Day hike shelter for 5

Would a tarp not work?  is it so windy you need sidewalls?

I’d vote for a big flat tarp or two. Even in silnylon you could do this at around a pound per tarp.

Just get a lightweight bothy bag if all you’re using it for is breaks and snacks. They’re perfect for that use.

I think a 9×9 pyramid would work, but be a little tight for 5 hikers eating lunch. I think a pyramid would be better than a bothy bag for rain, not as good in high winds, probably about equal for snow. A few makers have 10×10 pyramids, one of those would definitely have enough room. Flat tarps would be more work to set up than a pyramid.

Depends also on the forest… A 10’x10’x72″ mid is hhhyyuuuuggge. Footprint and height could be an issue in a forested area depending on density of canopy.

Trailstar. There is a photo here somewhere with at least six full size guys under one.

Trailstar sounds good.

https://rab.equipment/us/group-shelter-4-6-bothy

But of course. ☝️

As above; get a big bothy-bag, a 6 to 8P bothy shelter is light enough and room to spread out the lunch.

If you use hiking poles just prop the middle up with an extended pole or two, ditto for the 4 corners

Thanks everyone! I should have said that this is for a relaxed guiding with “normal” people, so I have to consider comfort as well, but I’m asking from you because I do my personal adventures with your kind of mindset.

Bigger tarp might do it. Google image search for group tarp gives ideas. One thing I’m not sure is wind-driven rain and snow, so walls on three sides anchored down and one open side for a view to lake would be perfect. Doesn’t these kind of things always tend to go to the MYOG route ;)

I feel like the comfort and level of my service requires something a bit more substantial than the bothys, like Rab’s Group Shelters. I’ve never seen those, just judging by the photos.

The winds we experience here in Southern Finland aren’t too strong and the forest gives protection, but the chilling factor and wind-driven rain and snow is why I’m looking for walls.

I have a Lunar Duo, which is almost 10 feet long, so 10×10 mid should be ok. Being too high isn’t a concern.

I’m having hard time judging the Trailstar from photos, it either looks just perfect or absolutely not. The roof angles seem low and the height very low, if pitched for better protection. Could it be pitched with the rear against ground and the door side higher? The door also looks low, it doesn’t have to be walk in, but neither on all fours is desired.

Thanks for the food for thought!

^^^

” I feel like the comfort and level of my service requires something a bit more substantial than the bothys, like Rab’s Group Shelters. I’ve never seen those, just judging by the photos.”

http://www.summitgear.co.uk/product/supalite-bothy-bag-4-person/

Click on Testimonials

“… for relaxed guiding with “normal” people…”

Ahhh, pardon me  …

https://www.aliexpress.com/item/Ultralight-Outdoor-Camping-Teepee-double-side-Silicon-coated-20D-nylon-Pyramid-Tent-3-Person-Large-Tent/32848294123.html?spm=2114.search0104.3.104.1aca1c98JF0RPZ&ws_ab_test=searchweb0_0,searchweb201602_5_10065_10068_10130_10890_5730315_10547_319_10546_10548_317_10545_10696_10924_453_10084_454_10083_10618_10920_5729215_10921_10922_10307_537_536_10059_10884_10887_10928_100031_321_322_10103,searchweb201603_51,ppcSwitch_0&algo_expid=0d892e2e-62c9-4636-a19b-adba040980b1-13&algo_pvid=0d892e2e-62c9-4636-a19b-adba040980b1

Crammed bothys may be a little tight but one larger than minimum is cosy rather than crowded and the difference in weight between a 6P and an 8P would mean a lot of room for very little extra weight. Granted a tarp means you can stand up but if using a tarp you should also take along a smaller separate tarp to use as a windbreak and eat on the leeward side or take a much bigger tarp with a side pegged down to the ground, a long rectangle rather than a flying diamond pitch.

I’ve been looking at this tarp shelter from 3F for a while now as a winter group eating shelter for snow camping

https://www.aliexpress.com/item/3F-UL-Gear-A-Tower-8-12persons-7-4m-professional-sun-shelter-awning-canopy-tarp-outdoor/32856439970.html?ws_ab_test=searchweb0_0,searchweb201602_5_10065_10068_10130_10547_319_317_10548_10696_10924_453_10084_454_10083_10618_10920_10921_10922_10307_537_536_10131_10132_10133_10059_10884_10887_100031_321_322_10103,searchweb201603_51,ppcSwitch_0&algo_expid=84b2b408-079a-48c8-b4a6-f92915fee2ad-34&algo_pvid=84b2b408-079a-48c8-b4a6-f92915fee2ad

I don’t know anything about 3F, but I’ve heard about Chinese so-called waterproof fabrics that started leaking fairly soon after purchase.

Just wondering…

Why do these bothys (bothies?) have tube shaped openings? I’m guessing it’s because you can get ventilation with the tube sagging down keeping rain out but maybe there is another function?

Thanks everyone, I think I would’ve made the wrong choice if I didn’t ask you. Tarp seems to be the obvious choice for space and weight. I’ve never used tarps, so it wasn’t obvious to me.

I went full silly comparing 10×10 mid and 10×10 tarp for sitting up, with half legged people, enjoy:

“Why do these bothys (bothies?) have tube shaped openings? ”
Simple and economical way to have a vent that can be sealed if needed.
no stiffeners or zips.
Mikko,
I am guessing that the pole in your pyramid is around 80″ and that your drawing does not include the typical inward sag of pyramid tents ?

Franco, no, it doesn’t. I didn’t go that far, even without the sagging the mid looks small for sitting up. I used Nigor WickiUp 4’s measurements, it’s 68″ high, the models are around 6′ tall and they are sitting at spots that have around 35″ of height.

If everyone’s sitting back against the pole, then there’s plenty of space, but that feels more like a survival atmosphere rather than gathering around.

Anyone have opinions or tips for setting up the tarp? Wind protection from 1 or 2 sides and a roof. Is the 10×10 too small, from real life experience?

For wind protection one edge of the tarp needs to be pegged tight to the ground, so rectangular tarps work better for this, 3 * 6m [ 10 * 18′] is a good size pitched 1/3  * 2/3

I have the BD Megalite and it would work for 4-5 people to sit up in.  For your requirements, I’d personally just go for a 8×10 tarp and just pitch it as a lean-to.

Thanks for the help. I bought a 10×15 tarp. Now I just need to try out the different setups in various spots to see what works for me.