Planning to do JMT in early October. Probably around 2 weeks. Need to decide between MH Gore-tex pac-lite bivy or MSR Hubba 1 HP tent. Don't have the tarp business figured out yet. Choice for me is bivy (alone) OR tent.
Topic
Bivy or Tent for JMT early/mid October
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
I vote for the bivy, but temps this time of year might cause condensation problems. Pluses for the bivy are you can hike into the night and just plop down anywhere. Minuses are, well, it's not that great if you do get into some weather.
Can't figure out the tarp business? Why not just quick order an equinox poncho tarp and figure it out on the trail. You might want that lean-to to get out of the rain…and it's only like 7 ounces and super cheap.
Are you going to get snow? If so, the HP for sure. I have had several inches fall on me while in a bivy and it was not fun – compression of down bag; borderline suffocation.
I would want a tent on October for sure. You'll have most of the trail to yourself, that is for sure.
How will you be resupplying?
Tent for sure!! If you are caught in a storm you will be able to cook or just hangout if need be..Bivys are not fun in any type of storm…IMHO bivys are best suited for easy summer hikes only. Tents and bivys both have there benefits in the right season.. Fall is definitely Tent season… BBRRRRRRR!!!!!
A bivy as a stand alone would be pretty iffy IMO in October in most places. I suppose if you were a little more selective in camp selection and had the right bivy( event top) you'd be ok. A tarp is super nice to use in conjunction with a bivy; especially as the cooler temps of fall arrive. I'll be going with a MLD Duomid for this fall and winter. I like the being enclosed in the shelter during cooler conditions, but having the option/versitility to open it up when at all possible. The "eye brow" setup that MLD shows on their page shows the perfect balance in protection and ventilation. At a little more than $200(silnylon), you get a 15.5 oz, excellently crafted, versitile shelter.
Aaron –
"The 'eye brow' setup that MLD shows…"
Are you refering to the vent at the top of the mid or has something new come along?
Thanks
As someone who just came down from mid-elevation Sierras and was an eyelash from being snowed in… tent.
I also echo the question – how are you going to resupply? Yosemite's stores have shut down, and most other stores and resorts at elevation are also, or are shortly going to be, closing up for the winter. While the current light snow won't stay, it's getting more and more likely that there will be significant snow at elevation.
Here's what the MLD site says…
Extra Ventilation Trick: Pitch the front and/or back side a bit loose and then use the middle tieout on a 3'
line to pull the side out tight forming an large eyebrow shape edge to let under more air.
In all single wall shelters, especially in winter, ventialation is key to keeping me and my gear dry. This little trick is nice to know when setting up the Duomid I thought. Storm proof setup+excellent ventilation= =)
Yes, re-supply might be the breaker here! Body weight loss is not really an option. Posted elsewhere on this. Think VVR is open 'til 15 Oct. Thanks for the scoop on the tarp. I'll have to hang around here a bit more and get an education! Think I would need a lot of practice with one of those tarpies before a trip! You guys and girls are awesome. Love this place!
Many people report JMT to be a perfectly manicured trail — even a "highway". Short of white-out conditions, would route finding be especially difficult under a bit of snow?
:-)
Sorry. Personally, I don't think the questions are that stupid. There will always be naysayers — with various agendas. I have talked to many people who have done the walk at various times of the year. Overwhelmingly, they describe early October as usually stable and pleasant for walking the JMT. "No problem!" Yes, it is late in the season and the chances of having to abandon a tramp do increase.
:-)
Harsh weather experience? All relative, I suppose. I do not think I could make a judgement about someone from the information I have provided! Perhaps a discussion of what constitutes "harsh weather" on the JMT in October would be more productive. Thanks for your comments!
just trying to help.
you obviously don't want to hear it.
I've deleted my posts.
good luck.
"Bivy or Tent for JMT early/mid October?"
and
"Need to decide between MH Gore-tex pac-lite bivy or MSR Hubba 1 HP tent."
These two statements suggest that consideration to a winter storm was small to none, Or that you are very knowledgeable in winter route finding and survival.
But not wanting to assume, please tell me, How much winter experience do you have? Knowing that will greatly help in formulating useful responses.
Greg, I don't agree with your analysis. And I am not going to get into an "experience" contest with you! Trash talking is not my thing. Thanks everyone for your insight! And thank you especially for the reports of recent travel in this area! Though clearly weather related, re-supply is probably going to be the limiting factor here and NOT the possibility of a bit of winter weather.
Yeah, there seems to be a lot of hating going on. The point I believe is that October can bring serious winter storms that overwhelm even the well prepared and experienced. If you're neither, consider not going. If you are both, and are up for a potential epic, and have a high-ish risk tolerance, go ahead and think about going.
Sure, bring a tent. The "harsh" weather of an October storm could in a worst case scenario be about five feet of snow over 3-4 days. People die in October in the Sierra. It's more likely that the "harsh" storm of the month will be more like two feet. And it's quite likely that there will only be a few 2-6 inch drops. Or perhaps no more at all for the month. A Hubba 1 isn't a great tent for snow. And it'd be downright bad in a BIG snowstorm.
The Sierra can be fantastic in October. I'd love to go. Heck, I'd go any month of the year. And I fall in to the experienced, and prepared category. Both in terms of gear carried and being prepared (fatalistic?) about dying. Traveling outdoors is dangerous. If you go, have a superb time with the mountains all to yourself and the few other hardy people that are out there doing it, rather than sitting on the couch, or the computer.
Ms Chick,
No problem. I'm not any good at trash talking.
Enjoy your trip.
There are regions where the trail is worn into the ground like a trough, and others where an inch of snow will make it disappear leaving you on a high elevation pass wondering which way to go while the wind tries its best to rip your hat off, or push you off the edge entirely.
Given the weather trends and predictions, and lack of resupply opportunity, I would only go if I had sufficient practice navigating successfully in whiteouts, and had enough support that I could rely on someone snowshoeing or snowmobiling in to give me a week or two of food, if they had to.
Good luck in your endeavors. I'm heading for the coast, myself.
Jack, what would you carry in terms of a tent on this tramp at this time of year?
nevermind, this post came late!
Nate, I love your attitude! "Just figure it out on the trail." Seriously, that's my style though I'm trying to be a bit more of a "planner"! This is probably going to come down to the re-supply issue. Post holing with a heavy pack? Perhaps an easy cruise along the Lycian Way for the next few weeks.
Brian Robinson did the Triple Crown in all sorts of weather with just a poncho tarp and an emergency bivy. He saw all sorts of weather. Contrary to popular belief, setting up a poncho tarp is not rocket science. Obviously if the weather's bad, you go as low as possible, get under tree cover, and set it up there. It's not going to provide much protection for above treeline conditions. Which is why for the JMT in October you'd want a tent or mountaineering bivy for the southern portion of the trail.
I think my biggest fear would be route finding. If 8 inches of snow falls, and you can't find the trail, you may be in a bad situation. GPS and map and compass would help, sure, but I hate the idea of being lost in the snow….the JMT is not winter marked.
Become a member to post in the forums.

