Topic

Some Neo Air Issues to Vent

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 27 total)
PostedOct 14, 2009 at 6:47 pm

I recently bought one of these at a store and used it outside for the first time a couple of weeks ago. When I woke up the next morning, it felt as though 25% of the air had escaped from the pad in the middle of the night. This is not to say that I was lying completely on the ground, but it led me to worry that perhaps I had a defective pad.

After I got back from the trip, I promptly returned it to the store that I bought it from and told one of the employees about the experiences I had while on my first outing with it. He was more than happy to exchange it out for me, but cautioned me about how it is normal for Neo Air sleeping pads to lose a little air overnight, especially compared to other pads that are more durable, and that in the morning I should not expect my pad to be as firm as it was when I went to bed. I have no clue where he was going with this nonsense, and almost felt as though he thought that I was making a big exaggeration out of things. That is a whole different story in itself though.

So low and behold, I test out my new replacement mattress this weekend. On Saturday morning, the pad seemed to hold up a lot better than the previous one I experimented with. Sunday and Monday morning were complete different stories. The same problem occurred; the mattress appeared to lose a lot of loft.

Now before anyone makes any quick comments, some things should be known ahead of time. I blew up the pad as full as I could before I went to bed. The temperatures were around 45 degrees on average in the three nights that I camped. Finally, I was not camping at high elevations.

Has anyone else experienced this with their Neo Air Mattress? Is this common and somewhat normal to a certain extent as that one employee told me? If you have any input you can spare, please take the time to fill me in. Thanks. As of right now, I plan on returning this mattress back to the store tomorrow afternoon and have given up on Neo Airs for the time being.

PostedOct 14, 2009 at 6:52 pm

Its odd. I have not experienced deflation at 11000 feet at 27 degrees. I have experienced deflation at 300 feet and 45 degrees. It rained for six hours the night it deflated a bit. I only noticed when I went to deflate the sucker, however.

Unless you're just totally disgusted with it, I would give it a few more tries. A few years ago at GNP with a BA REM AirCore, I experienced wild deflation issues at 9000 feet but have not before or since then.

Truly,

Jack

PostedOct 14, 2009 at 7:00 pm

This happens with all the blow-up air mats I've used. The difference in temperature between your breath at 98 F and a low of 45 F (which is often even colder at ground level) can be more than enough to cause a loss of loft. Even if you blew it up ahead of time and then topped it up at bed time, chances are the temp still dropped through the night between bedtime and waking. Mats lose thickness, tents sag and a lot of other things are affected by drops in temp.

Boozer BPL Member
PostedOct 14, 2009 at 8:15 pm

This is by no means Neo specific. I am 100% with Lynn on this.

PostedOct 14, 2009 at 9:50 pm

I actually find it quite comfortable to lose some of the air during the night. Body and NeoAir form together nicely.

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 1:15 am

Lynn is right: Cooling air contracts. Happens with all my pads, not just the NeoAir. I've used a NeoAir a total of 25 nights since I got my first one. (I've got a regular, medium and small) They rock.

I blow them up hard and, after climbing in my bag, let out enough air that my hip (I'm a side sleeper) is about an inch above the ground. Best night's sleep I've ever had in the woods.

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 11:03 am

Ok. So I have read what everyone has wrote and have a question. Is it me, or does the Neo Air tend to lose more air overnight than other pads? I understand where everyone is going with Boyles Law, but I am going beyond that and asking you to compare your Neo Air to previous pads that you have owned. I just got back from returning the pad, but I am still curious about what everyone has to say on this note. Thanks for taking the time to give me your thoughts on matters guys!

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 11:32 am

It depends on what pad you compare it to. A one inch foam self-inflating mat holds no where near as much air as a NeoAir, so won't contract as much when it cools (especially if it self inflates rather than using warm breath). But my 4 inch DAM will lose a lot more loft than the NeoAir, simply because it holds more air to begin with (though not warm air as it uses a pump sack to inflate).

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 11:37 am

Never had any pad lose air unless there was a puncture. On one of the original Thermarests developed a leak along a fold line, where I folded it lengthwise before rolling. Other than that the pad had to have been pierced. Dirt in the valve might cause a leak where the valve doesn't seal properly.

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 11:44 am

…than other pads I've had in terms of lost loft overnight, at least when considering pad volume as Lynn points out.

With the exception of my torsolite, which is very low volume, I inflate full size pads early when setting up camp so the air in them can cool before use, then I top it off before sleeping. That helps a bit.

Nia Schmald BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 11:55 am

I used the regular neoair for nearly 6 months on the PCT. I didn't notice much if any air loss over night. I inflated the pad just before going to sleep and made sure to close the valve tightly. Not sure what the problem is.

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 5:31 pm

Isn't it true that cold air is more compact than warm air?

Isn't this the concept behind a cold air intake on a vehicle? Cold air=more air per ci

So as the temp inside the mat cools, it compresses some? Would this even be noticable?

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 6:03 pm

"So as the temp inside the mat cools, it compresses some? Would this even be noticable?"

It depends on how much air is in the mat. With thicker non-foam cored mats is can be very pronounced.

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 6:17 pm

I have been using my NeoAir since spring and have had it down to 29 F so far. (I plan to take it as low as I can to see what it is comfortable to.) It does contract as it cools down. Other than that I have never had an issue with “losing” air. A good example is my Downmat 9. It gets filled with frigid air from the pump sack and it does not contract much if any that I can see. If anything I warm the air up in it once I am on it.

