Topic

Starting from Scratch

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 28 total)
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 9:47 pm

Hi All,
I'm new to BPL and lightweight backpacking in general. Been scouring this site for every nugget of lightweight goodness that exists here. My wife thinks I’m obsessed but I think she’ll thank me when her pack weighs less than 20 lbs. I have so many questions but my first is this:

With what you know now, what would you do differently?

I’m mainly thinking gear wise but I’m game for some general philosophizing! If this topic has come up before, please feel free to point me in the right direction.

Thanks,
Chris

Laurence Beck BPL Member
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 10:32 pm

I got back into backpacking with my son's Boy Scout Troop so I just went out and purchased what they suggested. The result was 50-60 lbs. The leaders of that troop used to compete about who had the heaviest pack!

Then I decided to lighten up but I did not consult a resource like BPL. Ok, so I got down to a total weight of 40-45 lbs for an 8 day trip.

You are already taking the right path to get information from this forum.

PostedOct 17, 2009 at 11:18 pm

On hindsight, I would have:

– Bought more 'cottage' gear ie. Tim Marshalls 11oz cuben/down quilt instead of my 19oz Golite Ultra 20 quilt.

– Gone with a lighter (ie. cuben or Silnylon) frameless pack (ie. MLD Revelation) instead of a 210 denier frameless pack.

James Naphas BPL Member
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 11:49 pm

First, I agree with starting where you are: checking the forums. This one is real good, but there are some other good ones out there. But that's a bit off point on what I'd do differently.

I guess the first thing I'd do differently is to not do much shopping at REI, or listen to what their people say. 90-95% of what they carry isn't as light or functional as what is available via the cottage industry from places like gossamer gear, tarptent, MLD, ula equipment, six moon designs and others.

The second thing is that I should have stepped up and bought a tarptent right away rather than step through 2-3 progressively lighter tents. Maybe I should restate that and say that I should have trusted buying stuff from the cottage industry vendors a little earlier. Of course, the guys listed above are fairly established now vs. where they were at eight or nine years ago.

Third thing would be to focus as much on volume as weight. A bag that compresses better or a shelter that packs up smaller is usually not only lighter but leads to being able to carry a smaller, lighter pack.

Fourth thing would be to move to freezer bag cooking right off the bat. By doing that you can carry much lighter and compact cooking gear, and you don't have to do clean up anymore.

Jeff Patrick BPL Member
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 11:58 pm

There is a ton of information in these forums. Make use of it.
Then once you have a good idea, decide what type of a person you are and what is going to fit your needs.
1. Superultralight, ultralight, or light?

2. brand name, cottage, or homemade?- I had big designs to make a lot of my stuff myself but when I thought of the time it would take me, i decided to ditch that route. Instead I patrolled the gear swap for a couple weeks and came across some deals that were cheaper than what homemade would cost.

3. Tent or tarp/bivy groundsheet- do you need bug protection or do you want to be out in the open

4. sleeping bag or quilt- I bought a WM Summerlite which is probably my dream sleeping bag. Had a bad reaction to what happened to my bank account, canceled the order and bought a golite ultra 20 on sale.

5. keep track of weights as you buy things- make a spreadsheet now. This way you'll know how much shaving an ounce is worth to you. I found that with each purchase I wouldn't really care about an extra ounce, but they add up quick. For example, I got my golite long, which adds 2-3 ounces but I like the extra room it gives me under the quilt. I think these are good ounces. But the more you add these little useful things to each item you buy, the quicker ounces turn to pounds.

6. With that said, create a budget.- decide the total amount you are willing to spend on new gear and use this along with your spreadsheet to make smart choices financially as to what will lower your base weight most economically.

I think thats about it. Research is definitely the key. There are some gear lists on here that you can download and use (not sure where they are but there was a competition a while back) or you can PM me and I'll send you the one I made based off of Ryan Jordan's which is just beautiful.

