Jul 11, 2010 at 4:21 pm #1261056
Thought I'd add a thread here for my first prototype of a LDPE tent.
I hope to use this in the Wind River range in a couple weeks.
You can see the original tent that spawned this and somewhat of a genesis of what I've gone through so far in this thread.
I was aiming for not having to sew at all but you can see from my last post on that thread that didn't work out with the mesh seams at least.
Tarp body weight was less than 7 oz. Size is 8×6. Likely doubled with the mesh skirt but don't have a total weight yet as I haven't figured out how to do the mesh door closure zipper-free. Thinking either ziploc pieces like Rog Tallbloke or snaps like Roger Caffin. Maybe I'll stay with the rolling and binder clips for now. Any suggestions?Jul 12, 2010 at 5:52 am #1628161Yohei AoyagiBPL Member
I'm thinking same design. But this time I bought zpacks hexamid.Jul 12, 2010 at 6:00 am #1628164Ken ThompsonBPL Member
@hereLocale: Right there
Looks great! With that weight I would just make easy on myself and add a #3 zipper. Can't weigh much more than binder clips.Jul 12, 2010 at 9:44 am #1628208
That may be true Ken. I have a zipper I could weigh and use. Al found in his original A-frame design that he had to fold it in a special way to avoid deforming the LDPE when packed tightly because of the zippers and cordage. I was hoping to avoid that hassle. Roger's 2 snap design would be lighter and simpler though I did not add a baffle to the door or have a floor to hold up as he does. Walmart didn't have any large plastic snaps though – just small and large metal ones you had to sew in. I'll need to go to a hobby or fabric store.
I'll also have to sew the mesh to the tent as I suspected. Rained last night and it separated from the tape in some areas. Just waiting for Al to respond on how he did it without gumming up his needle. My attempt at sewing through the tape was not good.Jul 12, 2010 at 5:44 pm #1628356
The snaps work, but the more important bit is a simple overlap of the mesh by 6 – 8". The snaps stop that from blowing open.
CheersJul 12, 2010 at 6:33 pm #1628375
I should have at least 8" overlap as I had seen your idea and wasn't sure which way I was going to go. I assume your snaps are the press-in vs sew-in kind?Jul 13, 2010 at 9:34 am #1628581Daniel FosseMember
@magillagorillaLocale: Southwest Ohio
I am thinking of making a bug hut that has a draw string entrance. I think it would be simple enough to leave some slack material in the front pannel, cut a circle out of the front and sew in a draw string around the circle. Kinda like a stuff sack. a piece of thin cord and a cord lock would be simple and light.Jul 14, 2010 at 7:58 pm #1629042Colin ParkinsonBPL Member
@parkinson1157Locale: Ontario Canada
That is brilliant.
I mad a bug bivy early this year but have not worked out a good closure method, as I find zippers and bug netting lead to snags, tears and tears.
This is one of those why didn't I think of that episodes.Jul 15, 2010 at 1:11 am #1629155
Yes, definitely press-in or rivet variety. Pics of them and na MYOG setting tool in the MYOG poncho article
CheersJul 15, 2010 at 1:12 am #1629156
> zippers and bug netting lead to snags
And the hook side of hook&loop fasteners is absolutely murder on netting!
CheersJul 15, 2010 at 6:54 am #1629204
What did you use for backing to keep from tearing the netting?Jul 15, 2010 at 1:32 pm #1629346
Finally weighed it now that I had to sew the mesh on vs just tape. 10.6 oz (298g) for LDPE, tape, noseeum mesh, 5 short shockcord tieout loops, and 7 short Triptease guylines. Doesn't include door closure, stakes, the long guyline for the pole or the "storm door" I have yet to make, but it should still come in under a pound for total weight.
