I can’t believe I discovered this thread over the weekend…AFTER I’ve hoarded a green Staika, two green Unnas, a Windsack, a red Rajd, and just received the green Kaitum 4GT and sand Jannu last Monday.
Last month, I read through advrider.com’s Hilleberg thread of 1150+ postings and really appreciate their tent selection based adaptability to terra incognito. They are mindful of volume and weight but are not obsessive gram-counters.
Due to archaic NY & NJ laws, Hilleberg cannot have a retail presence in these states so I’ve been relying on the Hilleberg catalog and youtube videos for reviews and pitching instructions. In this town, I know only one other person who has a Hilleberg but he didn’t want to lug his Tarra around to show me. I considered Exped but their warranty is too limited; Helsport seemed too rare, and Fjallraven cannot ship tents to NY.
MY COLLECTION (HILLEBERG AND NON-HILLEBERG) AND RECOLLECTIONS:
BIG AGNES COPPER SPUR UL3 MtnGlo
My very first tent was Copper Spur UL3 MtnGlo. I didn’t know about Hilleberg until after I bought this. Although I love this tent, too–less than 5 lbs. and very roomy for two; even roomier for one–it has too much mesh for my comfort in temperatures below 50F. While camping in the low 80F, it was too hot with both doors open and in the shade of the forest. It was waterproof during solid rains–despite the mesh, condensation created puddles within the inner tent–but it hasn’t been exposed to heavy winds yet. Is it wise to have a tent just for moderate to high temperatures?
SIERRA DESIGNS SFC SOLO ASSAULT TENT (akin to Mountain Hardwear Hunker 1 Tent)
This, too, was a pre-Hilleberg purchase. This is a hardy, tactical tent with three poles, two entrances and 22 sq ft of interior space. It’s ultra-low interior height of 30″ makes moving around difficult, especially with a Western Mountaineering Puma and a 3.5″ sleeping pad. The single-walled design is colder than a double-walled tent and it had a lot of condensation in a snowy environment. At 4 lbs 6oz, it’s negligibly lighter than the Unna but the Unna is far more comfortable for my use. I’m going to sell this tactical tent.
CLARK MARK2
This hammock can be used on the ground, too. I have yet to pitch this outside on the ground or between the trees. The quality is terrific but I would not be comfortable in temperatures below the mid-60s F because I run cold. Also, I probably would end up cramming my backpack next to my legs. At 3 lbs 8 oz without the tree straps and drip rings, the Unna is not much more weight for a lot more comfort. The good thing about the Mark2 is that it is a hammock.
STAIKA–MY FIRST HILLEBERG
For my first Hilleberg, I wanted something from the Black Label. The 1.5 lbs weight savings of an Allak seemed negligible. The Staika has served me and my 8 year-old son well for a year and a half. A few weeks ago, I pitched it on a blustery ridge in Harriman State Park after nightfall. This site was poorly chosen by my camp mates who arrived in the early afternoon. After pinning down all the guylines and the top vent cover, there was no flapping noises whatsoever and no breeze made its way under the outer tent. The next day, the rest of my camping group relocated their tents due to the immense discomfort. We were comfortable so we stayed put. One morning, a crow drummed the outer tent with its beak. Thank goodness, there wasn’t a hole.
I appreciate Staika’s two entrances that can fit our backpacks (85L and 50L). I carry the tent; my son carries the sleep gear. I’m looking forward to warmer weather to try out the mesh inner tent. At 4.5 feet tall, he has some difficulty getting to the upper clips of the Staika. Regarding condensation, I experienced a little in our first winter camp out at Camp Pouch in Staten Island. However, it was not pools of water like with my Copper Spur UL3 while at Floyd Bennett Field–a few minutes walk from the shores of Jamaica Bay–nor my Sierra Designs SFC in February in Harriman State Park.
