Yet Another DIY Stove Windscreen
- This topic has 8 replies, 5 voices, and was last updated 2 years, 6 months ago by
.
-
Or YADIYSW, for grey-haired fans of YACC.
Very rough tests, no field experience, probably been done before, could be optimized, good enough for me.
The concept is pretty simple. Start a with an aluminum roasting pan from the supermarket, cut, fold, and crimp, and end up with this:
The stove with canister sits on the bottom tab, holding the windscreen in place when it’s, you know, like windy.
Brought about 600 ml tap water to boil, and high-simmered for another 15 minutes. Canister never got hot to the touch – barely warmed up at all.
Ran more informal tests using a box fan:
Approximate times to reach vigorous boil from about 600 ml tap water.
2:15 No fan with windscreen
3:45 Fan with windscreen
5:45 Fan without windscreenAll tests done at the same half throttle, so fuel consumption should be comparable to boil time. Tests designed to see if the idea is worthwhile, not for comparison to other tests.
Windscreen weight: 33 grams
Final folded size: 125 x 190 mm
Construction time: About an hour.Notes:
– Trim and flatten the roasting pan into one big rectangular sheet of aluminum.
– Don’t worry about exact dimensions.
– Metal snips and a hard straight edge are your friend.
– The tall side panels should be a little narrower than the tall back panel, to make folding for storage easier. I fold the bottom flap in first, then the side panels.
– To start construction, I tri-folded the aluminum, then cut off part of the side panel bottoms to make the bottom flap. Along the way I folded over sharp edges about 6 mm, mostly to prevent damage to my fingers.
– The bottom flap is about 60 mm deep, which fits well under my MSR Pocket Rocket Deluxe on a 110 gram canister. The outer flap edge is under the center of the canister, with the back panel not quite touching the back stove arm. Most upright canister stoves have similar dimensions, but check before measuring and cutting.
– In case it’s not obvious, put the back panel into the wind, with the stove valve and pot handles downwind. It’s easy to move around if you forget, and the windscreen never got too hot to handle.
– The PRD piezo igniter is opposite the valve. It’s easy to lean the back panel, click the igniter, then push the panel back.
– In general, this windscreen should accomodate a wide range of stoves and pots. Might need tweaking for something unusual.
– No, the folded windscreen doesn’t fit inside my pot with the lid on. I’ll need to carry it elsewhere.
– Probably won’t last forever. Easy to recycle, easy to build a new one.
– All the usual warnings apply. Don’t be stupid!
– What doesn’t work: leaving the short side panels on and folding to form a three-layer aluminum base. Too lumpy, makes stove and pot less stable.
– Also doesn’t work: no bottom tab/base. Blows around in the wind too much.
– I was a bit disappointed that the windscreen didn’t have a weak Moulder effect. Might paint the windscreen interior black, hoping it will warm the canister some, but not too much.
— Rex
Might want a sturdy envelope to keep sharp-ish folded windscreen edges and corners from damaging other gear in your pack. A few minutes with scissors, a readily-available source of small Tyvek sheets (if that’s your Priority :-), and Tyvek tape, produced this:
Notes:
– Leave about 10 mm around the edges to make inserting and removing the windscreen easier
– Leave an extra 35 mm on one short edge to make an envelope flap to tuck in over the windscreen. I trimmed the side edges at an angle to make flap insertion easier.
– Tyvek tape is wicked sticky. Handle carefully.
– Weight: 6 grams
Enjoy!
— Rex
Credit: I started with the second windscreen described in this video
Good construction tips, including rolling down the folded edges with a big socket-wrench socket.
However, when I used this design on a windy day at GGG 2022, the windscreen literally blew away from the pot. Disappointed, I started cogitating on a simple solution.
— Rex
that’s sort of like
I use this when car camping
One thing is heat reflects from the burner, off the aluminum, to the canister
If the canister is warm enough to start, then reflected heat will keep it going. Down to 20 F with cheap butane.
I also have the heat exchanger around my pot, but it would work without that
Jon
I never built the first design in TheGoatMumbler video. With the second design’s wide open front, didn’t see a need for air inlet holes. I took one photo while the fan was running showing the flames:
Looks good to me, but I don’t spend a lot of time staring at canister stove flames under pots.
Jerry
With a larger aluminum pan, someone could make the bottom flap big enough to reflect heat upward. This modified design would still fold easily but weigh a few grams more.
Or cobble something together with a second pan and aluminum foil tape. Or take a bottom reflector for cold weather. Hmmm …
Bill
Let us know how well this design works for you. Probably a long time before I get to 10,000+ feet elevation to try.
Thanks all for your feedback.
— Rex
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
