Hi Guys –
what is your take on free-standing vs non tents? I have had many hiking pole supported tents but was wondering whether a freestanding one would make more sense especially in very rocky terrain or during winter time where the ground is often frozen/lots of snow. Any advice is appreciated!
Best,
Sven
Topic
Free-standing vs non tent
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
Do you ever go out without stakes? If not the point is moot, isn't it. Comes down to preferences of the individual I think. I've got a double rainbow but never set it up freestanding outside. They are nice if you made a poor site selection, or fill it with sand and grit, but…..
Free standing is very convenient, but usually heavier. I've switched to a rainbow from contrail this year to be able to set it up on platforms quickly and to have more space. I like it a lot. It's not completely freestanding unless trekking polls are used, but it's only 2lb.
I opted to ditch the freestanding tents and went with a mid and or tarp this year.
Less weight. Less condensation to deal with. Overall I prefer the simplicity…no rain fly's to attach or poles to connect etc.
Regarding rocky terrain…just use rocks and what's around you instead of stakes. But if that's predominatley where you will camp maybe a light freestanding tent would be preferable- I hear that.
As for snow, I'll still go w a mid(floorless is fine by me w bivy) unless you are camping above treeline then I would opt for a tent.
Tents have their place and time but I overall conditions I encounter I prefer a non tent as you call it. :)
Thanks. Have you ever encountered frozen ground that did not allow you to use stakes? Use rocks then?
I typically manage to get some y stakes into frozen ground with the use of a rock as hammer. Or I use rocks as you mentioned, yes. It's usually the combination of the two. Or in my region if the ground is frozen there probaly is snow too whereas I would do and /or this and or try some deadman.
>Read This
http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/ditch_your_stakes.html
nice thread, I'm surprised I haven't seen this one.
A couple things I considered going freestanding for non-freestanding are.
1) I generally do not hike with trekking poles. A set of trekking poles are usually anywhere for 10-16 oz that I save over others. I realize they serve double duty, but the areas I hike are mostly trailess and trekking poles to me are more trouble than they are worth in the brush. So if you don't use trekking poles you can subtract that weight off your packweight choice for a tent. Suddenly a tent like the GoLite Utopia line doesn't look too bad.
2) Treeline here in this part of AK is only at 2500' and there are times in the scree and rock or tundra covered ground that has loose rock only a 1/2" down that staking just isn't practical.
Granted site selection can prevent this but I still think there is a time and a place for free standing tents. Especially if you are one that doesn't use trekking poles, they are still worth considering.
There are places that freestanding is nice but very few places where free standing is required. Generally I prefer the weight savings of a non free standing shelter.
When in snow or sand you can make use of deadfall / driftwood and/or snow anchors. The places I have been, a Y stake and a rock have always been able to get into frozen ground, though sometimes extraction was a challenge. Several times I had to dig the stake out of the ground which was surprisingly time consuming.
I have never found myself unable to set up a non freestanding shelter when backpacking… though sometimes I ended up shifting my shelter in a slightly different location that I originally choice.
–Mark
> I have never found myself unable to set up a non freestanding shelter when backpacking…
Agree
Cheers
Become a member to post in the forums.

