From these related threads, it sounds like a first priority is finding light primary hiking footwear that fits and works best in the terrain where you trek. That’s also what I concluded, trekking in the north country of New England and northern Colorado. Do not need someone to sell me on some other primary footwear, when it took years to find what I have that works.
Having decided on the above, what about the OP’s water crossing issues? As these threads attest, grievous injury can result from something that is too thin over sharper rocks, or too slippery (even with at least one trek pole of course). Especially if the current is much stronger than apparent.
Wanted to have something to resort to, so looked for a thick closed cell foam sole, plenty of grip to keep the foot in the shoe, and plenty of protection for the feet. Came up with these (Ignore the cheap plastic ones on the bottom left):
The ones on the right were the thickest and lightest I could find in Walmart, so added the straps to eliminate any flip-flop. Then added some anklet dive sox to add protection and insulation for the feet (shown at top).
These are strictly for crossings (carrying two 25-30 lb. dogs one at a time – so one crossing for each dog, and 5 for me including the extra trip for the pack (These were spring runout conditions, and the stream bottom was very rocky – at the base of Long Mountain, in the Phillips Brook reserve in northern NH). With a dog under one arm and holding the pole with the other arm, and the stream bottom moving underfoot.
I think these worked because the thick foam soles conformed somewhat to the creek bottom. So enjoyed a long, and dry, day of trekking. Weight for the whole deal is 8.42 oz for the pair, anklets, and a thin stuff sack that fits perfectly.
A few points: 1) Would it be worth the extra weight if there were no dogs along (but forget about sun drying in runout – it is water world); 2) We had to do it all over again on the trip back; and 3) What to wear for comfort at camp sites. Still, I keep these around just in case a similar situation comes up and the extra half pound seems better than sloshing across in whatever you call your hiking boots.
P.S. The ‘are you a human’ test when posting is an incredibly bad idea. Don’t forget, I am paying for the privilege of posting on this forum, not trying to cadge a Covid shot.