PostedOct 17, 2009 at 11:58 pm

Decide early on in what conditions and environment you will be hiking. Early spring, summer? Mountains, desert? Dry, wet, etc. No need for a 20 deg sleeping bag if you hike summer months in 35-40 deg weather. Watch the weight of your cloths. Each item has lighter counter parts. Canister stove, easy to use, max 3 oz compared to white gas 14oz. You can always experiment with different cook systems once you are comfortable in your over all hiking system, such as alcohol stoves.
The single most important item of equipment for me that allowed me to be relaxed and feel secure on my hikes is my shelter/tarp tent. My main concern was wet weather. If you know that you can consistently have a bone dry camp, the question of down versus synthetic looms less important. Down being so much lighter to pack/compress is my choice. Buy most of your equipment first, then buy the right sized pack/volume, suspension, to handle your base weight. 18 lbs vs 35lbs base weight will influence your choice of pack. Lurk here, read and buy the lightest high quality bag, tent, and pack from the beginning, replacing gear with the latest and greatest can be expensive :)

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 1:56 am

"With what you know now, what would you do differently? "

Virtually nothing. It's been a fantastic journey.

A few pieces of gear advice, that I give over and over again. Don't buy a synthetic sleeping bag. They last only 2-6 years, whereas a down bag lasts 5-20 years. Synthetic, while cheaper in the long run, is more expensive. Disregard if you hike in extremely wet and cold environs.

Buy high quality unless you are of very limited means. That way you generally avoid buying the item twice.

Don't stress about it too much. The endless choices, and over-abundance of information, lead many to buy excessive amounts of gear. Try not to fall in to the rampant materialism hole. Such behavior is bad for the wilderness which we pretend to love so much.

Jason Elsworth BPL Member
PostedOct 18, 2009 at 2:31 am

You've had some great advice here, particularly from Jack. Over the years many people have contacted me with similar questions about buying photo gear. My advice has always been to research thoroughly (without driving yourself insane), make the best informed choice you can for your budget (buy the best you can sensibly afford, as it works out cheaper in the long run, but don't sell a kidney to get a cuben quilt), and then put the whole equipment issue behind you and just get out there.

It's just not possible to get it all right first time and you can drive yourself crazy pouring over information. You need to go through some in the field trial and error to work out what works best for you. You will make a few mistakes along the way, but it will be a journey and not having the perfect shelter is unlikely to seriously diminish the joy that comes form traveling in the wilds.

Andy Berner BPL Member
PostedOct 18, 2009 at 2:46 am

"Starting from Scratch". This is what I did. I spent so much time on this forum and cottage brand sites. I built a gear list with weights and prices and read up on each and every item that was an option. The search feature is your best tool. There really isn't anything that you can't find.

Look back at past articles and members gear list and see what they brought for certain conditions and understand why they brought those items. Your can really learn a lot and save a lot in the long run.

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedOct 18, 2009 at 5:31 pm

> With what you know now, what would you do differently?

I wouldn’t change much because it was a journey of discovery. Without trying a number of different things I wouldn’t have found what works best for me. Thank goodness for ebay and gear swap forums. Since a lot of ultralight gear can’t be rented, this provided a way to try items out for several trips and then recoop the money if it didn’t work for me.

#1… Know yourself

To often I chased what I thought I should do rather than be attentive to what worked for me. That said, I think it’s good to push beyond your current comfort zones… you will only know your true limits when you have exceeded them. I can give several examples:

I grew up typically doing no more than 10 miles per day… often 6 miles/day. In my mind serious ultralight packers did 20+ miles each day. I learned that I could do a sustained 20+ day and planned most trips to do this. I continue to push and found I could on long summer days get 40 miles/day in. But in the final analysis those trip were about counting the miles rather than enjoying the experience. I eventually figured out that I liked full days that where 15-19 miles, and 1/2 days that were 10-12 miles. I could do more, but it won’t be fun anymore.

I tried a lot of backpacks over the last 9 years. I think fairly early into in process it was clear that I really didn’t like frameless backpacks. Yet I continued to try them hoping to find on that would work because somehow I had gotten into my mind that the backpack really should be 1lb or less.

