Topic
Lightest & Best 3 Layer Rain Jacket?
Forum Posting
A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!
Home › Forums › Gear Forums › Gear (General) › Lightest & Best 3 Layer Rain Jacket?
- This topic is empty.
-
AuthorPosts
-
Jun 13, 2015 at 1:05 pm #2206981
Their Kimtah eVent parka is VERY reasonably priced.
I have had one for several years. Used it for skiing (a lot), backpacking and around town and it still looks like new.
Jun 13, 2015 at 1:19 pm #2206984Eric… thanks… yes, going to look at the Kimtah eVent parka soon. A little heavier than I'd like, but seems to meet my other concerns… and the price sure is right.
Just wish REI still have their forever return policy on something like this especially.billy
Jun 13, 2015 at 1:33 pm #2206987do these light 2.5l or 3l jackets need to be revived of WBP?
Jun 13, 2015 at 4:14 pm #2206998ALL outerwear, at some point, need DWR reapplied or revived.
IMO, Goretex Proshell requires the least maintenance and my 150 denier Theta SV has been used in all 4 seasons.
In the summer, I slow down pace during downpours. Even so, it still keeps me dry if I layer light. I usually am in a silk weight crew underneath until I stop and then put on a puffy.
I've heard westcomb's DWR is the best
Jun 13, 2015 at 4:32 pm #2206999"you guys are not giving me the information that I asked for… want I want and need are recommendations on 3 layer jackets…"
@ Billy,
Focus!
The EMS Helix anorak I recommended is 3-layer.Jun 13, 2015 at 5:54 pm #2207010Short answer:
For me lightweight Goretex is the best raingear around. I'd look at the Arc'teryx Alpha FL or SL, and the Haglofs LIM III or parka. Both companies have good face fabrics, DWRs, and know how to make a good hood (edge to Haglofs on the last point). No pitzips, no more than one pocket, and anorak preferred, please.
Long answer:
Except for Neoshell and Gore Active I've tried pretty much every raingear technology. Ponchos don't do it for me. Driducks is fragile. PU wets out. Non breathable waterproof jackets get super sweaty, even when oversized and with enormous pitzips. Event leaks under duress.
Goretex just works. It breaths well enough once a certain level of internal humidity is reached, and keeps the weather out. If I'm hiking all day in the rain I get plenty of internal condensation, but much less than with an impermeable rain coat, and unlike the leaky PU UL coats, said internal moisture is already warm so it doesn't cost me any internal heat. I've been using the same Haglofs Ozo since early in 2011 and I've never had precip leaking in through the fabric. With top shelf coats and regular washings I've had great luck with the DWR lasting years of regular use.
Goretex has certainly been guilty of rosy marketing language to the point of misleading consumers, but said consumers have been equally guilty of lazy gear maintenance and excessively high expectations. WPB ain't perfect, but it was and remains an impressively effective piece of technology. Since I don't go on multi-week trips in full conditions with no way to clean and re-up the DWR, Goretex works fine for me.
Jun 13, 2015 at 6:18 pm #2207016Thanks David, nice write up.
billyJun 13, 2015 at 6:21 pm #2207018David, I do note that you do not draw a distinction between 2 an 3 layer wp/b jackets… would you care to comment on that?
thanks,
billyJun 13, 2015 at 7:30 pm #2207026Gore's website has a lot of information about their products and a listing of most of the current products available with links to each manufacturer's website. You just need to filter out the marketing from the facts. Remember, Gore guarantees their membrane in every one of these products and the manufacturer must build them per Gore's specifications. So there is a plethora of outer and inner fabrics. Fit and function will vary between all manufacturer's.
The challenge is determining what fits your needs. What works for one person doesn't work for another. As Dave pointed out, all of these WPB fabrics need maintenance. I always did the maintenance on my rain gear, but eventually decided I no longer have the time or patience to deal with it any more. That is part of the reason for my rain gear preferences. The other thing is, I am packing my rain gear almost every week as I get to do a hike almost every week of the year. That is hard on laminated clothing.
Jun 13, 2015 at 8:00 pm #2207029Hypothermia is the enemy. When I hike in cold wet conditions, even going over sleeting/snowing passes, sweat is less of an issue. I have a 3 layer Rab event jacket that keeps the rain and sleet out and breathes reasonably well. Again, in cold conditions, when it really matters if you're wet, I'd rather have a robust three layer jacket for the elements. Sweat is not a huge issue for me when it's just above freezing/low 40's.
