Martin: "I've had it down to 14F with a 1/8 pad and was plenty warm. "
Me: The NeoAir "gets too cold for me when the temp goes below 40*."
These opinions dramatically illustrate how much individuals can differ in their perceptions of what is comfortable!
In general (although not universally), women feel the cold more than men do (note that the EU ratings of sleeping bags take this difference into account). Also, most older people have more difficulty with their internal "thermostats." This may not be true for those with high blood pressure, but fortunately I don't have this problem (thanks, no doubt, to lots of hiking and backpacking).
Given those two factors, I have a double whammy against me.
All I can suggest is that you take all claims with a grain of salt and not go out on a 3-day backpack in the high mountains in shoulder season without testing closer to home.
Lynn also has a good point about ground temperature–the ground was pretty cold where I was, because, thanks to being surrounded by high peaks, in early October it gets the sun for only about 5 hours a day. I believe, however, that variations in individuals' body "thermostats" are even more important. I also found the NeoAir plus 1/8" CCF pad too cold the second night at lower elevation, at about 24*F/-4*C.
Both nights, when on my back, I had the interesting sensation of my front feeling cozy warm while the muscles of my back were shivering violently!
For the OP, I think Rick has an excellent test to be sure the problem is caused by Mr. Boyle and his law of physics rather than by a leak in the pad!