Kevin,
Thanks for the comments. Especially in nasty weather, I wanted room for my XL NeoAir. I also wanted a bottom that was tough enough to protect my rather fragile NeoAir from puncture. It has a slow leak that I have to find soon. It's not my winter pad, so I have a little time. I have not used Cuben yet so I not sure of its durability compared to the Tyvek housewrap. I have used Si Nylon on some projects and feel like it's just to lightweight for a floor. I have slept all night with this bivy in a puddle of water and had no water come through the floor. I like lightweight gear, but good performance it the biggest driver for me. The idea of pitching a tarp in the storms I find myself in just sounds dangerous. In rescue, I don't get to pick good weather or nice campsites. The people who are lost or hurt chose them for me. This suits me since I really like the challenge of foul weather. I love getting in my bombproof cocoon to sleep.
As for a more simple bag. My Basic Bivy uses the same waterproof/breathable material on top and bottom. This is a good choice for winter where bugs are not an issue. Again, this one has lots of room inside, but no poles, zippers, or netting. I used this one 2 weeks ago to protect a lost skier from the helicopter downwash during a rescue.
http://www.milesgear.com/
The smallest one I make is just a sleeping bag cover or emergency bivy. I have spent a handful of nights in my Thermolite bivy by AMK. Its works as advertised, but I wanted a more breathable version.
Thanks,
Dave