Topic

2 shelters dilema

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
Ed Barkowski BPL Member
PostedJan 27, 2010 at 11:57 am

I've reserved this question for a few weeks now, but the geek in me craves input and information.

Headed for the A.T. in April (VA-ME). Want the perfect UL solo shelter. Objective is go keep light as possible without sacrificing reasonable comfort/dryness. Willing to push personal limits if payoff. I've narrowed to 2:

1. TARPTENT MOMENT ($215, 28.5 oz)

Pros: Known high quality/construction (Owned and loved the Squall 2), excellent customer service, spacious, sound weather-protection, easy setup, vestibule, great price point, rugged bathtub floor

Cons: Roughly 19 oz heavier than option 2, larger packed volume, uses single-function pole

2. ZPACKS HEXAMID, cuben ($259, 8 oz)

Pros: Unbelievably light, tiny packed volume, strong & "sag-less" tarp material, Utilizes trekking pole (double-function = good)

Cons: Relatively uncharted territory (cuben's lifespan/mesh floor), more complicated/slower setup, higher cost, susceptible to ground splash/side-rain, no true vestibule, limited privacy, requires groundcloth attention/technique/"bathtubbing"

Realizing showdowns of this nature are commonplace, I am happy to receive any and all words of wisdom, experience and sway.

Andy Berner BPL Member
PostedJan 27, 2010 at 12:24 pm

I got a Hexamid and havent' gotten to use it yet. If you decide to go this route I will sell it for $245 shipped. It is the first netted version.

Let me know.

Andy

PostedJan 27, 2010 at 12:26 pm

What kind of weather can you expect?

The Moment would be far superior in wind, rain, and light snow. You aren't getting nothing for the weight increase.

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedJan 27, 2010 at 12:33 pm

Hard choice. I only had a week with the hexamid so far. Most of that in the backyard during a series of storms and one night out at Pt Reyes.

For low rain but high bug situations (most of 3 seasons in the sierras) the Hexamid looks like a real winner. Places with constant rain, hard winds, or modest snow the Moment wins. Mixed environments… do you want ease of use/camp life / dry space, or lighter weight. While the Moment goes up easier, the hexamid has a pretty easy setup.

The optional door for the hexamid does help a lot in the face of blown rain.

–Mark

Ed Barkowski BPL Member
PostedJan 27, 2010 at 12:42 pm

Add

I'm 6'2". This matters, in the case of coverage/splash.

As the A.T. is so heavily used, the mesh bottom of the H-Mid is a raised concern. Camping near shelters usually means setting up where hundreds/thousands have. This ground agitation typically results in a rocky, packed surface (vs. grassy or naturally-padded). Granted, I'll stealth camp when possible and convenient, but the temptation to gravitate toward to beaten earth will inevitably get the best of me.

Also, I anticipate plenty of rain – especially if 2009 was any indication. I'd like to stay dry.

Ed Barkowski BPL Member
PostedJan 27, 2010 at 12:46 pm

Andy – thanks. I'll consider.

Mark – How tall are you, and does the H-Mid cover well? Also, how does the door attach, and does it create a vestibule?

Anyone have photos taken from the INSIDE of the Hexamid? I'm interested to see how the mesh falls around the camper's body, etc.

PostedJan 27, 2010 at 12:47 pm

Not that I am trying to steer you away from anything, but there are other choices. What about a Mountain Laurel Designs SoloMid with the inner tent? You can set up the outer in the rain, climb in and set up the inner nice and dry. Includes a floor and full bug netting but is effectively double walled. You would be right on top of 20 oz with the Spintexx version (without pegs). You do need two trekking poles, however.

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedJan 27, 2010 at 12:58 pm

I am 5'10". At 6'2" you would fit in the hexamid. The question would be if you would be comfortable with the headroom at the edges. If I was 6'2" I would want a larger shelter… but I am somewhat of a space hog. I think someone 6'2" could manage in the hexamid if they were very careful how they moved.

