Chris, I found the real problem with starting completely over is that UL backpacking requires a skill set almost over a gear set. I found that if you are heading out into the woods and you are solo or are in the lead that if you jump right to the end state you might be disappointed. Not because of the gear, but because of needing to know too many new skills to use it properly.
If you are interested I have a spreadsheet that has 2 complete gear sets with costs and weights (both <8 lb baseweight). One can be purchased from major online guys (REI & campsaver). The other is mostly cottage stuff. I also give a website where each item can be purchased. Just send me a PM if you want a copy with an email address.
But be warned the list will get you an ultralight kit with just a few mouse clicks and a cedit card. What it wont get you is the skill set to go along. So I recommend you take baby steps. Here is how I did it.
First few trips – gregory g pack, msr hubba, marmot hydrogen, and alcy stove+freeze dried food. (~15 lb base)
Next few trips – I went to Granite Gear Virga Pack, 5×8 tarp and montbell bivy, marmot hydrogen, and alcy stove+freeze dried food (~8 lb base)
Next few trips – Golite Jam2, poncho tarp + MLD bivy, golite ultra 20, homemade alcy stove+freeze dried food (6-7 lb base)
Latest trips – MLD Prophet pack, MLD cuben tarp + MLD bivy, Nunatak quilt (& JRB quilt), caldera cone stove+freezer bag cooking (self dehydrated) (4-5 lb base)
In hind site the best purchase was the marmot 30 degree hydrogen. Though I have purchased 5 bags and quilts over the last 2 years, the hydrogen would have worked fine for every trip I did.
I have found I can handle some pretty rough weather with a sub 5 lb kit. Had I started with this kit I would not have had a clue as how to handle it. Each trip I plan to learn a new skill. This is actually a big piece of the fun of a trip…learning how to use a new piece of gear.
Jamie