Topic

Another Half Dome death – Saturday, June 13, 2009


Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Home Forums General Forums General Lightweight Backpacking Discussion Another Half Dome death – Saturday, June 13, 2009

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 61 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1237075
    Larry Sullivan
    Member

    @150mph

    Locale: Los Angeles

    Yosemite this weekend. My camp mates saw it happen. Here's the story I wrote on my hiking site:

    http://planetrambler.com/150mph/news/_accidentonhalfdome.html

    #1508210
    Ashley Brown
    Member

    @ashleyb

    Scary stuff. It seems like they could do with a simple harness and clip-in system. If losing your grip means falling to your death then it seems pretty dumb that non-climbers are allowed to go up and down in wet conditions without any safety device. I might be jumping to conclusions there though. Does anyone clip themselves onto the cable?

    #1508211
    Nate Meinzer
    Member

    @rezniem

    Locale: San Francisco

    Here's the news link:

    http://www.modbee.com/local/story/744397.html

    His name was Manoj Kumar, from San Ramon.

    #1508212
    Rog Tallbloke
    BPL Member

    @tallbloke

    Locale: DON'T LOOK DOWN!!

    > It seems like they could do with a simple harness and clip-in system.

    Yup. Slows things down, but as my dad always says;

    "Better ten minutes late in this life, than 40 years early in the next…"

    #1508229
    Eugene Smith
    BPL Member

    @eugeneius

    Locale: Nuevo Mexico

    That is a sad story, very unfortunate for that to happen, I think it speaks a lot to the safety that we all must take when outdoors, whether it is a trail run or extended backpacking trip.

    #1508233
    Greg Mihalik
    Spectator

    @greg23

    Locale: Colorado

    "Better ten minutes late in this life, than 40 years early in the next…"

    I like that.
    It lends a good bit of perspective.

    A wise man, your Dad.

    #1508234
    John S.
    BPL Member

    @jshann

    The last death in June too. Maybe it should be closed until later in the summer?

    #1508236
    Jim MacDiarmid
    BPL Member

    @jrmacd

    I was about 12 miles away on the trail to Vogelsang High Sierra Camp. I heard a helicopter going overhead (couldn't see it, the sky was so low at the time) and knew something bad must have happened somewhere in the park.

    It was definitely not a great day to be going up Half Dome. It should go without saying that this man's death is awful and something that could've happened to anyone who has made a bad decision in their lives.

    But, if the park estimates of 50,000 people a year scaling Half Dome are accurate, that means 100,000 people did it w/o dying between the last death and this one. That's a pretty good success rate.

    As dangerous as it seems, and by the looks of some of the people who attempt it, are the cables a case of the NPS making something too easy for people, and as a result, putting people's lives in danger? Should something like Half Dome only be accesible to people who have the requisite climbing skills?

    I also thought of this when I saw the sign at the Half Dome TH about people breaking up trees on HD for firewood, pooping and not packing it out, etc.

    If you make things too easy, people don't appreciate them and don't always treat them with respect.

    #1508254
    Ken Helwig
    BPL Member

    @kennyhel77

    Locale: Scotts Valley CA via San Jose, CA

    Very sad indeed.

    I did Half Dome a few years ago, and could not help but think that it is an accident waiting to happen. The people that I see heading up the trail to Half Dome especially scare me. Most are unprepared for an outing in the Sierra's. A small water bottle for hydration, no jacket, no food, sun protection, etc. I understand the allure of hiking Half Dome but some thought should be taken as to the precautions involved in undertaking a difficult hike.

    #1508321
    george carr
    BPL Member

    @hammer-one

    Locale: Loco Libre Gear

    Sorry for my ignorance, I've never climbeed Half Dome, but is this picture the spot your talking about:

    half dome

    I hijacked this pic from another thread here, and only just noticed exactly how serious this climb is. Tragic.

    I agree that maybe this appears to be just a little to accessable to inexperienced climbers. Having never been there I might just be blathering on about a moot point.

    I don't want to be exclusionary, but how do you protect foolish people from themselves without imposing restrictions on all users?

    #1508323
    Roleigh Martin
    BPL Member

    @marti124

    Locale: Founder & Lead Moderator, https://www.facebook.com/groups/SierraNorthPCThikers
    #1508327
    Ken Helwig
    BPL Member

    @kennyhel77

    Locale: Scotts Valley CA via San Jose, CA

    George, those are the cables. It is not as steep as it looks from the picture. Though without cables and the wooden slats it would be pretty tough to climb without climbing gear.

    Alot of folks do this hike and alot of them are not too well equiped.

    I had a friend do the hike that same day and he is not too experienced nor I think was his group. They turned around and went back. Smart move on their part that day. I heard that the Rangers were leading others down off of Half Dome. The weather has been pretty strange in California this month and I am sure that the Sierra's are having some rather intersting weather too. This is the time of year for Thunder Storms up there.

    #1508332
    Ken Helwig
    BPL Member

    @kennyhel77

    Locale: Scotts Valley CA via San Jose, CA

    Roleigh after reading your two links, it sounds like hikers were pretty defiant towards the weather in an attempt to summit. One can understand wanting to summit Half Dome or any mountain. The problem is, most that are climbing it are not prepared both in experience and being properly outfitted.