My final example of this is shelters. I downsized to a reasonably light weight double walled tent because I couldn’t quite bring myself to go with a tarptent. I couple years later I tried a tarptent and loved it. Pushed down to a poncho tarp. That wasn’t enough. Up to a small shaped tarp… which was ok. Finally back to a tarptent like shelter (GG The One) for three season use. I could sleep comfortably cowboy style or with just a tarp, but when I go to bed I found there was something nice about having a floor and integrated bug netting.

#2 Don’t over think / over analyze

I tend to be a bit obsessive about everything I do. I like objective data: run experiments, measure everything, etc. I think this has been helpful… but there was a season where I lost the joy of the trips because each trip was an experiment where I was constantly evaluating “Is this working?” “How does X compare to Y”. Some of this is reasonable… but make sure your trips don’t become gear evaluation trips.

> point me in the right direction.

I am not sure it’s the right direction… but I what written up (collected useful links) to mark’s recommended gear and a far from complete guide to light weight backpacking

Tom Clark BPL Member
PostedOct 18, 2009 at 6:53 pm

Use Gear Swap more. Lots of good equipment that you can get, and re-sell if it doesn't work for you so the penalty is small.

Ross Bleakney BPL Member
PostedOct 18, 2009 at 7:43 pm

I agree with several of the earlier posts. First, you can't possibly get everything perfect the first time. You have to figure out what is right for you (there are a lot of trade-offs). So, don't worry too much. Plus, you may want to gradually move towards ultralight. For example, try a closed cell foam pad (Gossamer Gear makes great pads) and see if it is comfortable enough. If not, than you'll have to get an inflatable. Likewise with a tarp tent. My wife and I are thrilled with our tarp tent, so I can't imagine going back to a double walled tent, but I also don't feel like trying a bivy and tarp (too many bugs).

As said earlier, try to get really good stuff, as it may save you money over the long run. For example, if you are going to buy a down bag, buy from one of the really good companies (FF, Western Mountaineering, Marmot, Nunatak, etc.). I would get a synthetic bag before getting a cheap down bag. At least then you would have a bag for car camping or rain forest camping.

The cottage gear is usually the best, and often just as cheap as the other stuff. Consider your needs, and buy appropriately. Don't buy a Propore (O2) jacket if you bushwack. But if you are on nice trails and careful, those jackets are very light and perform extremely well.

Buy your pack last (my biggest regret).

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 9:17 pm

Thank you everyone for the great advice so far. I wasn't expecting such a good response so quickly!

Just a little background on myself. I grew up doing a few backpacking trips with my dad. I didn't get fully hooked then but started back up about 6 years ago. I did a gear list for my last trip and tried to trim the gear I had as much as I thought possible. I made it to a 27 lb base weight for a 3 day trip (can't imagine what I was carrying before that). I live in Colorado and have done almost all of my backpacking here (generally 8,000-12,000 ft) from late spring to late fall.

Definitely been looking at cottage industry gear. Been eyeing the Double Rainbow or Scarp 2, various down bags and quilts, ULA and Gossamer packs. The one thing I'm struggling with the most is determining if such and such gear will work for the conditions I see and my size (6'3", 165lbs) without being able to go check it out in a local store. I haven't really checked out the gear swap that much so I might have to take a closer look.

Also, I've noted a lot of people mention buying a quality down bag. Any suggestions? I've been using a 15F deg mummy synthetic which I think has lost some of it's insulating power (6 year old). Not sure what it would be rated at this point but it was comfortable earlier this summer with just lightweight long johns and the mummy hood. I'm thinking I need to look in the 20F-30F deg range for a new bag and wear my insulating layers to bed when it gets colder.

I appreciate all the help!

Chris

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedOct 18, 2009 at 9:29 pm

I haven't spent a lot of time in the CO mountains recently (mostly in the sierras these days)… but I seem to recall some somewhat significant snow falls even in late spring and in the fall. Maybe global warming has stopped this? So I might lean toward the scarp 2 rather than the DR. If snow is a one in a blue moon thing, then the DR is a really great shelter. The other shelter I really like is a pyramid tarp (with or without a bug insert) depending on conditions.

