Dec 22, 2015 at 4:57 am #3371743Virginia LSpectator
So, I’ve seen a ton of gear lists that specify the SmartWater brand vs any other disposable water bottles. Though I’ve never picked one up (other brands are cheaper, my trips aren’t too long, and I can easily find other 1L bottles), the prevalence of these bottles on the forum makes me curious. Why are they so popular?Dec 22, 2015 at 5:17 am #3371744Monte MastersonBPL Member
@septimiusLocale: Changes Often
It’s because of the shape, long and tall with a small diameter. They can be secured to a pack strap and ride better than other bottles. I personally like the 20 oz Gatorade bottles for pack straps because the mouth is larger and that allows for easier refilling and drying.
The SmartWater bottles are also quite durable and the opening on the caps tend to not leak, therefore you don’t have to unscrew the cap in order to drink like with a Gatorade bottle. The narrow shape can fit down into a pack better too.Dec 22, 2015 at 5:33 am #3371747George FBPL Member
I like the shape of the bottles for storing, on my REI Flash 65 I could easily fit two in each side and even get two more in the front pocket for long water carries. I also like the texture. When drinking I can squeeze the bottle to get more faster, that doesn’t work with every bottle.Dec 22, 2015 at 5:47 am #3371751matthew kModerator
Dec 22, 2015 at 6:40 am #3371759Brad RogersBPL Member
- Durability is good.
- Smooth exterior goes in/out of pack easily.
- Good thread compatibility with Sawyer filters.
- 750ml Sport Top works for backflushing Sawyer filters.
@mocs123Locale: Southeast Tennessee
While I have long used Gatoraide bottles with Aqumira, I have thought about trying a Sawyer filter so that has made me look at narrow mouth bottles.
I have have noticed the Smartwater bottles have a very nice lid, which is something that is becoming harder and harder to find these days on disposable bottles.Dec 22, 2015 at 7:33 am #3371764Jim CBPL Member
@jimothyLocale: Georgia, USA
For me, it’s all about the flip top. The flip cap is easy to pop up, keeps the spout clean if you drop your bottle, and prevents the water from leaking.
Propel Fitness Water has a similar cap; I’ve used and like both. As a small bonus, Propel bottles are slightly larger: 750ml vs 700ml.
If you’ve got a narrow mouth bottle you like better (because of size or whatever), it’s likely the flip cap from a Smartwater or Propel bottle will fit. The caps also fit a Platypus bag, though I haven’t tested to see how leak proof this setup is.
Finally, it’s probably a good idea to bring a spare cap or two, just in case you lose your cap while refilling. That’s true whether you use flip caps or regular screw on lids.Dec 22, 2015 at 2:59 pm #3371871Roger CaffinModerator
@rcaffinLocale: Wollemi & Kosciusko NPs, Europe
Maybe Smart water bottles compensate for the owners?
Ducks for flaming…
CheersDec 22, 2015 at 4:31 pm #3371896windsor akBPL Member
The tall narrow shape and smooth sides makes it perfect for getting the bottle out of and back into the side stretch pocket of my Mariposa Plus without taking the pack off or doing contortions to reach.
Compitable with a Sawyer Mini.
Have not had one spring a leak after repeated drops.
Carrying the bottle raises my IQ by 1 point and makes me more smrt.Dec 22, 2015 at 4:42 pm #3371902Jerry AdamsBPL Member
@retiredjerryLocale: Oregon and Washington
I just re-use any convenient bottle, but Smartwater are a good choice. Some bottles are too heavy or aren’t durable enough or don’t have the thread size for Sawyer filters.
There’s the “virality” of it – people use them because they’ve heard a lot of other people do.
The price isn’t important if you re-use for a while. $1 (or whatever) amortized over a period of time is unimportant.Dec 22, 2015 at 5:04 pm #3371907Valerie EBPL Member
@wildtownerLocale: Grand Canyon State
Smartwater bottles also have completely smooth sides/bottoms, which make them easier to keep clean (avoid bacteria).
Personally, I prefer shorter, wider 1L bottles for water (usually the ones from flavoured fizzy water) and a Gatorade 1L bottle for coffee/flavoured drinks (easier to fill; easier to pour in coffee crystals). Both of these weigh slightly less than the Smartwater bottles, and seem to be very durable (the most I’ve used one for is 500 continuous miles).
Good point about exchanging the caps — I’ve done that before. Just test your setup at home to be 100% sure the newly-paired bottles/caps don’t leak, even when left on their sides, or shaken vigorously.Dec 22, 2015 at 5:17 pm #3371911David ThomasBPL Member
@davidinkenaiLocale: North Woods. Far North.
+1 on bringing an extra cap. So little weight, so valuable if you need it.
Plumbing doesn’t have to stop when you leave home, so I have a variety of water-bottle caps adapting to be shower heads, or adapted to tubing for more pressure through a water filter. Some of which can double as an emergency replacement cap.
Also, from Water Bottles 101: if you wish your water bottle was a little less slippery or didn’t flex quite so much; you need a place to store your one to two feet of Lueko tape, duct tape, etc, and wrapped around your water bottle is one good place that takes up no extra room and is readily accessible. It also identifies your water bottle as yours.
from Water Bottles 101, second semester: tie a sturdy loop of string around the neck of the bottle, securing it with glue or tape if needed. Sometimes the footing down to the creek is tricky, but if clipped to your trekking pole, your water bottle can be dunked in the creek, remotely while you stay on the footbridge or well ashore. This can be really handy while snow camping because the little trickles of flowing water always seem out of reach or a meter of thin ice away.Dec 22, 2015 at 8:11 pm #3371926Katherine .BPL Member
yep, the sports cap on the 750 ml.Dec 22, 2015 at 8:27 pm #3371932Ken ThompsonBPL Member
@hereLocale: Right there
They’re the smart choice.Dec 22, 2015 at 8:49 pm #3371939J RBPL Member
I agree with all the benefits others have pointed out, but I think the biggest driver at least for me is that they match well with the Sawyer Squeeze and Mini filters.
First, the SW threads match the Sawyer filters. The threads on most disposable water bottles do not.
Second, the whole way you use a Sawyer filter is to squeeze the dirty reservoir, and you’ll be doing this repeatedly over a multi-day hike so you want a dirty reservoir that isn’t too fragile that it will easily crack from being crushed and re-expanded multiple times but also isn’t too stiff that it makes squeezing difficult. The SW bottles fit a sweet spot in this durability/flexibility trade-off, easy to squeeze but durable enough not to bust with repeated use, while most other disposable water bottles are too flimsy to last through many squeezing cycles and Gatorade-type bottles are too stiff for squeezing.
For those reasons I use a SW bottle for the dirty reservoir but not for clean — for that I use a flimsier, lighter disposable water bottle with a flip-top nozzle. That also helps keep it really clear which bottle is clean and which is dirty.Dec 23, 2015 at 10:06 am #3372011Edward JursekBPL Member
@nedjursekgmail-comLocale: Pacific Northwest
1.) Shape – tall shape fits great in my outside web pockets.
2.) Durability – strong bottle, but not too heavy.
3.) Sawyer compatibility – love the flip top cap. I will keep a spare cap as well, and use it on my Sawyer even when I am just using one of my Evernew bags.
Depending on the length of the trip, I will also carry a very light/fragile12oz bottle for hooch and a 1L Gatorade bottle for dirty water/pee bottle.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.