I know this thread is a little old, but it is really not too bad.
I have owned these shoes for long enough to LOVE them. I wear these not for trail running, but for backpacking. I also do day hikes in them and occasionally wear them to work for a little added flair. The most comfortable shoes I could have asked for, especially after trying about 6 different actual boots that sucked. There is not much protection from rocks and things, which I assume is more of a problem for the runners, since us hikers have much longer to look where our feet are going. They don't have a built-up heel like a lot of shoes, so footfall is more natural and takes some strain off of your knees.
Great shoe for trails, but concrete and asphalt will wear out the tread in a hurry (the soft rubber and tread design wasn't intended for use on-road, so not a negative thing).
I have the normal version, but I would love to have a pair with Gore-Tex in them, too.