Topic

Warmth of jackets

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 6 posts - 26 through 31 (of 31 total)
Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 8:52 pm

"I have never camped in weather this cold – sounds like I will need to plan for something warmer.. Would 2 baselayers, a full blown down parka, and softshell be warm enough? The people I talked to (this is climbing Kilimanjaro) seemed to feel this would be enough, but would be great to get the advice of the forum here.."

Maybe you are asking if it gets super cold on Kilimanjaro. Kili is almost on the equator, but it is 19,340' on the summit. In one respect, it must get a little cold up there since there are several glaciers. However, the glaciers are receding, perhaps due in part to global warming or other factors. Since it is almost on the equator, there is not a lot of winter/summer variation, but there is a rainy/dry season variation. I was there one June, and I don't think the night temperature in the summit crater dipped below +10 F. I didn't even wear my down jacket on that trip. Just mostly fleece.
–B.G.–

Robert Blean BPL Member
PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 9:13 pm

> I have never camped in weather this cold – sounds like I will need to plan for something
> warmer.. Would 2 baselayers, a full blown down parka, and softshell be warm enough?
> The people I talked to (this is climbing Kilimanjaro) seemed to feel this would
> be enough, but would be great to get the advice of the forum here..

Under what conditions do you plan to wear the clothing you are talking about? What weather, and what is your expected activity level?

— MV

PostedFeb 17, 2010 at 11:09 pm

Since when were the 80's cool? Punk died in the early 80's, neon colors were great, and everyone thought digital watches were a pretty neat idea. And John Lennon died in 1980… way to introduce a decade.

What?!? Hypercolor shirts were awesome! Oh wait, that was the 90's.

PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 4:03 am

"Under what conditions do you plan to wear the clothing you are talking about? What weather, and what is your expected activity level?"

I plan to climb Kilimanjaro – so will be hiking at low levels of aerobic activity, esp given the lower oxygen levels nearer the summit. Am less worried about when I am on the move, more so when I am still at camp – temps can range from 10 to -10, depending on weather patterns. We will have porters to help us , and will be 2 to a tent at night.

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 7:28 am

Assuming that you are on one of the standard routes, part of the problem will start at the high camp. To get to the summit and back down, they normally start you hiking up in the middle of the night, so it will be cold and dark and high altitude. That gets pretty demoralizing.

I didn't have any of those problems the way I went.
–B.G.–

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedFeb 18, 2010 at 8:14 am

First thing to consider: all those layers add up to a ton of weight. Soft shells in particular are absurdly heavy. Also consider added bulk, weight of umpteen different 2-layer shells (the shell of each jacket usually weighs more than the insulation inside). Add to that the ultimately restricted motion inherent to wearing a ton of layers… multiple of which are lofty. Last thing, all metabolisms differ, and it depends on your level of activity.

Sure, below zero on the move I'm probably only wearing a 320-ish weight wool and a windbreaker (hat, maybe a thin pair of gloves). But when I stop, at those temps, I end up wearing a very lofty down vest and a very lofty down parka.

Climashield 5oz would translate to roughly 140g/m2; a jacket made of that would probably be good for sedentary activity in the +20s. The Montbell Thermawrap you mention is ~80g/m2.

Save yourself a ton of weight and bulk, and simplify your system, by going with one big poofy down parka. A Feathered Friends Icefall, perhaps, and perhaps with the Thermawrap or a thinner down or synthetic vest. Ditch the softshell; they're usually too hot if you're really moving, anyway.

Cheers-

Viewing 6 posts - 26 through 31 (of 31 total)
Loading...