It can be cold in the PNW any month when it's raining…meaning any month. (Mount Rainier may be warmer than the Cascades because it's closer to the ocean?).
In warm rains I think that every jacket will sweat out, but hypothermia is far less of an issue in these conditions.
Jun 13, 2015 at 8:49 pm #2207032The MH SL is a jacket I bought and think it is very nice and light at just 7.5 ounces. It is a breathable membrane but most importantly it feels good and NOT STICKY against wet skin.
Jun 13, 2015 at 9:06 pm #2207037Michael,
That is a 2/2.5 layer jacket. Thanks, but I was asking for suggestions of 3 layer jackets.Of course, this thread will likely degenerated into people posting whatever their favorite jacket is without regard to what the question that the original poster was asking… for suggestions on 3 layer jackets. But thanks anyway.
billy
Jun 13, 2015 at 10:38 pm #2207050My suggestions:
Arcteryx Alpha FL (11oz)
Arcteryx Alpha AR (13oz)
Arcteryx Beta LT (similar to above but with more pockets and less of a climbing cut (11oz)
Patagonia M10 (9oz)
Westcomb Switch LT (15oz)
Westcomb Shift LT (12oz)
Jun 14, 2015 at 5:20 am #2207065David,
did you use the latest air-permeable Gore-Tex Pro (so not Pro Shell) ?About DWR: as most companies used C8-based DWR's and C-8 is more or less banned because of it's negative influence on a human body, a lot of those chemical companies and outdoor companies are searching now for an alternative and the new DWR's (so with a new chemistry) are not up to the level of the old C-8 based DWR's, repellency-wise or particularly durability-wise, for now. So the search goes on. So, even recent experience with the DWR of a certain company, might not be relevant.
Jun 14, 2015 at 5:35 am #2207067When I know i'm going to be in cold rain I bring my Rab Demand (smock, 3 layer eVent, perfect hood, 11 oz) – it's what I used bike commuting in Chicago for the last 2 winters and springs I was there.
I also really like the Haglofs 3 layer Goretex Active (?) jacket that I have (12 oz) – but it won't fit over my butt anymore. BUT I WILL WEAR IT AGAIN!!!! lol…..
Jun 14, 2015 at 7:06 am #2207074Great suggestions Trill and Gen… any idea who has the best/longest return policy?
Would really like to buy an expensive jacket like this from someone who has a forever and for anything return policy like REI used to have…Jen: "…but it won't fit over my butt anymore. BUT I WILL WEAR IT AGAIN!!!! lol….."
NOW THAT's a change of thread topic I'm sure we'd all find acceptable :)
(a picture is worth a thousand words?)billy
Jun 14, 2015 at 7:11 am #2207075I've had great success with both coupons/deals AND return policies (including a pair of pants I just wore around the house but ended up with tons of charliedog hair on it….i felt really bad about sending them back but they just did NOT fit) from CAMPSAVER.com. They've been awesome…
Another not-so-well-known site but again, great sales and great return policy is backcountryedge.com (https://www.backcountryedge.com/on-sale.html?trk_msg=9BJQL1BDQG2K17FV6K3EMEA3MG&trk_contact=LSU1KM1GH4VINCENCCFD9EBD4K&utm_source=Listrak&utm_medium=Email&utm_term=Shop+the+Best+Deals+of+the+Season+at+Backcountry+Edge!&utm_campaign=6-11-15+Best+Deals+2015+LC&utm_content=6-11-15+Best+Deals+2015+LC+Msg1)
They also have a lifetime no-questions-asked return policy.
And of course, the favorite backcountry.com also has a lifetime returns policy.
Good luck in your search – may it be fruitful.
And no, you can't see a picture of my butt.
Jun 14, 2015 at 7:25 am #2207079"And no, you can't see a picture of my butt."
Now Jen… nothing untoward intended… butt I do think we need to see exactly what the fit problem is you're having with that jacket…
billy
Jun 14, 2015 at 8:30 am #2207089Backcountry.com has a much more limited return policy now. Once REI lowered the bar they didn't have to match it anymore and lowered it that much more. Any used returns only get you store credit and have a shorter return window.
They do honor items purchased under their old policy like REI does.
Jun 14, 2015 at 9:34 pm #2207285> Those UL 6 oz jackets generally don't let water IN – they simply soak through the OUTER
> layer and then do not allow the fabric to breathe at all any longer (particularly in the
> shoulders, or under pressure from the shoulder straps). You are getting wet from sweat on the
> inside…THAT is why they feel like they are wetting through.
