Topic

Water Treatment – Hybrid Filter?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 29 total)
EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 9:31 am

I find myself dissatisfied with all current water treatment methods:

UV – light and quick but does nothing to improve water clarity / taste.

Chemicals – light and quick but long treatment time. Also does nothing to improve water clarity / taste.

Filters – effective against biological baddies and improves water clarity and taste — but bulky and fussy.

Would be nice if someone can make a simple, compact pump filter like this:

1. prefilter to block out sediments.
2. small carbon chamber to improve taste.
3. UV to zap the water as it passes through.

With UV, the filter portion won't need to be so intricate/bulky — just enough to block out the visible stuff. Pump and you're done — no worries about foul tasting water or any biological baddies — including viruses.

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 9:43 am

>I find myself dissatisfied with all current water treatment methods:

That's why I made my own filter out of a wide-mouth nalgene and Katadyn Hiker filter element. It's not a hybrid like you suggest, but it's something I AM satisfied with.

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 9:55 am

BPL isn't letting me upload them. I'll try in a little while.

. . BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 10:30 am

Travis, what's the weight on that?

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 11:13 am

So, I took a Katadyn Hiker Pro filter element, and put a quick connect on it.

filter 1

I also put a quick connect on my Platypus drinking tube.

filter 2

The filter fits pretty nicely inside the wide mouth. It doesn't screw in or anything, but does create a nice seal if held correctly.

filter 4

When you're ready to filter, I just connect my drinking tube to the filter, and let gravity do the rest!

filter 4

You can't hang it because the filter would fall out, but I can filter a liter in around 2 minutes or less, depending on water clarity. I don't mind holding the filter either, but some may not like it. The clean water reservoir can be set down, and the 1 L platypus bottles that stand up worked well like that.

me filter

The Nalgene and filter weigh 5 oz. dry. I don't factor in the weight of the tube since I count that weight for my hydration bladder. I used this on my last trip through the Superstitions, and I actually really liked it. It might be a little slower than a pump, but the Hiker Pro weighs around 11-13 oz with tubes and such.

Considering the filter is rated to .3 microns, it will get rid of anything except viruses.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 11:22 am

That's very cool!!

For treating viruses (not always an issue but who really knows) — it would still be wonderful is someone like Steripen or MSR can build a UV inside what is now the filter cartridge.

Weight and space reduction aside, pumping through a prefilter / carbon element instead of a complex matrix filter element should be a lot easier on the arms.

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 11:23 am

If you wanted, you could also just connect the filter to the tube and plop the filter in any water source and suck away. But its not the greatest way to drink.

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 11:24 am

Yeah, if there are known viruses, I then just throw in some Micropur. Should kill anything in there in less than a half hour since all the really big stuff is filtered out.

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 11:26 am

Oh, also…you do have to "prime" the filter if it's not already saturated. Otherwise it'll take forever to come out. I just GENTLY squeeze on the dirty water bag or suck the water through to get it started.

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 11:30 am

>it would still be wonderful is someone like Steripen or MSR can build a UV inside what is now the filter cartridge.

I have no doubt that it could be done…just a matter if a company would invest in producing it.

Sorry for the multiple rapid-fire posts. Sometimes a chat function would be nice.

Konrad . BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 12:04 pm

Hey Travis, where are your finding the male end of the quick-connects? (as seen in the first photo)

Alex Gilman BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 12:13 pm

I'm not as UL as most of the people here so I use the Katadyn Pocket Filter. I have 0 complaints it's not fussy at all makes great tasting water at about 75 strokes to fill a SIGG.

PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 2:43 pm

Nobody mentioning the frontier pro in conjunction with UV or chemical?

Isn't that pretty much the lightest solution to treat everything plus clean up the taste?

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 3:03 pm

The frontier pro is definitely an alternative. It is smaller and lighter than the Hiker filter.

However, its 3 micron rating versus the Katydyn Hiker's 0.3 micron is a big difference, and another form of filtering/purifying would be necessary. With the Hiker filter, I don't need chemical treatment. Here in the U.S. viruses aren't really a problem.

I don't own one, but others have said that it filters quite slowly as a gravity filter–though some have had decent luck with it.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 3:13 pm

Actually, I use the Frontier Pro — in conjuction with chlorine (treat first, wait 20 minutes, then suck water through Frontier Pro). But my "wish" as stated in the first post would eliminate the 20 minute wait — and no need to suck water each time.

PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 3:15 pm

What about UV+FP?

I know there are inherent reliability issues with UV (what's the word? Not filter obviously) treaters.

Honestly what's the lightest UV setup out there? I know SteriPEN isn't it.

PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 3:16 pm

I'm one of those who found it slow, then found it stopped probably at half it's life expectancy. (Yes, I understand how its pre-filter works and followed instructions.) Maybe I got a bad one and maybe I did something bad without noticing. Too bad, it was light, but I didn't try another one. I upgraded to the heavier Amigo which uses a Katadyn filter.

Sorry to hijack the thread, but why don't I see the Amigo on ULA's site?

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 3:18 pm

When in the mountains, I use a Frontier Pro in a gravity flow setup. One Platypus above, and one below.

I've found that after a lot of use, flow will decrease. I take it apart, and nearly always there is some tiny debris in the first stage filter. That is removed and the thing is reassembled quickly.

–B.G.–

Konrad . BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 3:20 pm

When ULA switched ownership, they dropped the Amigo. As i recall, Bryan was licensing it from someone else, and when he sold the company, the parties decided not to transfer/renew the license

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 3:21 pm

Actually, the Amigo was partially my inspiration for my setup. I had the Hiker Pro, and happened to notice it fit in the Nalgene. I know my setup's not for everyone, but so far, I'm happy with it! Best of all, it was free! (only because I had all the parts already, so "free" is relative).

PostedFeb 8, 2010 at 4:35 pm

Interesting…
My Pur Hiker filter fits snugly inside the Nalgene. The o ring on the Hiker collar keeps it there.
(for now at least…)
For Travis I have something else in mind. I might experiment this afternoon.
Franco
Hiker Nalgene

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 29 total)
Loading...