If the 15F synthetic bag (most of which are optimistically rated) was warm enough for you, then you are likely a warm sleeping and a true rated 30F bag would be enough. That said, my experiences in the Rockies left me a bit cautious because I saw larger swings there then anywhere else. One trip in the middle of the summer sticks in my mind. When we started it was 85F and partial sunny. Later in the day the rain started. That night the low was 25F. We had only climbed 4k ft during the day.

As to what bag. The typical favorites are Western Mountaineering, Feathered Friends, Marmots 800+ fill bags, and Montbell (though I think they are sometimes underfilled). If you shoulders aren't to wide, my first suggestion would be the WM Ultralite which is a great bag for many. Personally I would go with a quilt from JacksRBetter or Nunatak.

–mark

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 10:02 pm

Mark,
Thanks for posting the links to your Outdoors page. I think I stumbled across it at one point and will have to check it out some more.

Yeah we definitely do get some large swings in temp. The saying I like is "if you don't like the weather, wait a minute." I've never been snowed on yet but am always prepared for the possibility. I've being eyeing pyramid tarps as well but don't use trekking poles right now and am not sure I want too. Also, my wife is a bug magnet so we would definitely need a bug net.

I consider myself a moderate to cold sleeper actually (but maybe I'm off on that). I took a trip about a month ago (lows in the low to mid 30s) with the synthetic and wore my midweight base layer thick socks, a midweight fleece and a wool beanie and slept pretty cosy. Not cold at all but definitely not hot.

I've been looking into quilts but haven't determined how drafty they would be (especially with going to a tarptent). How much weight saving do you see with a quilt vs the lighter down bags (for similar fills of course)?

Chris

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 10:16 pm

Andy,
I like the idea of creating a hypothetical gear lists to sort through the decisions. I think I will do that here shortly.

Aside: More than just lighting my load, this lightweight backpacking really captivates the engineer side of my brain. Creating spreadsheets, weighing items to +/-1g, evaluating different designs for boundary conditions. Now if I had only taken a sewing class in school…

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedOct 18, 2009 at 11:15 pm

Six years ago quilts has a real weight edge over bags for 3 season sleeping systems. Not so much true today. I think the quilt -vs- bag issue is more about personal preference now. Quilts are a win for people who feel constrained by sleeping bags (me) or people who tend to bring fairly warm clothing because it's easy to vary the girth of the quilt. Bags tend to feel a bit more cozy and are a bit more resistant to wind.

–Mark

PostedOct 19, 2009 at 7:34 am

I started from scratch a few months ago and if I had to do it over again I would probably buy EVERYTHING from the gear swap section. I am constantly looking for deals and havent paid anywhere near full price for anything but I still find it either cheaper on gear swap or I find what I REALLY wanted but was too cheap to get, for about the same price as what I spent already. If you don't mind getting things used you can really save some money. Everything i've gotten on these forums has been in top notch condition so personally I really see no point it buying it new.

PostedOct 19, 2009 at 10:04 pm

Steven,
What did you end up going with/wanted to get for the major items (shelter, bag, pack)?

Chris

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 3:20 am

I ended up getting a tarptent rainshadow 2 (I always hike with my girlfriend and our 80lb dog), a golite ultra 20 quilt, and a golite pinnacle pack. I probably should have held out for a ULA pack from gear swap but they were a little too expensive for me to buy new. I think i'm going to like the quilt and I got a pretty good deal on it. I would have preferred a jacksRbetter or a nunatak quilt although I havent seen one very cheap in gear swap yet so i'm pretty happy with my quilt purchase. I wanted a quilt because I really dont like being confined in a mummy bag. If I didnt mind that though I would have picked up a western mountaineering mummy bag from gear swap. The golite pack is nice but it might be a little too big for what I need…although being fairly new to all this I dont mind having a little more space and it will compact so it's really just a weight thing. I probably could have gone with a golite jam2 and saved a little weight.

