Topic

Bivy or Tent for JMT early/mid October

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 12 posts - 26 through 37 (of 37 total)
PostedOct 5, 2009 at 2:35 pm

Not all of us are Brian Johnson….He was also attempting an amazing feat and suitably trained for it and understood his and his gear's limitations.

Most of us are mere mortals ;)

PostedOct 5, 2009 at 2:41 pm

That's true Dave. I'm certainly not recommending it. He also, for what it's worth, bailed a few times due to weather.

Back to the original question though–I would take either a full on mountaineering bivy AND a tarp shelter (duomid type) OR else a tent. If, god forbid, you're stuck up high, you want something strong to wait out a storm, and no it won't be fun, but a breathable bivy and tarp isn't going to cut it.

I had a trip planned last weekend for the Mammoth Lakes area and cancelled due to the snow…..glad I did after reading trip reports. Going solo in the snow unless you're very experienced w/ route-finding scares the bejesus out of me. I just wouldn't risk it.

Chris Morgan BPL Member
PostedOct 5, 2009 at 3:18 pm

It seems like you are getting a lot of grief here, but I think you will get even more grief from the Yosemite rangers issuing you permits. They are known to grill folks about their preparedness, especially in less than optimal conditions.

This August we experienced temperatures in the low 20's and there were reports of a snowstorm(!) that never materialized. It is important to note that for the southern half of the trail almost all the bailout points are over a pass, so you'll need the capability to go over the pass in bad conditions, or wait out a storm for several days until the pass clears up.

I personally would not feel comfortable doing a JMT trip this late, but then I have a lower risk-tolerance. I would have even more reservations doing this trip solo. If I had to do this trip, I would definitely take a PLB or Spot.

PostedOct 5, 2009 at 3:42 pm

Guess ditching in any REAL snowstorm (and consequent road closures) would require bailing to the west — longer distances.

PostedOct 5, 2009 at 3:46 pm

BTW, recently got a SPOT. Been playing with it. Would carry it for other's peace of mind. Would not derive much security from it. Breadcrumbs are neat though.

PostedOct 5, 2009 at 8:07 pm

" Yes, it is late in the season and the chances of having to abandon a tramp do increase."

Precisely, B.C. I think what people are concerned with is the nature of the bail. The farther south you go, the later in October it will be, with a higher probability of significant snow, and higher passes to get over if you have to bail. This can be extremely problematic for the strongest of hikers. As long as you are aware of what may be involved and ready to accept that potential existential challenge, go for it. Your life is yours to live, or lose, as the case may be.

PostedOct 5, 2009 at 8:23 pm

"Jack, what would you carry in terms of a tent on this tramp at this time of year?"

What I have is not ideal. And I've got a lot of tent!

But if I was heading out in the next week, hoping to do the entire trail, I'd bring my four season tent. It's a Bibler Tempest. Same tent that I'm bringing to Patagonia. http://www.rei.com/product/682732

I wouldn't want my silnylon shelters. And my other option, a MSR Zoid, I don't like.

hmmm.. on second thought, my Tempest is really too heavy. I'd probably carry my large tarp and goretex bivy sack. I've spent almost a hundred and fifty winter nights with it. It sucks in a storm, but I'm still alive. Weight is almost four pounds.

PostedOct 5, 2009 at 8:28 pm

Just checked. The 10 day weather forecast for the Sierra looks sunny. I'm head out as soon as possible and enjoy myself!

PostedOct 5, 2009 at 8:41 pm

Thanks Jack!

Yeah, Doug from the portal store/hostel (worth staying there just to hang with the dude!) says general pattern for october is 7-10 days clear and then a bit of a storm. Re-supply probably "killed" JMT for me this October. Of course, weather possibilities would tend to dictate increased rations and heavier gear anyway. Especially for someone who needs to go about 20 degrees F below manufacturers specs in just about everything!

Do you know where you're headed?

PostedOct 5, 2009 at 8:52 pm

Have you been before? 7 metres of rain/year. Went in December/January. Bought synthetic bag (one of the MH ones) and jacket (Patagonia Das Parka) especially for the trip — did Paine Circuit and a couple shorter walks. Then got pneumonia/asthma combo and lolled about. Heavy stuff but so glad I had it. Slept in a Macpac Microlight — Kiwi classic — people swear by them but I have since ditched it! Was glad to melt the fly while drying it over a fire on Paine. It was an excuse for a new 3 season tent. Have I-tent but kind of heavy for solo travel. Would have been a better choice for Patagonia. IMO, it's a place to take your time anyway!

Hope to get back this summer. Have some serious time off and need time away to come up with LT plans. This part of the world is relatively cheap!

PostedOct 5, 2009 at 9:01 pm

Ouch, sounds painful.

The plan right now is to bus from Buenos Aires, to Bariloche. Ride my bike south from there. So Argentine Lake District, Catterra Austral, Fitz Roy, Cerro Torre, Torres Del Paine, etc etc etc. Probably won't make it to the tip as I hear the wind is hell for cyclists. I'll be back in the states when the weather is right for the CDT.

You're bagging in the JMT? Why not just head to the mountains for some high country hiking. No need to do the whole trail. It's not the best anyways…

EDIT: you might have been asking about where I'm heading now.. duh. Driving across the Sierra, across Nevada, across much of Utah. I'll be stopping in various places, and will stop and turn around at the Escalante River. Should be GREAT.

PostedOct 5, 2009 at 9:25 pm

Wow, that sounds like an incredible adventure. Wind is CRAZY!!! Helicopter rescue is simply unavailable from what I've heard! If you have the time, you can wait around Tierra del Fuego and catch a ride on a Chilean naval vessel to Antarctica for a reasonable fee.

As for JMT — the prospect of a VERY heavy load probably did me in.

Viewing 12 posts - 26 through 37 (of 37 total)
Loading...