PostedOct 16, 2009 at 2:39 am

I don't use an inflatable mattress but I can draw some conclusions on quite a bit of real world experience.

I grew up playing a "ton" of driveway basketball. We quickly learned that if we brought the ball indoors and allowed it to warm up and inflated the basketball indoors (70F) and then set them in the garage during the spring / fall when it was around 35-45 F we'd come out the next day to a ball that was useable but wouldn't bounce for crap. We'd have to pump it up some. If we inflated it out in the garage while the ball was cold, it would be great the next day.

My wife's car has low air pressure alarms on her tires. Here in Michigan it is nothing for it to be 75F during the day and have a night that hits 35F. This will sometimes trip her low pressure alarm.

I can't imagine the amount of air in a basketball is much more than the amount of air in a sleeping pad, so if you inflate your pad and you see a 40 degree downward swing I would expect there to be some deflation. But again, I have no pratical experience with sleeping pads.

PostedOct 16, 2009 at 8:14 pm

I've used the MEC Kelvin Summer Pad which is a user inflatable design like the NeoAir. It's 3.5" thick. I find the NeoAir loses a similar portion of air.

PostedOct 16, 2009 at 9:01 pm

Not a neoair user but I also have deflation with many of my pads, many nights. The logic behind it makes sense, but in the field it seems a mystery as to whether it happens or not. I think the neoair is 2.5 inches right? Plus, no or not much foam inside of it? I'd assume it deflates more than my 2.5in, foam core Thermarest Luxury Camp, which is the pad in my arsenal that deflates the most.

PostedOct 16, 2009 at 9:14 pm

I have owned 8 or 9 inflatable pads over the years and my Neoair is no worse than any of the others. I always inflate my pads on the hard side and by morning they're just right.

PostedOct 17, 2009 at 12:51 pm

I inflate when I set up camp and let it deflate as it cools. Then, a few more puffs later and just before I turn in to limit the amount of warm air in the mattress.
It just gets more comfortable as it deflates a little in the night….on warm ground no problem.

However, on snow (ice) my butt gets uncomfortably chilled. I put a closed cell foam pad under the Neoair, comfort is improved, much warmer. I assume a pad under the Neoair would help to minimize deflation due to cold ground.

A 1/4 inch foam pad on top of the Neoair would seem to distribute weight a little bit more and minimize compression due to butts or hips. More air between skin and ice. Make sense??

I'm not sure whether it is better to put the foam on top of or on the bottom of the Neoair, but right off it seems that putting it on the bottom would minimize deflation and also provide added insulation. More experimentation is in order.

Any thoughts or comments would be appreciated.

Mary D BPL Member
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 4:39 pm

The deflation issue happens with any air pad when the air that starts at body temperature cools down; I learned all about it in high school physics 55 years ago.

I have other issues with the NeoAir. First, it gets too cold for me when the temp goes below 40*. A 1/8" GG Thinlight pad gets it down to about freezing. At 18*F (-8 C) last week I froze with this combination. I wouldn't take the NeoAir out again below freezing without a 3/8" or 1/2" CCF pad, which negates any weight savings. I did find out with trial and error during that 18* night that the NeoAir is slightly warmer with the CCF pad on top than on the bottom. It's also slightly warmer when blown up stiffer, but then it was not only too firm for comfort but "bucked me off" every time I turned over. I'm ditching the NeoAir and going back to my POE Insulmat Max Thermo (predecessor of the Ether 6) which will take me down to 20* without supplement and for quite a few degrees below that with a 1/8" torso length Thinlight. The POE pad is also a lot more comfy at any temperature and doesn't buck me off when I turn over. IMHO, the POE pad is well worth the extra half pound of pack weight! Your Mileage May and probably will vary–I'm a cold sleeper!

Lest you think I'm stuck in a technological rut, I really like the concept of the pad that Huzefa is developing! It would give me a pad warmer and thicker than the POE pad for the same or less weight.

M G BPL Member
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 5:00 pm

YMMV

I've had it down to 14F with a 1/8 pad and was plenty warm.

I do agree the NEOAIR is a bit wobbly given the height and width when fully inflated, but not cold for me.

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 10:09 am

So from what I am seeing, a large majority of you blame what is occuring on Boyle's Law and the remedy you suggested is using a 1/8" inch pad underneath the mattress. With these conclusions, I plan on giving the NeoAir one final go for the money and also buy a 1/8" inch pad to use in combination with it. Can anyone recommend a 1/8" inch pad that I could buy at a commerical retailor. I do not want to go through the process of waiting 2 weeks for one of the smaller guys online to send me out one by mail. Thanks for all of your help and recommendations. I am crossing my fingers this time around.

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 12:14 pm

I think you may find that the temperature of the ground becomes more important than air temp when talking about comfort. This may be why one person was fine at sub-freezing temps, and another was very cold. Personally I would want some true 'insulation' under me if I'm sleeping on ground below freezing, in other words some foam or down, not just air! As for the loss of loft, I always wake up through the night anyway, so I just top up my pad every time I answer nature's call.

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 12:28 pm

Michelle, I believe GossamerGear is the only place that has it. If you find a commercial retailer that has it, let me know. Perhaps you could look for some local places that sells hammocks.

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 27 total)
Loading...