem.  The door is located far enough away that rain doesn’t blow inside.

It has its own bug net, best used with the center pole set at 125 cm.  I clip the TrailStar InnerNet in the back using the hooks.  You don’t have to use the hooks, but they keep the net from sagging, so the mosquitos won’t land on you and bite through.  The innernet has a deep silnylon tub floor, which can be waterproofed.

Its versatile.  When the weather is nice, you can pitch it high and open and get a great view.  If there are no bugs or rain, you can leave the innernet at home and use it as a floorless tarp.  If it sags at night, you can reach underneath and tighten your tautline hitches without going outside.

It’s stealthy olive brown — a nice color that blends with almost every landscape in every season.  The original gray is stealthy, too.  It packs small and weighs little.

It’s simple.  Stake out the back corner & door (use pole), the arms, (insert center pole) and the legs of the star.  There’s no floor to fuss with.  No dangly parts to attach.  No extra poles to backpack, just your hiking poles.  It’s one of the the least fiddly tents around.

Fair warning:  The Trailstar is based on a pyramid shape.  The walls are slanted.  You’re not going to get much vertical room.  Rain will feel like it’s falling close to your face.  The pole in the middle will limit where you can lie on the floor.  Also, it has a big footprint.

Adam White BPL Member
PostedNov 26, 2016 at 10:54 am

Welcome to BPL!

I realize that the gear review subforum is down, but I would recommend adding the words “Gear Review” to the title of any subsequent gear reviews you post (beyond the three that you did within the last ten minutes).

“Best” is not a good word to use, because the premise is incorrect. There is no “best”. There can be “best” for a set of conditions, goals and preferences, but that will vary trip to trip and person to person–and will still be subjective after controlling for all that. You have not made it very clear under what conditions and preferences you have found this to be “best”, nor have you offered comparisons to other tarps that are competitive in feature/weight/cost space.

I’m glad you like your tarp, and am not surprised that you’re happy with a MLD product–I always have been!

Lance M BPL Member
PostedNov 26, 2016 at 3:16 pm

Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts on the Trailstar.

-Lance

Christine H BPL Member
PostedNov 27, 2016 at 9:24 am

You’re welcome, Lance.

Adam, yeah, there wasn’t any gear>review subforum available.

Regarding your comment: “You have not made it very clear under what conditions and preferences you have found this to be “best”…

I think I made it perfectly clear from the start that I wanted a simple, ultralight, roomy tent that is aerodynamic  and performs well in the wind and rain.  Also:  versatile, stealthy, and comes with a bug net.

Also:  I was going for the Google Search criteria to help people shopping for a tent:  Best, tent, tarp, solo, 1P

Regarding your comment: “…nor have you offered comparisons to other tarps that are competitive in feature/weight/cost space.”

Okay, fair enough:  The MLD Trailstar was roomier and more enclosed than the Tarptent Notch, but it didn’t it need its own pole like the Tarptent Moment.  It wasn’t made of polyester like the Six Moon Design Lunar Solo.  It offered a view, unlike the MLD Duomid.  It wasn’t as expensive as the ZPacks Cuben shelters.  It didn’t need weird hubs like many of the geometric tents you can buy from REI.  It got great wind reviews, unlike LightHeart Solo.  Um, that’s all I can remember.  Didn’t save my research notes.

 

 

Ben C BPL Member
PostedNov 27, 2016 at 9:34 am

It is the best for me too, Christine.  The lack of a zipper really adds a lot of simplicity. But at the same time, it has a lot of versatility.

Adam White BPL Member
PostedNov 27, 2016 at 12:10 pm

Well, we could continue the discussion regarding the word “best”, but I can tell that in doing so, I’m heading down the path of becoming an internet curmudgeon arguing semantics. So, let’s not ;).

Your post got me poking around on MLD’s website, where I saw the following in regards to the Trailstar: “Eight people can sit inside…”

That is indeed a roomy tarp! I suspect that they must be eight very, very good friends.

PostedNov 29, 2016 at 9:03 pm

Well, I like my Tarptent Moment DW solo tent.

Very fast setup (hence the name), extremely wind-worthy, totally enclosed but has 2 doors and vestibules, good venting and a crossing pole option for stability in wind &/or snow.

 

PostedNov 29, 2016 at 10:53 pm

“The MLD Trailstar was roomier and more enclosed than the Tarptent Notch, but it didn’t it need its own pole like the Tarptent Moment. It wasn’t made of polyester like the Six Moon Design Lunar Solo”
Both the TT Notch and Moment are fully enclosed double wall tents. Add an inner net to the Trailstar and the weight/price  will go up and usable space will go down..

(you can also  use either as fly only…)

The SMD Lunar Solo comes in silnylon too and is on sale  at $172 right now.

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
Loading...