Great pictures, thanks Dave.
Topic
Bivy Sacks?
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
If, you had read my post a bit more carefully, you might have understood that I was listing a number of factors that can/might be considered in choosing a given item of gear. I was NOT suggesting that one choose a bivy based on availability of rescue services alone and, with over 50 years of VERY active and often professional wilderness experience in western and northern Canada, I would not do so.
I merely wanted to add a little to the discussion as having participated in a number of rescues and recoveries as a part of my former employment, I can say that there are conditions where the I.D. type bivies will be a lifesaver and the others might not be.
I am looking at a mountain which is about a half hour drive from where I sit in my home where a couple of years ago, in mid-summer, VERY "warm weather", a young, fit man, from the N.E. USA, and described by his wife and friends as a "very experienced outdoorsman", went solo hiking.
He did not return and his frantic family flew here to encourage a massive search; they found his icy corpse about two weeks later, dead by hypothermia after a fracture sustained in a minor fall immobilized him….this in the most benign environment we have in Canada and it was mid-July.
I was in the eastern slopes of the Canadian Rockies a mere 10 days ago, it was very warm and lovely; it snowed there yesterday, about five inches and this WILL kill you if you do not carry a bivy camp that works in such conditions…as I have seen many times. It is a common occurence here where tourists from suburbanized areas come to experience the beauty of Canada's wild country….hence, my comments.
That is my point Exactly Dewey. I read your posts multiple times to make sure of my post. Each time I read it sounded like you making a list of things to consider. There was no statement such as "Some people factor in…" or anything like that. Rather it was "This depends on…and other factors…" I simply stated that, in my opinion, factoring in how easy is it is to be rescued when choosing a piece of gear is irresponsible.
I was not trying to argue. I agree with you. Being outside is risky. People seem to assume safety and predictability and for a small percentage of people that assumption can be deadly. However, without getting off track too much on what I think is an interesting discussion, I still feel most of the bivy advice given was overkill based on what this person asked for.
Certainly it is true that there are conditions where the ID bivies will keep a person safer than another. I feel that a lighter bivy with an event top and small net opening can serve as a backup for most conditions one would experience and that the benefits that the I.D. bivy offer are not so great as to warrant their use.
Dewey, as always thanks for the perspective. I KNOW where you trek and do not take your opinions lightly. Some trek in consistently calm weather on trail so hence some of the comments you are getting. Note also that for those in the mountain regions of Canada, 45C is reasonably balmy in July.
I think part of the confusion may also be directed to what was mentioned in the original post – the ID Unishelter. Hence, it implied a more storm worthy approach. In addition, there was a comment around 'additional warmth' in the original post. The ID's do provide additional warmth at the cost of additional weight. I am not convinced anything made of a pertex-like fabric will provide as much wind block and / or prevent as much convective heat loss than eVENT, but I could be wrong. Although MLD makes an eVENT bivy, it is 2ply and the interior layer can be fragile as per Ron so that may or may not be a consideration.
Thanks also for the information on the Bivanorak. I want it more breathable than that.
I agree David. Aaron needs to come back and make it more clear how he intends to use this bivy.
Has anyone read the report? Basically you scroll down, get the ratings, ID unishelter has the best rating overall. It get the nods for storm worthy (I can agree with this) and for summer bivy. MLD bivies weren't included in this review. Nor was Tigoat.
REally, we're just spinning our wheels without Aaron clarifying where he is gonna be out. If it is in the kind of places that Dewey speaks of, then a more serious bivy is certainly in order. C'mon Aaron, give us some info!
Well, everyone is entitled to their opinion, however, I consider factoring in the relative availability of assistance/rescue to be an essential aspect of gear choice, most especially here in western/northern Canada, where this is not as commonplace as in most regions of the USA, for example.
A case in point, is that I take slightly different and a bit less/lighter gear when dayhiking here in the BC Lower Mainland with my buddy than I do when hiking alone in the same places and much different than I invariably carry when going solo in remote BC locales.