I didn't put the shockcord at all the tieout points, just the 4 corners and the middle of the 8' back. That's to reduce stress during windy conditions or so I hope since I'm going to the Wind River Range. The plan is to start with the guylines to get the most headroom. If a storm's coming in, I'll re-stake using just the shockcord loops. If it looks really bad, I'll just stake it to the ground using all the tieout points and put up the storm door if needed since I'm not using a bivy.Jul 25, 2010 at 7:48 pm #1632204
I'm not going to make my 16 oz target. :( I'm at 16.6 with everything except the "storm door" now. However, that also includes extra LDPE and tape that had to be used as patches after my dog tore it up, and I ended up using a zipper for the mesh door closure. I couldn't figure out how to use snaps when my opening width varies up to 20". I suppose I'll also need to add in groundcloth weight. On the bright side, it did handle 35 mph winds during a storm yesterday.Jul 30, 2010 at 1:40 pm #1633526Lawson KlineBPL Member
Nice job on the construction. It looks like it was made in a factory. What thickness film did you use?Jul 30, 2010 at 3:07 pm #1633559Vick HinesMember
@vickrhinesLocale: Central Texas
You might consider not using a zipper or any closure at all. Just make the net upside down = the apex of the triangle faces down instead of up, and make it 6 inches longer – taller. It will drape on the ground and you can just lift it up to get in or out. Put a pocket at the center of the bottom to hold a water bottle or shoe to hold it down in the wind.Aug 11, 2010 at 9:15 am #1636734
According to Heatsheets, they are 1 mil vs typically 1/2 mil for mylar blankets.
I think the added weight of the required mesh would exceed that of the zipper at least in my application. The zipper was < 1 oz. Keep in mind, my opening width (bottom corners of the tarp at the door) could vary from 60 to 80 inches.
FWIW, the tarp worked well on my trip. My next design will offer me more room (eg, steeper walls) to move around without touching though condensation as expected was not too bad. I hope to make a short video detailing this one and you can see the damage my dog had done to it.Aug 15, 2010 at 6:43 am #1637552
FYI, total system weight including a heavy stuff sack of the right size I happened to have (& a little dirt and moisture) was < 22 oz. I could lose some with Ti stakes perhaps and not taking so many. Al's design had tieouts every foot where I did every 2 feet. I never used all of mine but we never had gusts above 30 mph.
I hope to make a video of the new gear I had on this trip vs last summer which will show some more detail on what I did for this tarp and what I've learned for future designs.Aug 15, 2010 at 2:38 pm #1637643
Sometimes I just sewed over a double layer of netting. That holds reasonably well in practice. Other times I used a narrow strip of silnylon to bind the edge.
When using snaps I had to use an area or strip of silnylon with a small square of heavier fabric (1" square say) to hold the snap. Opening the snap is done via the silnylon, not the netting, of course.
CheersAug 15, 2010 at 2:40 pm #1637644
> I ended up using a zipper for the mesh door closure. I couldn't figure out
> how to use snaps when my opening width varies up to 20".
Generous overlap. It keeps the bugs out, and is a lot lighter than a zip.
CheersAug 15, 2010 at 4:23 pm #1637658
>> I ended up using a zipper for the mesh door closure. I couldn't figure out
>> how to use snaps when my opening width varies up to 20".
>Generous overlap. It keeps the bugs out, and is a lot lighter than a zip.
That wouldn't work with just the 2 at the bottom as you have. I'd need a row going up the overlap to prevent huge gaps forming when I was pitched at a smaller door width. My zipper only added an ounce, likely less since I lost about a double layer of 8"x40" mesh. I was pleased with the no-fuss performance of the zipper.Aug 16, 2010 at 9:32 am #1637789Apr 13, 2012 at 5:33 am #1866791
For anyone that had been watching this thread, Prototype 2 is now in the works. Different material and no netting at this point. I also increased length a foot so it's 6' x 9' now and changed the pole connection so I need 1 fewer stake.Apr 13, 2012 at 10:35 pm #1867104Sam FarringtonBPL Member
@scfhomeLocale: Chocorua NH, USA
Don't know if this is any use to you, but thought about the overlap for netting on a 2-piece A-frame door being secured by light shock cord loops sewn to the corners of the netting and attached to buttons sewn to the outer bathtub wall of the floor. The thought was that you could easily reach into the overlap, down to the button, and remove the loop to open. Vice-versa to close. Thought about doing this also for emergency A-frame doors made of light cuben to be unrolled when the weather got really nasty – upside down rain, and all that.
Like you, found the #3 zippers too handy and used them for the net doors. It may be partly psychological – keeping out creepy crawlies, and all that.Apr 14, 2012 at 11:29 am #1867210
Yep, the zipper eliminated having to figure something that would work with an opening that varied 20" in width. If you always pitched it the same width within reason, your idea and a few others would have worked OK.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.