Seal Skinz are waterproof but not breathable like Goretex. My son took a high school trip last winter to the Yosemite Institute. I posted a question on the board regarding what to do. I did not want to buy a pair of $100.00+ boots for a 4 day trip.
Many suggested GTX socks. Since I got started late I could not get them locally. They also cost $60.00 or so. So, I found Seal Skinz for a bout $15.00 and he took them. They worked for him because he was not doing a lot of work. They spent one night out in a snow cave but did not do a lot of hiking. His counselor was intrigued and thought they were cool. He stayed nice and dry even while being in snow all day long each day.
I would not use them if you were planning on doing a lot of miles or if you sweat a lot as the moisture has nowhere to go. Of course, the other suggestion was to use bread bags. Not a bad piece of insurance.

