I was wondering if anyone could tell me what kind of comfort rating could be achieved by layering a montbell Thermawrap parka and a montbell Alpine light down parka? I am thinking that it would be good, with normal base layers, down to about minus 10F. I know that Richard did some charts about a year ago on warmth but I can't seem to figure out the classification system.
Thanks,
Travis
Topic
Warmth of jackets
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
No way, no how. I'd want more clothes if I was sitting around camp at +15F.
I'm planning to camp in -15 degree weather for a couple of days – will have 1 or 2 base layers + First Ascent Down sweater (900 fill) + a marmot M3 softshell. Should keep me warm – sounds like you're aiming for something similar..
I winter camp for a living. I don't know anyone that would be warm at -15F, while sitting around, with clothing similar to that.
At -15F I'm in a full-on winter parka, puffy vest and/or puffy jacket and puffy pants. Along with big dumb mitts and mukluks.
Have you ever been camping at -15F? What were you wearing then?
i agree, you're gonna get owned at -15 degrees. My 800 fill downsweater will keep me comfy in 25 so long as im moving, i cant imagine a 900 filled version of the same thing, even with a softshell, would bring me anywhere close to -15. That's what the First Ascent Peak XV is for, but thats a full blown parka
A few decades ago, a bunch of us went snow camping in Yosemite, and we had some beginners along. In advance, we told them to prepare for +10 F. On skis, I had carried in a big 4-person pyramid tent for the beginners to use. Later that day, one woman beginner looked at that big, drafty pyramid, and then she looked over at a cozy 2-person tent with two guys. She asked for permission to sleep between the two guys. Naturally, that happened. In the morning, it was very frosty. It had gotten to -10 F, so the pyramid tent sleepers were a little unhappy. The tent with the two guys and the woman… they had gotten so hot during the night that they had to completely open the tent door and leave it wide open.
–B.G.–
There is a significant difference between hiking at -10F and camping at -10F. I've hiked at -10F with a mid weight base layer, shell pants, and a mid weight fleece. Camping at those temperatures (ie sitting around for long periods of time) would require more to remain comfortable.
Thanks for the replies guys. I guess i misjudged the warmth of those two pieces. Looks like I will have to continue to look at warmer down jackets like the peak xv for around camp use.
Thanks,
Travis
Thanks Bob, for reminding us that we missed the 60's.. Braggart.
I think warmth is somewhat relative to the temps you're used to.
Live in cold climates … cold not so bad.
Live in warm climates … the brain and body rebel against the cold.
Please explain your comment. It wasn't in the sixties.
–B.G.–
Just giving you a hard time Bob, thought you were bragging about some free "trail love".. ;)
No harm intended man. I hate that I missed the 60's and 70's. I'm only 29.
Maybe you misunderstood what I wrote. Don't let your imagination run away.
My point was that if it is very cold and you are worried about staying warm, then put three bodies in a two-person tent. You can get by with 3-lb. bags instead of 4-lb. bags, or maybe 2-lb. bags instead of 3 lb.
–B.G.–
> put three bodies in a two-person tent.
And share a quilt.
Seriously.
Cheers
I thought it was funny.
I think the whole… "and then she looked over at a cozy 2-person tent with two guys. She asked for permission to sleep between the two guys. Naturally, that happened." part was the funny part.
Us young-uns have perpetually dirty minds. In this context, the statement "Naturally, that happened." is humorous. I laughed when I read it.
I don't think he meant any harm. There is a heat retention reason to do this, sure. It was written ambiguously enough to incite young minds to leap into the gutter. (mine included)
This was back in the era when we had campfire refreshments. There would be a bottle being passed around one direction, and a joint going the other direction. Take your pick.
That is one good situation for snow camping, because snow is good for chilling a bottle of champagne.
–B.G.–
I gotta pick one?;)
A friend and I camped on Mt. Adams (NH) at tree line in the winter. There is a "heated" cabin up there that is manned by a ranger in the winter. "Heated" means that he burns one load of firewood in the stove at about 6pm….that's it!…this got the cabin up in a peak in the 20s by 8pm. The overnight lows were -19, and the small cabin dropped back to -14 by morning.
So, what does the ranger wear in his "heated" cabin? A himalayan down suit that he bought used from a British climber. I brought my warmest expedition North Face down parka, insulated pants, many layers, etc….and barely kept warm. We also spent one night in the tent, and "survived". If you were not moving, you needed to be in your sleeping bag.
If you have never camped or spent several days at <15 F, I'd suggest you take a few trips at progressively colder temps until you know what to expect at -15. If you are not careful, you will comeback a woman as your balls will be frozen off. Those temps do not "sound" that bad but remember the difference between freezing (32F) and -15F, is like the difference between 80F and 33F….it's worlds apart. Be careful, and pack more than you think you need. These are not the temps to test "ultralight".
> Camping at those temperatures (ie sitting around for long periods of time)
Having been there, my question is why one would spend much of any time just sitting around at -15F or so? That's downright chilly.
> If you were not moving, you needed to be in your sleeping bag.
To me that is normal for winter in the NE — you can dress moderately for active -10F to +10F days. Travel all day, make camp, and get into your sleeping bag for the night. Then cook. It makes no sense to me to be just "sitting around" after dark when it is well sub-zero, and the thermometer is heading south.
— MV
Here is a different scenario. Lets say i am wearing a merino wool t shirt, merino wool crew, a fleece pullover, a Softshell jacket, then the Thermawrap parka and the Alpine light down parka. To go with this I have a warm hat, balaclava and expedition down mittens and appropriate leg and foot insulation. I feel that these are most definately enough layers to take down to subzero temperatures. In his review of the alpine light jacket Will Rietveld talks about taking a system very similar to this down to negative 16 and being comfortable in yellowstone. He was using the ID Rundle jacket which has 4 oz/m2 of insulation. The Montbell Thermawrap parka has 2.82 oz/m2 of insulation, yet in this system I have added the softshell jacket which should compensate for the lost 1.18 oz/m2 of insulation. I hope my logic makes sense to everyone.
I have personally taken my apline light parka into the single digits with the base layers and fleece underneath, so I feel that with the addition of the thermawrap parka and softshell should be able to go down to below zero.
Travis
Six layers? You are going back to the old clothing strategy of the Everest climbers from the 1920's, many thin layers. It's not silly, but modern winter travelers might find it clumsy to be taking off and putting on so many layers. Obviously, six layers has some advantages in versatility, but a smaller number may be more convenient.
The worst that I ever did was five layers on Mount Washington, and that was about one layer more than what was necessary.
Find a meat locker with a walk-in freezer, and ask …
–B.G.–
"I winter camp for a living. I don't know anyone that would be warm at -15F, while sitting around, with clothing similar to that"
I have never camped in weather this cold – sounds like I will need to plan for something warmer.. Would 2 baselayers, a full blown down parka, and softshell be warm enough? The people I talked to (this is climbing Kilimanjaro) seemed to feel this would be enough, but would be great to get the advice of the forum here..
"Thanks Bob, for reminding us that we missed the 60's.. Braggart."
No big loss…i had the 80's!!!!!!!!!!
Since when were the 80's cool? Punk died in the early 80's, neon colors were great, and everyone thought digital watches were a pretty neat idea. And John Lennon died in 1980… way to introduce a decade.
Become a member to post in the forums.

