3 configurations for 40F+ 3-4 day backpacking in the Catskills and Adirondacks….pick one and why?!

Of course I am open to any other suggestions so long as:

The gear is lighter.

Or…

The gear is the same weight but provides more protection/usability.

Thanks!

I think the first list looks the best.

You have some pretty sweet gear there.

For a pack liner a Nylafume bag from your local exterminator is half the weight of a compactor bag. Gas and odor proof as well.

@Josh – Don't own some of it yet, but "gearing" up to make some purchases. ;)

@Ken – never heard of nylofune bags. Nice tip! Time to research where to buy them and learn a bit more about them. :) So which setup would you take? Or would you mod one for even better result?

I've tried to consider the pros and cons and the overall weight effect, not just one shelter vs. another.

Well today I went for the left most option in my spreadsheet, a tarp tent of sorts w/ bug netting that affords me much better rain coverage:

http://www.bearpawwd.com/tents_tarps/cubden.html

In the NE we have bugs so I'll appreciate the large bug-free space more often than not and this shelter will afford me better rain protection and sprawl out space with my quilt. Expect a BPL review when I receive it, I'm psyched!

never noticed the cub den before…nice for both weight and price.

I'll tell ya though, i'm still on the fence with the duomid and perimeter netting…i've had some rough nights with bug infiltration. I actually talked to the gent at bearpaw about getting a floor option for my duomid…i've just been holding off because of my lack of motivation to add weight to the setup.

The northeast is truly blessed with flying biting insects.

Yeah NE is bad for bugs, that's why the perimeter netting is a major plus vs my current poncho/tarp setup. I am fine w/ the floor not being completely enclosed in bug netting like the Hexamid because I have a polycro ground sheet to cover the floor, plus the perimeter netting from the Cub Den is very substantial and wraps under quite a bit.