Topic

ultralight tent decision???

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 44 total)
PostedMay 30, 2010 at 1:51 am

I have been looking at UL tents for months now and still cant decide.

TT moment looks like a good tent, and great weight… But camping in the northern rockies, I want something that will be warm and stormproof, (moment looks like it might be drafty). How far is the fly off the ground?

The scarp 1 seams bomber and warm, but the weight is getting a little high. Also, its a 4 season convertible tent, and could fit two in a pinch.

Vaude Power lizard is pretty light, "two man tent", but pricey, hard to find, and I would rather buy from a 'cottage company' if possible.

What I am looking for is a UL tent with good wind protection, and room to sit up and is a plus. I am shooting for a base weight of <10 lbs, although around 11 lbs is more realistic right now. I dont hike with trekking poles, so those options are not in the picture.

Not sure what I am looking for in this thread… just need some help making a decision! ;)

PostedMay 30, 2010 at 2:44 am

Scott
I would not expect the Moment to be warm in a conventional sense.
By that I mean that it will be draughty in strong wind , however it may prove to be warmer in a different way.
If you block wind completely , or close enough, in most situations you get condensation. If at around 40f or under, that will make you feel colder than at a few degrees less but with dryer air.
Here are some unofficial pictures of the Moment in wind attack mode.
In the first you can see the end vent closed and the floor up. There is a mesh sealed gap of about 15" between the floor and the vent
The next is the non door side with the floor up. As you can see the floor rises (by about 2") over the bottom of the fly (about 8" away at the pole) So you will still get the wind in but deflected by the fabric and diffused by the mesh.
On the door side the floor is up about 5" , and that is about the gap between the fabric and the ground at the pole.
All around the fly is 4 to 5" above the ground.
Moment end up
Moment side up
Moment side up 2
The last two shots are of the same area. The first one is from eye level laying down, the next from above .
Franco
franco at tarptent dot com

PostedMay 30, 2010 at 2:44 pm

Scott,

So you want something "warm and stormproof" but you don't want the weight of a 4 season tent (even one as reasonable as the Scarp.) Hmmm.

I have a Moment. Great little tent. For winter camping it's much better than what I was using — a flat 6×10 foot tarp. (Yes, in winter in NC. Yes, it was fine.) I put my money into nice fluffy down in my sleeping bag.

Not sure how the Moment would fare in the Rockies, but for me it's working out very well. Plenty of space for me and gear, good headroom, excellent storm protection, etc. I have been using Tarptents since 2004 and I've never had any (what I would consider) serious problems with condensation.

Good luck.

PostedMay 30, 2010 at 6:39 pm

I guess I may have some unrealistic expectations… The moment is looking good right now. I was a little concerned that wind would blow right through the tent. but looking at those pics, it appears to have more coverage than I initially thought.

PostedMay 30, 2010 at 6:57 pm

I really like the Moment but silnylon and I are fairly soggy combination due to condensation. The only two sil tents I have been able to use without experiencing this are the Contrail and the Hex 3. I have had tremendous condensation even with a Wild Oasis. Is the ventilation sufficient on the Moment stay fairly dry…equal to the Contrail?? Franco? Anyone? I would really like to have a Moment for use in wet climates.

PostedMay 30, 2010 at 7:28 pm

I have only used the Moment in my backyard, however grass does produce a good amount of condensation.
Because of the end and top vents , as well as the usual 360 degree TT mesh, air circulation is pretty good in my opinion.
Note that the entry is rain protected so you can leave the door partially or fully open as well as propping the non door side up.
One advantage that the Contrail has is the space over your head. That dissipates most or all of your warmer breath so possibly this
is the reason why you have had better luck with this than some others.
Franco

PostedMay 30, 2010 at 10:01 pm

Here is a sample pitch. It looks about as benign as one can get:
TentPitch

but the next morning:
wet tent
wet tent2
WetInside

I am going to need a tent to keep me dry with consecutive days of rain. The Moment would keep the rain out but if the Wild Oasis with all of its ventilation provides these results I am afraid that the Moment will be somewhat similar??

