Topic

Most comfortable lightweight pack?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 22 posts - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)
PostedDec 8, 2013 at 10:11 am

I am still trying to decide which pack to buy for the AT next year, and comfort is a HUGE factor. I'd rather carry an extra 1/2 pound of pack than be even slightly less comfortable.

The other factor is durability.

So right now I am considering a cuben Circuit, a Windrider (probably 2400), or an Arc Blast (probably 52 L).

Everyone talks about how comfortable the Circuits are, so that is the main reason I am still considering it. The Windrider sounds very durable, but maybe not as comfortable.

I have recently taken an interest in the Arc Blast. It looks very comfortable, but I would want to make sure that it is durable enough.

Any thoughts?

The bottom line is that comfort + durability + features are more important than cost + weight.

PostedDec 8, 2013 at 10:16 am

You're up in the $300+ range, and price isn't an issue… so you could get a McHale pack made before your AT hike and never buy another pack again. I bet you could get a pretty great minimalist one made around $500 and have a competitive weight to boot.

James holden BPL Member
PostedDec 8, 2013 at 10:23 am

Comfort depends on mostly on fit … Its really that simple

What is comfortable for someone else may not be for you … And theres no realistic way to tell on BPL

The best way is to go try out each pack in person under load for hours

If you do order online keep it in pristine condition while you walk around the yard testing it out

Youll lose put on shipping for any bag that doesnt work

;)

PostedDec 8, 2013 at 10:29 am

spending $500 would make cost become a factor!

But I do live in Portland so it would be easy enough to got to Seattle to get a custom pack made…

Justin Baker BPL Member
PostedDec 8, 2013 at 10:50 am

I find ula packs to be comfortable. They aren't the cushy "oooh aaah this feels nice when you first put it on" comfortable, but my ohm pretty much melts into my back and I forget it's there. It's very durable and the stretchy front pouch gets used a lot.

Steven Paris BPL Member
PostedDec 8, 2013 at 11:13 am

Matthew,

In case you didn't know, Mountain Shop carries HMG packs you can try on. Also, SMD is in Beaverton and should be releasing their new pack line soon. Finally, MLD is going to release a new version of their full suspension Exodus sometime next year.

PostedDec 8, 2013 at 11:15 am

You are in a discussion area that depends a lot on body shape and pack fit. Since you mentioned two of the packs that I have used I can give you my opinion on comfort from them as they pertain to me (158 lbs, 5'8") — the waist belt on the Circuit would after a few days of use start giving me a soreness on my left side (upper pelvic bone / hip flexor area). Since switching to the HMG 3400, I have no such issues there nor any new 'hot spot' areas caused by how the pack rides. I have tried adjusting the Circuit's double waist strap webbing, but the issue never went away, just lessened. I only carry about 13 lbs BW for a weekend so I just dealt with it until I moved to the HMG.

So, could it be my leg length versus torso length and how the Circuit sat on my hips – maybe. Again, all has to do with your personal comfort so you might try to get the packs you are considering on loaner and try them out for a weekend before you invest one way or another.

Edward Jursek BPL Member
PostedDec 8, 2013 at 11:29 am

I would look at something custom from Zimmerbuilt if you know what features you want. His workmanship is top notch and his prices are great. I have one of his packs and love it. He has great customer service skills and gets rave reviews from fellow BPLers.

PostedDec 8, 2013 at 11:41 am

Strange, Mark… I find the ULA waist belt the most comfortable I've ever used… and I've used a lot… just goes to show that fit is a very personal thing…

Billy

PostedDec 8, 2013 at 12:09 pm

In addition to the ones already mentioned, you should also consider packs by Elemental Horizons (see BPL review) or you could pick up a used Granite Gear Vapor Trail (older version) at a good price.

jscott Blocked
PostedDec 8, 2013 at 12:25 pm

I use a Luxury Lite frame with a Gossamer Gear bag attached, instead of the cylinders that come with that frame. This gives terrific load transfer off of my shoulders to a very comfortable hip belt. This pack also carries a bear canister great–it fits right in to the L shaped 'flange' on the bottom of the frame. A bit heavy at just over two pounds.

