I’ve got a nice predicament in choosing between the Lost Coast trail or Thousand Island Lake via PCT coming up.
I have a 2 night permit for mid to late August for the Lost Coast Trail (Mattole to Black Sands). Originally, I was set to go with a good buddy of mine who’m I haven’t had a proper chance to catch up with in years… we figured taking this leisurely pace and car ride up to catch up, joke around, and reminisce on the good ol days would do us some good. Anyways, he had to cancel. So this leaves me with a long drive up and down from Los Angeles and a whole lot of sitting on the beach time, waiting for the sun to set… albeit in a gorgeous environment. I’ve never done this trail, and have always wanted to. But now that it’s within site, I just can’t seem to pump myself up for sitting around for most of the afternoon, waiting for the sun to set, thinking about a lonely 11ish hour drive back down home.
Meanwhile, a buddy of mine has an overnight permit for Thousand Island Lake that I can jump onto… when we’ve hiked in the past, he can keep a good pace, but with his pack weight, it’s harder for him to hike longer distances. He’s coming along with 2 other people who I have yet to meet, but by all accounts are lovely people. They’re also bringing their dogs, which I’ve heard usually poop out at about the 3 mile mark and then get carried the rest of the way, haha. I figure if time permits, I can just hike past Thousand lakes up to Donohue Pass and back or loop back around Waugh Lake to get in a good 19ish mile day and some extra time on the PCT, while they set up camp and hang out by Thousand Island Lake. I’ve done this trail before – but many years ago, so I feel it will still be worthwhile to rehash.
These are both very short trips, in the spectrum of things, but with not a lot of available time out and about this year I’m trying to get the most bang for my buck.
Does anyone have any special insight into either of these trails that could help me definitively make a decision on which way to go? They both look great on paper, but have circumstances that seem to set things back a bit on both ends. Any help in making a clearer decision would be much appreciated.