That is all I was trying to impart and I DO tend to be a "belt and suspenders both" kind of guy, so, just feel more secure with my I.D. or Hilleberg setups. YMMV, of course and that is what keeps these forums interesting and a valuable learning tool for all of us…and the gear makers cheerfully counting OUR hardearned bux!!!
Haha, the gear makers definitely get a lot of $$ from this forum!
I see your point and understand what you mean in the case example you gave. That is exactly how it should be, I think, so we definitely agree.
I see what you mean about factoring in rescue where you hike vs. hiking in the USA. I did not think of that and it makes more sense now where your comment came from. I wouldn't argue that ID and Hilleberg setups provide more security! I think if I had them I would take those, over my tarp/Bivy combo that I have now, for trips that I needed to be prepared for anything. Though, with a good tarp and a nice eVent bivy I would feel safe in most weather experienced in N.E. where I hike.
What is the draw to bivys such as the ID Unishelter and BA Three Wire when they weigh as much or more than real tents?
Case in point is the Six Moons Lunar Solo at 27 oz or the HS Moment at 28 oz compared to the BA bivy at 28 oz or ID Unishelters at 31 & a whopping 40 oz!!! Heck, my HS Cloudburst Two only weighs 36 oz and it's a large two person tent. Additionally, these legitimate tents have vestibule storage/cooking space.
Why carry more weight for far less room & usability? I can hear the argument that bivys are warmer, which, can be the case but….. realistically, under most conditions, I don't believe they add any where close to the often touted 10 degrees.
On a high perch above treeline, you would have trouble setting up any of the shelters you mentioned, let alone having them remain standing up. They would be 'wind walls' with fabrics that have relatviely low tear strength.
The bivy shelters have the benefit of being extremely low profile and far more wind happy than a tent. They can also fit into places that no tent could ever manage and are made of more durable materials than the tarp tent variety.
Pick the gear to suit the conditions.
For ME, the simple advantage of a bivy tarp rig is due to ease of setup in VERY space-restricted situations, as in BC's steep and densely forested mountains here even my Hilleberg Soulo and I.D. MKI-XL tents are too "big" to easily find a good spot for. The bivies and tarps I carry have been chosen for EASY setup in such conditions so that I can erect them quickly should I fracture an ankle or kneecap and THAT is WHY I prefer them for emergency packs.
I also prefer to sleep under a tarp whenever I can in Grizzly country and just about anywhere as I like to look out in the early ayem and watch …the dawn come up like thunder… or, fall asleep in "the gloaming".
Now that you mention it, I have noticed it is easier to find a location for a bivy compared to a tent. I have always gotten by with my Cloudburst though and am always thankful to have it instead of my bivy in rainy weather. The environments I'm traveling in however typically provide many options for shelter size/placement.
Thanks.
Thank you so much everyone – and thank you for requesting more info in order to better guide me.
I think I did post, in response to Todd, that I would be using it most immediately in Baja – but that I would like to be able to use it wherever and forever (as much as is possible, at least)….
So I think I really am looking for something that's top of the line, and the ID Unishelter's top rating for both storm and summer bivy appealed to me.
So I guess I'm just really asking – since that State of the Market Report was from 2006 – whether anything has come along since then that would displace the ID Unishelter for all-around best performance as a summer bivy and storm bivy?
Thanks again for all your help.
Best,
Aaron
I have given this issue some serious thought and, no, IMO, there is nothing that quite equals the I.D. EVENT Unishelter as a "do it all" bivy, at least for western and Canadian conditions. I like the look of the BA-3-wire very much, but, it is larger, bulkier and thus maybe a bit heavier than the ID and thus is more suited to short trips in winter where it will do well as a stand alone shelter…and I would love to try one for that purpose in the timbered interior of BC where it would be all one would need for 1-3 night trips.