I personally haven't been able to find an internal frame pack, even with stays, that achieves the kind of load transfer that is provided by an external frame pack. So, like the OP, I'm willing to sacrifice a bit of weight to achieve greater comfort.

PostedDec 8, 2013 at 12:31 pm

I use the Kalais. Extremely comfortable! But I was only able to put 600 miles on it last year. Great communications and guarantee from the company also. Talk to Mathiew at Elemental Horizons.

PostedDec 8, 2013 at 12:38 pm

Would be great if posters would include what weight they carried for their professed comfort…

makes a difference… just about ANY pack is comfortableat 20lb, me thinks

thanks,

Billy

PostedDec 8, 2013 at 3:06 pm

Suggest you get one of the Hyperlight Mountain Gear packs. They're built using a Cuben hybrid, and are very light, durable, *and* comfortable.

Miner BPL Member
PostedDec 8, 2013 at 3:20 pm

As someone mentioned, pack comfort is a function of fit (not everyone will carry the same pack the same). However, its also a function of how you pack it. If you find a pack uncomfortable, try packing it differently.

That said, the ULA circuit is a good pack and served me well on the PCT in 2009 which has larger water carries, bear canister requirement in the Sierra Neveda, and longer food carries (some carry 10-12 days of food in the Sierra) than anything you'll see on the AT. However, given that you are interested in the 2400 Windrider Pack, wouldn't a ULA OHM be a better choice than the Circuit? Its more comparable to the Windrider 2400 in size, lighter weight (in non-cuben) and still a comfortable pack.

But the biggest question should be, just how large of a backpack do you need and what sort of weight you'll be carrying. That is the first thing you should consider followed by price, fit, and weight of pack.

M B BPL Member
PostedDec 8, 2013 at 3:26 pm

Comfort has a *lot* to do with how much your pack weighs.
At 17 lbs any pack is comfortable

The Circuit is a great pack up to 30 lbs.

IF you bend the al stay to match your back closely
AND if the torso length fits you good.

Cannot emphasize those two enough, especially the last one.

PostedDec 8, 2013 at 4:10 pm

I went to the Mountain Shop in Portland with the intent to buy a CiloGear WorkSack. I tried it on as well as several packs, both empty and loaded. The clear winner in comfort was the HMG ice pack. I was surprised to find such a minimal pack so comfortable, but individual fit is everything. I ended up ordering directly from HMG because the Mountain Shop only had the 2400 and I wanted the 3400. Fit is the same and I'm very happy with it. You're in luck living in Portland. You can try out just about everything.

PostedDec 8, 2013 at 7:02 pm

I was preparing for an AT hike (that didn't happen) a couple of years ago and tried on a lot of different packs. Since you'll be wearing the pack everyday for (hopefully) a few months, its worth the extra investment to try on a bunch of packs and pay the extra shipping.
Packs I've liked are the gossamer gear gorilla. In addition to super light loads with no frame, I used it as my ice climbing and skiing pack for a while. Not a good recommended use, but it did carry those heavier (25-30lb) loads well.

For very light loads (15ish lbs) I've been happy with the MLD burn, a small and narrow frameless pack. I've since used an HMG ice pack for most of my trips from climbing, skiing, packrafting and backing. I think I prefer the frame/suspension of the gorilla slightly, because of the wide shoulder straps, but HMG packs carry light to moderately heavy loads pretty well.

And I'll add one speculative recommendation, not based on experience, but based on good design: the zpacks arc blast looks awesome, and assuming a good fit, an excellent thru hiking pack. The pockets would make for quick access, the suspension is airy and looks comfortable, its water resistant, super light and the material used is semi durable.

PostedNov 30, 2014 at 3:36 pm

I ended up using the HMG Windrider 2400 and was very satisfied with it.

It was plenty of pack for the gear and food I was carrying and it was nice to not have to worry about putting on a rain cover. It was quite comfortable I think. Its durability was mostly positive though I did have some de-laminating occurring on the inside. Supposedly they have updated their packs to make that a non-issue.

Would recommend.

Viewing 22 posts - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)
Loading...