UNNA
I got the Unna in January for a solo outing in Camp Schiff, Long Island (Camp Wauwepex for you oldies). That weekend, it dumped a foot of snow and I could witness the stretching of the Unna outer tent. I decided to sleeping in the lodge for convenience: I didn’t want to get up at night to clear off the snow and I preferred my tent to be dry before we left early in the morning. Shannon at Hilleberg said that the stretching was normal and that it would have been good to adjust the stakes during or after the snowfall.
It’s easy to move around within the Unna even with my 85 pack next to me. The double-walled set-up is warmer than my single-walled Sierra Designs SFC Shelter. No condensation during this camp out. There was enough room to place my boots between the inner and outer tents so I didn’t have to detach the corner of the inner tent.
An opportunity arose to get another Unna + mesh at a low-ish price so I snagged it since my son will be sleeping on his own. He can set up the Unna by himself. I considered getting a Soulo but he thought that the inner area was too small. Still, I might trade one of my Unnas for a Soulo just for variety.
WINDSACK
The Windsack is a 3-person bothy bag and works well in keeping the heat in. Me and a colleague sat on a bench in the snow for more than an hour. The warmth wasn’t apparent until we exited the windsack. I got this for a ski trip but that didn’t happen. Anyway, this item is a keeper.
RAJD
As urban dwellers with no backyard, we have yet to set this up. The red is somewhat sheer and I prefer the privacy of the green tents. If I could trade it for a green one, I would be happy. I thought this might be a good emergency shelter if I wasn’t going to be toting around my Unna but I may just let this one go.
NAMMATJ 3GT
I bought a used Nammatj 3GT but the previous owner sent it dirty and smelly so I returned it. Although I don’t really need the length at the foot end of the Nammatj, I didn’t really like the acute slope. I figured that the Kaitum GT or the Keron GT at 3 feet longer would give me a whole different experience. Even the Jannu has more height towards the foot to allow for more area to sit upright.
JANNU
It was only after seeing Alexander Barber’s interview with Petra did I consider the Jannu. After pitching this indoors this weekend, I know that it’s a keeper. There are times where I would rather have our gear together in one vestible and carrying 7 lbs may be preferable to the Staika’s 9 lbs. Also, it seems hardier than an Unna for solo camping. They were out of green so I thought I would try sand but it’s too sheer for privacy if I were to use the outer tent only. There is no mesh inner tent for the Jannu. I wonder what is the highest temperature that would be comfortable in a Jannu.
KAITUM 4GT
After much back and forth between the Keron 4GT and the Kaitum 4GT, the ability to create a porch with the extended vestible was the deciding factor in selecting the Kaitum 4GT. If the Keron 4GT had the porch capability, we would have gone with that. The Keron GT’s outer tent has solid and mesh options for the vents and door, whereas the Kaitum has only the solid. I’m sure we can retrofit the vents with mesh option. It’s more time and money but it will be nice to not have bugs coming through the vents. The Kaitum 4GT is spec’d to be a little more than a pound heavier than the Staika. However, with the footprint, it tips the scale to be a car-camping tent for me. Despite a sloppy job pitching this indoors, the palatial feeling is lovely. At 16′ 5″ in length, it’s a lot of tent but Zachary at Hilleberg said as long as the inner tent is on level ground, the vestibules could be pitched over rocks or tree stumps.
OPTIMIZING OUR COLLECTION
After reading the entire Hilleberg Tent Threads on both backpackinglight.com and advrider.com, I realized that I didn’t really consider everything. Instead of a Staika, I could have considered the Tarra for the larger vestibules and more inner volume at the same weight or Jannu for a smaller footprint and two pounds less. I won’t relinquish the Kaitum 4GT. I may let go one of the Unnas even without getting a Soulo. Since my son has many camping decades ahead of him, all of our tents will have repeated use.
For my personal preference, I will stick with double-walled designs, the outer tent ending at the ground, and an inner tent will always have the ability to be completely sealed. The outer/inner/footprint pitching combo is a blessing since our outings usually include inclement weather and setting up camp after sunset. Although I will explore other tent makers, I’m satisfied with Hilleberg’s offerings.