My recommendation and I don't bother with any gear that is not "carriage trade", due to long and sometimes "bitter" experience, IS the ID EVENT Unishelter plus a Siltarp II or, my preference, STIII. I have and have used STs and other tarps from the 5×8 size on up and I am willing to carry the few extra oz.s of the STIII to get the substantial extra "living room"….this is largely in our very wet autumn and spring conditions, YMMV.
ID gear costs, no question and I would suggest using a Tyvex ground sheet UNDER a bivy when in rocky regions to save the floorsheet from pinholes, or, using a EVA auxiliary pad UNDER the bivy, as I do and your NeoAir or whatever inside….works well for me.
HTH, I have had my ID Uniushelter since 1994 and it is my main rig for traveling and setting up O/night un expected camps; it has never failed me and is still like new, so, these are a longterm purchase and the EVENT model IS worth the extra cost…check "Prolite" for some deals.
I am going to go the other route. I think the BA 3 Wire is a better rig than the Unishelter, especially with the updates to the 3 Wire. Why?
-freestanding. The Unishelter requires 1 peg at the head end and if you toss and turn you will pull out the guyline in soft soil collapsing it on your head. Trust me, I know.
-more space in the head area with a much reduced feeling of being closed in.
-superior ventilation options. The second mesh door goes almost to your waist so it is a great summer option with bugs. You can leave the outer door open a bit in the rain. The Unishelter only has a small band of mesh and is noticeably stuffier. Open the outer door in the rain and you will get wet.
-you can actually get out of the 3 wire without letting in a ton of rain because how the 'awning' overhangs. With the Unishelter, if you unzip in the rain you get wet.
-I do not trust waterproof zips (on the Unishelter). The BA has a rain flap.
-The BA weighs 1 ounce more packed but comes with 6 pegs. The Unishelter does not come with any pegs. The BA is effectively lighter.
The new 2010 version of the BA 3 Wire has some additional features now. The poles set up from the outside more easily and the zip to get in extends down further. The color has also changed.
Essentially the BA takes a great product in the Unishelter and makes it better. The BA is the best storm bivy shelter in production in my opinion.
See the pics I posted previously to see some of the differences I mention.
Do you live near PA?
David makes some valid points here and, as I posted, the BA bivy is probably the "best" STAND ALONE rig available. I always use a tarp with a bivy and thus felt that the ID was better as it seemed lighter and more compact.
David has tried both and while I wonder HOW the BA IS lighter than the ID, unless they use far lighter and less "bombproof" fabrics, his recommendation here may well be a better option than mine, in an ultralight situation.
The new BA sure seems like "THE ANSWER" for a simple, light shelter which will deal with severe weather and still be U/L to carry. I wish they would make it in a dull, earth colour for hunting and nature study, as well as in bright red.
Thanks Dewey (Kute).
The BA is slightly shorter, although enough length for a 'long' bag and then some. The ID also has the rear vent. I suspect the two offset the addition of the pole(s) on the BA.
As far as color, the new BA comes in red now – no longer orange if that is a consideration (I am the gear enabler – sorry about that).
For when the weather's OK, what's your opinion between the two in terms of "feeling outdoors" (yet bug-protected)?
The BA appeals to me because it has so much more bug-netting, presumably allowing you to open up to the outdoors (and still be bug-protected). But I don't know if that is out-weighed by the fact that the "awning" is (or looks) so much bigger? (Seems like there would certainly be no gazing at the moon/stars – or gazing at much of anything – with that BA awning!?)
Which one leaves you feeling more "closed in"? and which one allows you more of a view and feeling of being outdoors (yet still be bug-protected), when weather permits?
Or does anyone have any other suggestions in this regard? Seems like the MLD would be even worse, with such a small window?
Thanks again for all your advice!
Best,
Aaron
looks to me that if you want to stargaze you could just unclip the apex of that beak and roll the grey part back, or slide back on the previous version (?)
Franco
Become a member to post in the forums.