PostedMay 31, 2010 at 12:47 am

Wow…..that looks like a lot of condensation considering you even had the door open. It's hard to get more ventilation that that. Maybe leave the blue camp chair at home and use that weight towards a double wall :)

PostedMay 31, 2010 at 9:19 am

The door was zipped shut most of the night but there was still ample ventilation. Yes, a double wall tent is being considered. Dan, you have a keen eye to pick the chair out from that little corner peeking through. I suspect you may carry one yourself? :>)

Martin Rye BPL Member
PostedMay 31, 2010 at 9:35 am

Henry is adding clip in panels for the Moment which will offer superb protection from condensation. He has been testing the Moment in Scotland for the last two weeks so it should be be a superb option for the Moment.

PostedMay 31, 2010 at 11:33 am

As you can tell Martin from the post that this is the tent that I would like to order. So there will be an upgrade to the Moment??

Martin Rye BPL Member
PostedMay 31, 2010 at 12:54 pm

Defiantly according to Henry. Clip in panels like the Rainbow has. He emailed me the other day about it. We discussed some stuff about the TGO Challenge he was planning to do and as a part of that the Moment was discussed. Henry has been using his new version in Scotland. A long test. Hope that helps.

Martin Rye BPL Member
PostedMay 31, 2010 at 1:16 pm

"Adds 120 grams but eliminates any condensation issues–I stayed completely dry." – Henry wrote that to me the other day in a email. A good tent just got very good.

PostedMay 31, 2010 at 2:06 pm

I would welcome anything to reduce condensation in single-wall tents. I seem to be in the minority here, but condensation always seems like a huge issue for me here in the Pacific Northwest. I finally understood after hiking in the Sierra during during the summer what a joy it is to backpack in lower-humidity climes – waking up in the morning without having to shake out the tent was welcome.

Dirk

PostedJun 1, 2010 at 2:23 am

Any idea when the clip in panels for the Moment will be available for purchase? Definitely makes the Moment a more interesting tent for me (scandinavian conditions).

PostedJun 1, 2010 at 3:35 am

Right now Henry has the only one.
He arrived back to his home a few hours ago from Scotland , so he is going to be very busy catching up in the next few days.
The liner should be in production soon.
Existing shelters will need two clips to be attached to the fly take it.
When more details are available I will post them.
Franco

PostedJun 1, 2010 at 6:20 am

Scott,

Have you considered bringing along a UL breathable bivy? This would provide the extra wind protection and water condensation barrier that you are looking for without adding the weight of a double wall tent.

PostedJun 1, 2010 at 6:27 am

So this Moment modification will, essentially, take four ozs of drapery turning it into a double wall shelter??? Is this the idea Franco, Martin? Sounds like a great solution.

PostedJun 1, 2010 at 7:23 am

I think im going to order a Moment and see how it works for me. Considering some people sleep year under tarps, the moment should provide all the protection I need or want at least 90% of the time.

John, if I was going to carry a bivy all the time, I think I would be best off just using a tarp. However, adding a bivy to any sleep system i choose would probably work well for cold/windy conditions when I feel I would like more protection.

About the new moment liner… Will this become a new tent with the liner attached? Or simply as an option that you can purchase and add/remove as needed?

PostedJun 1, 2010 at 8:51 am

I just got off the phone with Henry. It sound like the inner for the moment will be available to purchase separately. For optimum use you may need to add a couple clips to the tent, but will work OK with out.

PostedJun 1, 2010 at 3:58 pm

Henry was very pleased with the performance of the liner in Scotland, so it will go into production towards the end of this month.
The liner is the same highly water resistant fabric the Scarp inners are made of.
This is what it looks like :
Moment liner 2

Franco

PostedJun 1, 2010 at 4:15 pm

I camped in the Indian Peaks Range near Nederland, CO last Oct. I was at the tree line at Arapaho Pass and, even behind a windbreak of low firs, I found the Moment to be a bit drafty in all night 35 -45 mph winds.

I laid some clothes on the horizontal end mesh and back side mesh which helped, closed the triangular end flaps and built a 2' high snow wall on the door side. Still in the ripping winds and at 20 F. it was a bit drafty, but not "windy". YMMV A 4 season tent it ain't. I suggest a Hilleberg Akto.

The tent was VERY stable W/ the extra guys on the main hoop and did not flap at all. Cooking under the vestibule, out of (most of)the wind was easy. Just pull the floor back off its ground level Velcro hold down to get more cooking space.

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 44 total)
Loading...