I'm intrigued by this discussion for a few reasons… first, because zPacks already makes the best solo shelter and it is lighter than this, the Solplex. And it fits a 6' human with PLENTY of room to spare. I am intrigued by this shelter, but other than "extra" room for things like putting all your gear inside the tent with you, or maybe a dog, what benefit does this shelter offer over a Solplex?
Also, Dan, I wanted to disagree with/pick apart your points, sorry/not sorry in advance…
You say "…The overlapping door is neat although I suspect it decreases structural integrity."
Why do you presume this? I own a solplex with this door system. Not only is it weather proof, it has absolutely zero negative effect in terms of structural integrity. Most of that has to do with the orange guy line that runs from the top of the tent to the ground, the force is not all on the door panels, at all. That would suck. As it is, its bomber. I've ridden sever thunderstorms in my solplex, enough rain to cause standing water on the ground and flow under the tent. Never an issue. At all. And wind… yeah it can handle wind. This one looks just as strong.
You also say "Zpacks know how to make shelters that are light. I would like to see them focus more on making them simple as well. It's like they're trying to be different for no real reason."
Seriously? What could possibly be more simple than one pole and a few stakes? Its even less complicated than the Solplex. The fact that they sew in the net and floor to make it easy and appeal to people who like tents, is that why its complicated? I don't get your point. There are a lot of benefits to a hex over the traditional rectangle, mostly when it comes to wind. More angles = more wind breaks. Basic physics/math, right?
You then go on to say "For 3oz more, one could buy a cuben DuoMid + solo inner. That combo is simpler to pitch, has more vestibule space, it's likely better in tough weather and it would enable you to go even lighter than the Altaplex outside bug season with just a ground cloth."
Anyone buying an altaplex does not need to go lighter. Its a tent, not a tarp with inner net. There is no "outside bug season" for some of us. Furthermore, this is also for people who want simplicity, not two separate things to deal with. Which brings me to the next point… how is a two-part tent with inner-net "simpler to pitch?" It certainly isn't simpler because it needs more stakes, both the inner net and tarp need their own sets. It isn't simpler because you need to set up two things one at a time… it isn't simpler to clip them together or deal with multiple pieces in the wind, is it? Furthermore, while I didn't check the price as I write this, I doubt its cheaper. Usually I notice the two piece systems are the same or more expensive.
Now don't get me wrong, I'm not against a two-piece shelter in any way, but it sure isn't simpler at all. I can't help but to see you just say a lot of things that are either not thought out, not based on actual physics or logic, and just emotionally spewed out for whatever reason. Just had to provide the opposite perspective based on my experience with this style of shelter. You really bring the point home when you say:
"I'm not trying to be a downer, I just don't understand the Zpacks fever these days. There's a lot of other manufacturers making comparable but better sewn and better designed gear (i.e Locus Gear, MLD)."
This post isn't some competition over which cottage company is "better." Yes, zpacks has some sloppy stitching once in a while. This isn't REI I don't care, personally. That's just about the only piece of feedback that has any truth to it here.
Overall, this looks like a pretty cool shelter. I think what you refer to as "zpacks fever" is actually just a lot of people realizing that the simplicity and ease of using a one-piece, all inclusive and bug free tent that weighs close to 16 ounces is hard to beat. Some of us aren't looking for the 10 oz and under shelter, we want a "bomber" tent made of cuben in this weight range. I would still recommend the solplex over this. It can take a shit ton of hard wind and rain, and looks like it has better ventilation. No condensation issues at all.
I can't say enough great things about my arc blast either… so yeah I highly recommend zpacks and their shelters, but I would even more highly recommend checking out the solplex or duplex tents before you pull the trigger here.