Dan,
It sounds like our “needs” are similar. These days I mostly backpack to get to remote fishing locations. This is exactly why I bought this pack… I used to use a “heavy” NF daypack that I have had for years which was very functional, but really overkill for my needs. The EMS pack is exactly what I was looking for…(simple, light, and functional) the only thing that might make it better would be if it was completely waterproof for those times I am wading deep but I just use a trash bag or drybag to solve that with this bag. I had been looking at the stuff from Simms, Fishpond, etc, but they were all “heavy” and again overkill for my needs. The EMS pack does have a hydration sleeve, and a “brain” that the whole pack stuffs into, but I cut both out since I use Gatorade bottles, and do not need the extra room and function of the “brain”. This along with cutting down the straps is how I got to 6.4oz, but it was light to start with…
How large of a stuff sack is it? What would use it for in your large pack?
Quite large-I can fit either my sleeping bag in it with a few other things, or pretty much all my clothes if I want. I usually fill it with everything I need for fishing except my waders (rain jacket, flies, leaders, tippet, extra insulation layers, water, purifier, etc) then put it in the top of my larger backpack. That way I am ready to fish while hiking, or as soon as I set up camp!!
Used as a pack, how much "stuff" can it fit?
Again I would imagine our “needs” are similar, and I have yet to not be able to fit what I needed for fishing… Easily holds 2 Nalgene’s(in my case Gatorade bottles) water purifier, extra food, extra layers, extra gear, reels, etc.
Is the pack comfortable enough to hike with all day?
I guess this it somewhat subjective, but yes. As long as you don’t overload it you should be good to go. It does not have a waist strap, and lacks any structure (which is what I was looking for). It would not be a good daypack for trail running, but for casual day hikes, and for fishing all day it works great for me. If you overload it, it would not be comfortable, but for what you are looking for I think it would work great. It does for me…… Should work great for those alpine lakes in the Sierra’s….
Tight lines.