Jamie Shortt BPL Member
PostedOct 20, 2009 at 6:25 pm

Chris, I found the real problem with starting completely over is that UL backpacking requires a skill set almost over a gear set. I found that if you are heading out into the woods and you are solo or are in the lead that if you jump right to the end state you might be disappointed. Not because of the gear, but because of needing to know too many new skills to use it properly.

If you are interested I have a spreadsheet that has 2 complete gear sets with costs and weights (both <8 lb baseweight). One can be purchased from major online guys (REI & campsaver). The other is mostly cottage stuff. I also give a website where each item can be purchased. Just send me a PM if you want a copy with an email address.

But be warned the list will get you an ultralight kit with just a few mouse clicks and a cedit card. What it wont get you is the skill set to go along. So I recommend you take baby steps. Here is how I did it.

First few trips – gregory g pack, msr hubba, marmot hydrogen, and alcy stove+freeze dried food. (~15 lb base)

Next few trips – I went to Granite Gear Virga Pack, 5×8 tarp and montbell bivy, marmot hydrogen, and alcy stove+freeze dried food (~8 lb base)

Next few trips – Golite Jam2, poncho tarp + MLD bivy, golite ultra 20, homemade alcy stove+freeze dried food (6-7 lb base)

Latest trips – MLD Prophet pack, MLD cuben tarp + MLD bivy, Nunatak quilt (& JRB quilt), caldera cone stove+freezer bag cooking (self dehydrated) (4-5 lb base)

In hind site the best purchase was the marmot 30 degree hydrogen. Though I have purchased 5 bags and quilts over the last 2 years, the hydrogen would have worked fine for every trip I did.

I have found I can handle some pretty rough weather with a sub 5 lb kit. Had I started with this kit I would not have had a clue as how to handle it. Each trip I plan to learn a new skill. This is actually a big piece of the fun of a trip…learning how to use a new piece of gear.

Jamie

Jamie Shortt BPL Member
PostedOct 20, 2009 at 6:46 pm

This thread has me thinking too much….so what would I recommend to someone to get their base weight down with the least amount of pain.

* Marmot Hydrogen Sleeping Bag – great bag + goes all sale
* Therma Rest Prolite sleeping pad – use it to frame your pack as well
* Golite Jam2 Pack – latest models are a bit heavy but still a great pack for the money
* Henry Shires Tarptent – Any version with poles that you like
* Snow peak giga stove (canister) + 700 ml pot solo (or 1.3 lt evernew pot w/gf)

This kit wont require much in the way of new skills and will weigh under 10 lbs.

Jamie

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 8:01 pm

Jamie,
No worries about the philosophical detour. As I said in the original post, that's welcome on this thread! I think you make a very valid point. I've definitely wrestled with whether to just lightening up my current kit with similar lighterweight options and cutting out the unecessary items or go full bore to a sub 10lb kit with lot's of unfamiliar items.

I've definitely looked at the Hydrogen and Helium. How low have you taken the Hydrogen?

PM sent for the gear lists. Always good to have examples even if I don't go with anything in the set.

Chris

Jamie Shortt BPL Member
PostedOct 21, 2009 at 5:57 pm

Chris, Gear list sent to your email.

As far as the hydrogen, I took it down to 20 degrees and 22 degrees on two different nights. Both times I was under a tarp (no tent) but was inside a 6 oz bivy sack. I used lightweight pads only, nothing thick. I do think I wore a Montbell down jacket to bed and fleece cap. The Montbell is a nice jacket but it is still <7oz in weight.

I would encourage people to go with the lightest bag they thick they might need. A heavy bag is a lot of weight that you will carry all the time and probably only really need maybe 1 in 10 nights. Instead just suppliment with clothing items when needed. I really think the hydrogen could take me lower (teens) if needed and I am a guy that gets colds easily.

Jamie

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 28 total)
Loading...