    #1508337
    Barbara Karagosian
    Spectator

    @barbara

    Locale: So Cal

    I hiked it the day after the person fell in 2007. Almost the same weekend to the day. On the advice of some climber friends, I changed into (rented) climbing shoes and also set up a rope round my waist with a second rope looped thru it (I'm sure there's a name for this, ha) and both ends of that clipped to the cable. Yes it takes longer cos you have to unclip and reclip as you go past each upright. Because I had 2 ropes clipped, there was always one clipped on at any time. If I fell, I'd fall a few feet only.

    I saw no-one else doing this but many thought it was a good idea and someone borrowed it to sue after I got down. The rock was dry, but still slippery. Gloves with good grips are a must. I came back down facing forward (as told) til i started to slip, then I faced in towards the rockface for the rest of the way. The railroad tie "steps" are a vital resting place, – I found my arms got more tired than my legs – they do a lot of work. I'm sure it is incredibly slippery when wet. I've heard people say that the cables would never be put up "nowadays". There are numerous signs warning not to ascend if clouds present….it's very sad.

    #1508340
    Ken Helwig
    BPL Member

    @kennyhel77

    Locale: Scotts Valley CA via San Jose, CA

    Here is a blog written by a friend of my friend that was up there that day. Again, they are not experienced hikers.

    http://davidgoad.wordpress.com/

    #1508345
    Jesse H.
    BPL Member

    @tacedeous

    Locale: East Bay, CA

    My mom told me about this when i was driving back from a whitewater rafting trip… im currently planing a trip up half dome in august, I had thought about tethering myself, in all honesty, i had nixed the idea.. BECAUSE OF WEIGHT!, d*mn my UL obsession… definitely tethering myself… call me a pansie if you want (friends already have, lol) but as stated about swimming in the ocean, as a surfer, i know about taking proper precaution… dont let your pride get in front of returning home to tell the tale…

    #1508346
    David Olsen
    Spectator

    @oware

    Locale: Steptoe Butte

    A friend of mine skiied down that face quite a few years
    ago then returned to film another fellow snowboard it.

    Don't close everything down.

    #1508352
    Lynn Tramper
    Member

    @retropump

    Locale: The Antipodes of La Coruna

    My nephew climbed that when he was four years old. It scared the bejeevies out of me when I climbed it, and I was an experienced rock climber at the time (prolly why it scared me…I don't like going up something like that without being tied in). I think what happened was just an accident, as already pointed out, 2 deaths out of 100,000 ascents is really not that bad. I wonder if more people die driving to get to the valley??? Still pretty horrendous for those that have to watch, and the bereaved family and friends.

    #1508362
    Ashley Brown
    Member

    @ashleyb

    A few simple safety measures like clipping in is all it needs. I really hate it when the authorities go too far in trying to protect us, and end up spoiling the natural beauty of the spot. I'm sure a lot of folks here would agree with that. I think it's awesome that you can do this sort of thing without needing to be a climber. The fact that they would never set up something like this 'nowadays' is pretty sad, but true.

    #1508382
    george carr
    BPL Member

    @hammer-one

    Locale: Loco Libre Gear

    David,

    I agree 100% that these things shouldn't be closed down. It was more like me wondering out loud how to prevent this sort of thing from happening, when the reality is you can't protect the people from themselves. I just wonder how well informed the non climbing/hiking tourist about the dangers that are present. The problem is if you have too many of these types of incidents (regardless of fault), something will be done, maybe to the detriment of recreation and the outdoor community at large. Two deaths in 100,000 visits doesn't sound like a big number, but what is the number that sets somebody's alarm bells ringing to close or limit access to a trail or a peak? I guess what I am advocating is more/better education to users of these areas, to better preserve them. Unfortunately the price of freedom is never free.

    #1508407
    Eugene Smith
    BPL Member

    @eugeneius

    Locale: Nuevo Mexico

    The Cables up Half Dome appears to be a very rudimentary and insufficient attempt at a via ferrata route popular in Europe. The network of cables and railroad ties has been present for some time, but perhaps gravitating this section of Half Dome to a bolted setup mixed with aids, cables and steps would provide some added safety? This could possibly deter a small percentage of inexperienced hikers/climbers who lack the most basic gear and knowledge.

    #1508411
    Jolly Green Giant
    BPL Member

    @regultr

    Locale: www.jolly-green-giant.blogspot.com

    Actually, I was there when it happened. I was actually surprised how mechanical the medical efforts were. It was as if the park had done it many times and the visitors weren't any the wiser other than the helicopter flying around with the baskets and supplies underneath (see picture).

    Half Dome Medical Transport

    #1508444
    Tony Wong
    BPL Member

    @valshar

    Locale: San Francisco Bay Area

    Half Dome Death

    Half Dome at 3:21 pm on 06-13-09

    Half Dome Death 2

    Half Dome at 3:21 pm on 06-13-09

    Shots taken while descending on the trail from Yosemite Falls.

    #1508445
    Larry Sullivan
    Member

    @150mph

    Locale: Los Angeles

    They show the weather conditions throughout the day

    #1508447
    Nate Meinzer
    Member

    @rezniem

    Locale: San Francisco

    A 23 year old died in a fall near Mirror Lake this past weekend too.

    http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5j_Ho6ic5-M2_tQjPmGCVRmQ3me5gD98RGJT80

    Very sad. He had just moved to CA from Florida…

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 61 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Get the Newsletter

Get our free Handbook and Receive our weekly newsletter to see what's new at Backpacking Light!

Gear Research & Discovery Tools


Loading...