DING DING DING DING!!!!I am glad someone finally brought this up! 100% correct! As a hiker, backpacker, climber in the PNW with over 40 years of experience I can tell you if it is IMPOSSIBLE to stay dry if you are moving at a good clip in the rain in moderate temperatures! If you MUST stay dry you can stop and set up camp, put on the best rainshell you can afford and move slowly enough that you don't sweat, or just get wet, either from the inside (sweat) or the outside (rain) no other alternative.
The myth of a waterproof breathable shell that will keep you dry in PNW rainstorm has been perpetuated by the fabric and clothing industry. Unfortunately for us backpackers the laws of physics still apply!
Jun 14, 2015 at 9:57 pm #2207289"> Those UL 6 oz jackets generally don't let water IN – they simply soak through the OUTER
> layer and then do not allow the fabric to breathe at all any longer (particularly in the
> shoulders, or under pressure from the shoulder straps). You are getting wet from sweat on the
> inside…THAT is why they feel like they are wetting through.
DING DING DING DING!!!!I am glad someone finally brought this up! 100% correct!"
Not in my world, Jim.
I can tell you for sure that my 7 oz 2 layer rain jacket absolutely leaks. And many others have reported the same. I know the difference between sweat and a leak.
Obviously both can and do happen. For the previous poster to make the absolute statement that all "Those UL 6 oz jackets generally don't let water IN" is absolutely wrong… at least for some jackets… especially ones that have been worn a under a backpack for some time.I have been doing this about 40 years, have owned wp/b jackets since the first generation Gortex and have used them everywhere from rain forest environments to mountains over 20,000 feet. And I am well aware of getting wet from sweat. But that is noting new. I can be soaked in the summer in the Sierra on a clear, dry day wearing only a T-Shirt and shorts. Daaaaa… you guys report on sweat like it is some secrete or something to be discovered. Good Grief.
Bottom line is this: Whether it's boots or jackets or pants, it's better to we warm and wet from sweat than to be cold and wet from rain. With a good WP/B jacket that does not leak in the rain you will be a little less wet, but still wet and warm. With a WP/P jacket that leaks/lets rain inside you will be wet and cold.
billy
Jun 14, 2015 at 10:33 pm #2207294Woubeir,
I spoke with a Gore rep today who confirmed the new Goretex Pro IS the new pro shell- just a different backer and membrane.
Jun 15, 2015 at 2:58 am #2207307Noticed this on Gear Junkie today, it won't be available until Feb 2016.
http://gearjunkie.com/columbia-outdry-extreme-waterproof-jackets
Jun 15, 2015 at 3:41 am #2207308Trill Daddy,
I know that. And I know the backer on the new Pro is ripstop and the one on the old Pro Shell isn't.
It's just that I wanted to know if DC has used the old Pro Shell or also already this new Pro as several reviews elsewhere said there was a real difference.Jun 15, 2015 at 7:12 am #2207327"Whether it's boots or jackets or pants, it's better to we warm and wet from sweat than to be cold and wet from rain. With a good WP/B jacket that does not leak in the rain you will be a little less wet, but still wet and warm. With a WP/P jacket that leaks/lets rain inside you will be wet and cold."
I just don't understand this statement. I've done a LOT of wet hiking in my 35 years of backpacking (and working outside) around the world, as well as canoeing in the Boundary Waters. If you are wet inside your jacket, you are wet. Who cares how it got there – if you are wet you will still be cold unless it's really hot out, in which case who needs the rain jacket? The rain feels good at that point.
why is only wet from rain the cold stuff and wet from sweat the warm stuff?? the whole point is to try to manage moisture, period. I sweat in the dead of winter, which means if I don't manage that well then I'm hypothermic.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Forum Posting
A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!
Our Community Posts are Moderated
Backpacking Light community posts are moderated and here to foster helpful and positive discussions about lightweight backpacking. Please be mindful of our values and boundaries and review our Community Guidelines prior to posting.
Get the Newsletter
Gear Research & Discovery Tools
- Browse our curated Gear Shop
- See the latest Gear Deals and Sales
- Our Recommendations
- Search for Gear on Sale with the Gear Finder
- Used Gear Swap
- Member Gear Reviews and BPL Gear Review Articles
- Browse by Gear Type or Brand.