Topic

Latest, Lightest Solar Charges?


Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Home Forums Gear Forums Gear (General) Latest, Lightest Solar Charges?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 17 posts - 26 through 42 (of 42 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #2017633
    Lowell Mills
    BPL Member

    @farmhand357

    I have a folding 12W solar array and use a 12V automotive-plug-to-USB adapter (the 5V, 2.1A kind). I noted that it would charge my iPhone 5 directly, unless a cloud passed by, which would kick it into the mode of telling me that this was not the correct kind of charger. Unplugging and replugging it got it charging again until the next cloud.

    Just wondering if once it starts charging, if I then shut it down, will it continue to charge but without the discriminatory circuitry that keeps stopping the charging when the direct sun is interrupted?

    The reason I ask is this same panel seems to charge my MacBook Pro when it's asleep, even though the wattage is well below the 65W provided by its power supply…

    #2017667
    David Thomas
    BPL Member

    @davidinkenai

    Locale: North Woods. Far North.

    >"which would kick it into the mode of telling me that this was not the correct kind of charger."

    I get that with various marginal chargers, loose connections, and having too many apps running for some chargers to support.

    Could there be an app that would clear that fault and let the phone try again to be charged? The only solution I've found is to unplug and replug the cord?

    >"Just wondering if once it starts charging, if I then shut it down, will it continue to charge but without the discriminatory circuitry that keeps stopping the charging when the direct sun is interrupted?"

    For some of my marginal chargers, I need to do that. If the iThing is off, it turns on when I connect the charging cord and often, quickly goes into "charging not supported with this accessory". I've had better luck having the iThing on, shutting down all apps, connecting the cord, and then quickly powering off the unit (just the quick, one-button push. Not the long-hold then thumb-slide shut down). Sometimes it still stops the charging before reaching 100%, but the above procedure gets me much further than leaving the unit on. So the discriminatory circuit still seems engaged, but by reducing the power draw of the unit, charging is supported for longer periods.

    #2017935
    Lowell Mills
    BPL Member

    @farmhand357

    Interesting; thanks, David. I tested my phone last night by plugging it into a USB port, then doing the complete shutdown (holding down the top button until I can use the red slidey thing at the top of the screen to shutdown).

    Of course, now I can't tell how quickly it's charging, but it would see that there's essentially no current draw in this mode and that it might consistently charge, even on a partly cloudy day.

    I will try to set up this experiment; I would think this would be great if it eliminates the need for a buffering battery intermediary…

    #2018082
    Joseph Brody
    Member

    @killroy1999

    I actually work at a Solar Company that makes roof top module, but no device chargers. I don't have solar module design experience, so I asked someone savvy today. He had a printer letter size module that is thin. Our product is a flexible laminate where silicon based solar is rigid and brittle, so our stuff can be a lot lighter and durable. The design is a nominal 5 volts and he said that with the performance of the cells, its possible to charge without any extra electronics.

    Yet, its still to big and heavy compared to a little 35g battery that I have. I'n not sure what the power is, but I think it could be downsized. I would not want anything bigger than a postcard.

    I think all I need is the battery for 6 day trips. I'm going backpacking, I don't need to be playing with electronics for a 5 day trip. Maybe for a 10 day trip next year.

    #2018084
    Bob Gross
    BPL Member

    @b-g-2-2

    Locale: Silicon Valley

    "Our product is a flexible laminate where silicon based solar is rigid and brittle, so our stuff can be a lot lighter and durable."

    If your product is not silicon-based, then what is it?

    The current types of solar chargers use either single-crystalline silicon (for high efficiency) or else amorphous silicon (for flexibility).

    –B.G.–

    #2018109
    Joseph Brody
    Member

    @killroy1999

    Bob, I'm talking about CIGS.

    #2018118
    Bob Gross
    BPL Member

    @b-g-2-2

    Locale: Silicon Valley

    So, what commercially viable solar charger products are there using this?

    –B.G.–

    #2018167
    Joseph Brody
    Member

    @killroy1999

    This one is down 112 g, but still fairly big.
    http://www.globalsolar.com/products/retail/sunlinq-1

    #2018173
    Nick Gatel
    BPL Member

    @ngatel

    Locale: Southern California

    2 watts maximum output (400mA) is rather anemic.

    For most backpackers the technology isn't there yet. Over the past 10 years I have spent nearly 1,000 days off the grid utilizing solar in my tent trailers, so I have a little bit of experience.

    You might find this interesting. Solar for backpacking?

    For thoughts on charging strategies and system sizing read this. RV Solar Systems

    Keep in mind, I am not an advocate for things electronic when backpacking. But if I were, spare batteries or a battery pack would be my solution, given the current state of technology.

    #2018185
    Zorg Zumo
    Member

    @burnnotice

    I used a Brunton Ember on my last trip. Charged my phone very fast. Weighs 142gm. Major downside is that it lacks any attachment points. It would be nice to have it on my pack charging while I'm hiking. Otherwise very simple use.

    #2018279
    Joseph Brody
    Member

    @killroy1999

    "2 watts maximum output (400mA) is rather anemic. "

    A USB only charges at 500mA. Of course if you are hiking, the panel is not going to be directly facing the sun(as mentioned in your link), but if you are carrying solar weight, it better be put to use on your pack all day when you don't have a full charge.

    In the link the solar charger was used was 360g. I never play with that many electronics to want to carry 360g of solar charger. For that weight, I could carry enough battery's to charge 10 iPhones.

    #2018284
    Joseph Brody
    Member

    @killroy1999

    The Brunton Ember charged your phone fast because it is a big battery. The solar is only good for 100mA max. I would call that anemic.

    #2018289
    Jerry Adams
    BPL Member

    @retiredjerry

    Locale: Oregon and Washington

    Maybe solar works best if it charges a battery at whatever current it produces.

    Then, use that battery to charge your device at the current required.

    #2018885
    Bob Gross
    BPL Member

    @b-g-2-2

    Locale: Silicon Valley

    "Maybe solar works best if it charges a battery at whatever current it produces."

    Not exactly. For most rechargeable batteries, there is an optimum charge current, and that is generally in the ballpark of one-tenth of the maximum available output current of the battery, but for ten times the time period. This varies from one battery chemistry to another.

    Solar panels work best in charging batteries if you use a charge controller.

    –B.G.–

    #2019420
    James Couch
    Spectator

    @jbc

    Locale: Cascade Mountains

    +1 Jerry!

    In particular most smartphones need something in the range of 7.5v to charge, when they don't get that they disconnect. Solar panels fluctuate the voltage output depending on how much sun they are getting. Charging a battery that has an integrated controller is the answer, charge the battery during the day, use the battery to charge the phone at night.

    Goal Zero is one company that seems to really have solar figured out.

    #2019445
    Taylor B
    Member

    @tboudreau

    I have been very impressed with my Suntactics Charger as it has been very reliable, and definitely feels like it will hold up as the construction feels solid. I apologize for not having more detailed voltage and amperage information, but I have found Suntactics claims of charging an iphone 5 in 2 hours to be reasonably accurate with consistent direct sunlight. Additionally just taking the panel, 8.5oz is pretty reasonable for the right trips.

    http://www.suntactics.com/shop/usb-scharger-5/

    #2019504
    Zorg Zumo
    Member

    @burnnotice

    Perhaps that is because you don't understand the usage model: Deliver a lot of juice when you need it and then slowly recharge during the day when you don't.

Viewing 17 posts - 26 through 42 (of 42 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Get the Newsletter

Get our free Handbook and Receive our weekly newsletter to see what's new at Backpacking Light!

Gear Research & Discovery Tools


Loading...