The door doesn't create a traditional vestibule since it's inside the netting. That said, I use the space between the door and the ridgeline as a vestibute. The netting lets moisture to escape into the ground. I found in places where the ground wasn't completely saturated that this worked very well.

As to photos inside… I tried to take some but they didn't come out well. I will try to do some in the next week or two.

As David indicated. There are a lot of good choices. The DuoMid is much more stormworthy but while both the SoloMid/DuoMid are really nice, but they won't give you more practical length compared to the hexamid, and the innernet space is smaller. You might want to look at the SMD Vamp which was designed for taller folks.

–Mark

Ed Barkowski BPL Member
PostedJan 27, 2010 at 1:10 pm

SoloMid looks great too, but I'm favoring the all-in-one options. The 2-piece, 2-pole setup works just fine, but – and call me lazy – the one shot/one pole setup is tough to resist. Utter simplicity.

For awhile, I was leaning toward the GG SpinnTwinn with a bivy (maybe TG Raven), but then Joe V creates this monster, and I'm all eyes/ears. One pitch/pole, no rain/bugs.

Hiker 816 BPL Member
PostedJan 27, 2010 at 1:54 pm

Joe is also coming out with a 2-person version of the Hexamid. That might be a good option for solo use, as you'd get the extra space to help deal with lots of rain. I'm not sure how soon he'll be selling it, though.

PostedJan 27, 2010 at 3:09 pm

Ed – the SoloMid can be ordered with a perimeter mesh should you be so inclined.

;)

PostedJan 27, 2010 at 3:16 pm

I just found out about that earlier today. I love how it's one of the few ultralight shelters that allows you to have a great view. With all the stake out points I'd think it'd be pretty stable in a storm too. There's a 2-person version coming out that's much bigger and only a couple ounces heavier. I might get one later for short trips.

PostedJan 27, 2010 at 4:27 pm

"I love how it's one of the few ultralight shelters that allows you to have a great view"
Yes , if it doesn't rain.
Franco

Ed Barkowski BPL Member
PostedJan 28, 2010 at 9:05 am

Thanks to all for the info. I'm leaning toward the Moment but will attempt to wait to see what Joe comes out with in the next 2 months. We tall folks need to stay dry, too.

PostedJan 28, 2010 at 9:29 am

For a 1/2 thru hike go as light as possible, like a TT Sublite in Silnylon (if it fits you).

I own a Moment & love it. If you really like it go for it. You're a big guy and can carry the extra few ounces that will result in a good night's sleep in any weather. Plus. with only two stakes, the Moment has to have the fastest setup/take-down on the planet. I had a Contrail and liked it but the Moment is so much nicer. You can stow your pack in the vestibule to the left of the inner screen door & still cook in front of the door, out of the wind & rain.

But for one lb. less try to get the lightest tent (but not a tarp & bug netting). This is a
L O N G hike. You'll want to go as unburdened as possible. I recommend aluminum MSR Groundhog stakes for all around use and exceptional durability due to their Y cross-section.

P.S. Make up a lot of freezer bag meals to save weight and for better taste and healthier food. Take some good multi vitamins & take 'em every few days. REI sells CytoMax, THE best electrolyte mix I've yet found B/C it reduces the buildup of lactic acid in your muscles. No sore legs in the morning.

PostedJan 28, 2010 at 9:40 am

Since the MLD mids have been brought up I will throw in another recommendation for them. I am personally sectioning the AT, and I recently bought a DuoMid and a Soul side zip bivy for use on the AT. It's a great system in that you can use the DuoMid to "tent", and the bivy in the shelters (I use the bivy under the DuoMid too). Most don't bivy in the shelters per se, but I hate mice and the bivy keeps them off of me. Also, using the bivy under the DuoMid offers extra rain protection and keeps the critters off. Then of course if there is a nice (read dry) evening one can just throw down the bivy, and forgo the DuoMid all together. It's a quite flexible system.

PostedJan 28, 2010 at 11:43 pm

I don't have either of these, but the Moment would be a clear choice for me. I'm fairly certain that the pole is aluminum rather than carbon.

Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
Loading...