The recent posting on Steripens got me thinking about this.
Several forms of water treatment either have a negative impact of the taste of water (iodine, chlorine, etc.) while other forms have at best a neutral effect on the taste (hollow fiber filters [msr/plat/sawer], steripen, etc.).
In my experience the only thing that really makes water taste more neutral, or 'more pleasing', is carbon. Even a britta improves the taste of all but the best municipal water IMO.
What are the options available to a lightweight backpacker for a carbon filter, primarily for the benefit of taste and removal of particles (ie not the primary treatment component of the system).
Obviously not all water in the back-country needs filtering. Drinking straight from a spring or good fresh snowmelt is just about the best thing ever… And much of my hiking in the Sierras and Cascades has plenty of clear tasty water. But often enough I also find myself having to drink some questionable stuff…


