Topic

Bivy Sacks?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 44 total)
PostedOct 3, 2009 at 6:09 pm

Since the last thorough review of Bivy Sacks on the site was 2006 – and I can't find any at all on Backpacker.com – I'd appreciate people's advice on Bivy Sacks. I'm further flummoxed by the fact that the BPL Vapr Bivies seem to have disappeared.

Anyway, according to the 2006 report, it looked like the Integral Designs Unishelter was the best bet. But that was 2006 – and it didn't include the new The North Face Backpack Bivy or others from MSR, RAB, Integral Designs, etc.

I'm looking for the best Bivy Sack for bugs and warm weather sleeping – and for adding a little extra warmth and sleeping warm – that's waterproof on the bottom, breathable on the top, and has a bug net in the hood.

Thanks and best.

PostedOct 3, 2009 at 6:34 pm

Can't go wrong with an MLD Superlight. Momentum top, silnylon bottom and a mesh window to allow breath to escape and keep out bugs. And simple. Andy Skurka uses a custom model with a more durable floor, sil 2.0.

Joe Clement BPL Member
PostedOct 3, 2009 at 7:21 pm

Another vote for TiGoat. And I can't imagine Backpacker testing any bivys I'd use……..

PostedOct 3, 2009 at 8:28 pm

I have three or four bivy sacks ranging from the 2.5 lb plus OR “advanced” bivy with a couple of hoops to my current favorite the Oware drawstring. It weighs about 6 oz, is waterproof on the bottom and very breathable on top and has a lot of netting. The draw string makes it light and simple. Cost about $95 from BPL and a bit more direct from Oware — must be something to do with the member discount.
My wife and I each have one and, with a 10×10 tarp, our complete shelter system weighs under 28oz for 100 sq feet.
Here they are with the tarp and every thing else we carry in a backpack
Tarp Camp at Bare Loon Lake, Chilkoot Trail

Tim Marshall BPL Member
PostedOct 3, 2009 at 9:41 pm

how easy is entry exit in the drawstring bivy? I thought many times about making this design for myself as it would be very simple to construct.

-Tim

PostedOct 3, 2009 at 10:28 pm

Thanks, Todd. Most immediately in Baja – but I'd like to be able to use it (as much as possible) wherever and forever….. :)

todd BPL Member
PostedOct 4, 2009 at 11:02 am

Then you should be able to get by with any of the above mentioned bivies. The Equinox bivy is awesome and cheap, but you will need a headnet or other bug protection.

I know you specified you want built-in protection, but a bigger net could be added to the Equinox, and you'll pay less for that combo than for the other bivies mentioned.

PostedOct 4, 2009 at 12:36 pm

If you are looking for a storm proof bivy, then the Unishelter is a good choice, although I would look at the Big Agnes 3 Wire Bivy. eVENT is the best and this bivy has pelnty of room and will do well in high wind conditions. It has also been recently revised with the poles now in the exterior. It has substantially more room than any of the other bivvies mentioned which are more simple sleeping bag covers.

PostedOct 4, 2009 at 6:25 pm

I agree on the Integral bivies and consider them the best overall that I have seen or used; I have a Unshelter, Bugaboo-eVENT and South Col-eVENT and I never leave my vehicle, horse, plane or boat without a bivy-tarp in my emergency pack.

Just did a trip in northwestern BC, it poured rain and we got soaked while looking for a RM Goat for my buddy. I did not care, even in that remote locale as I have bivy-camped in such situations many times and know I am safe and wsill be warm and dry as soon as I set up my rig and change into my spare merino base layer.

I like the look of the new "Three Wire Bivy" from BA and I might well buy one for winter hiking and short camping treks, probably get a bright coloured siltarp to go with it. Nobody makes exactly the bivy I have a mental image of, but, that one comes very close.

PostedOct 4, 2009 at 6:33 pm

FYI – I'm seriously considering getting an ID Overbay/Bivy (all eVent) for use as a stand-alone shelter in winter (mostly) and fringe season use.

PostedOct 4, 2009 at 7:00 pm

"how easy is entry and exit in the drawstring bivy? I thought many times about making this design for myself as it would be very simple to construct."

Tim,

It really isn't difficult to get into and out of the drawstring bivy once you get comfortable with it. The opening is as large as the girth of the bivy. I think it is easier than the clam shell style but less so than a side zip.

PostedOct 4, 2009 at 7:10 pm

Matt – I have an all eVENT overbag and it is awesome. I do wish one could get a slightly smaller size however. It is quite large.

I have also been looking at the Hilleberg Bivanorak as a multi-purpose bivy, rain / wind shell, and pack cover but I think the breathability may be quite poor.

PostedOct 4, 2009 at 8:23 pm

David: could you describe the closure system and stormproofness of the hood/entry? Thanks. Photo could be cool.

PostedOct 4, 2009 at 9:16 pm

David,

Now that the 2010 big agnes bivy is changed, which bivy do you like more, the Big Agnes or the ID event Unishelter?

Thanks

Dan

PostedOct 4, 2009 at 9:55 pm

Hi Dan,

I like them both…;)

The Unishelter has the benefit of the rear vent and the ease of getting into compared to the pre-2010 3 Wire. The BA has more mesh and more room in the head area.

However, the changes to the 3 Wire, I believe, but it ahead. It now has the poles attached on the outside which will be easier than the previous model. It has more mesh than the Unishelter and now has a longer zipper for easier entry.

Here is a pic of the two set up side by side (2008 BA).Bivy Comp 1

PostedOct 4, 2009 at 10:53 pm

Another happy user of the old ti goat bivy here.

Matt, here are some pics I posted a while ago of the ID overbag. As mentioned it's HUGE so if you're without a tarp and the precip starts, depending on how tall you are, you can just slide down further into the bivy, pull the hood in so it doesn't catch water and pull the bottom part of the opening over your head.

I bought this bivy as a primary shelter for use without a tarp and it's been great. A little smaller and some bug proofing and it would be perfect.

http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/forums/thread_display.html?forum_thread_id=17197

PostedOct 4, 2009 at 11:09 pm

Good to know. I'm glad it is long because although I am 5'6", my winter bag is a long (and also sufficiently puffy). Like I said, it's definately on my radar. I'm likely to go with the all-eVent model because I'll likely use it on snow in winter and fringe seasons.

PostedOct 5, 2009 at 1:46 am

I would not choose ANY bivy as a …stand alone… shelter for weather harsh enough to potentially cause Hypothermia; I have had a couple of unpleasant experiences trying this. A bivy really requires a tarp to reach it's full potential, IMO, and an ID STII is a good choice and there are LOTS of others.

Obviously, this will be determined by the climate regime one is in, the degree of genuine "wildness" and other factors such as length of trip, personal comfort level and availability of rescue services, etc.

On the Bivanorak, I have one and sometimes take it, combined with my Exped Wallcreeper Pl. bag, an item I specifically carry for survival on day hikes around the Lower Mainland of BC. It works, like the Black's of Greenock Cagoules I used to carry since the late '60s, but, it WILL condense on the inner surface.

This rig works extremely well with my Wildthings Pl "Elephant's Foot" bag and I.D. Dolomiti jacket for the most basic survival system I have and one that I trust in about any BC weather. It is a high-vis. red and designed for Swedish Air Force pilots if they have to "ditch" and it works.

I would probably not have bought my ID eVENT-Bugaboo in yellow for an emergency hiking shelter or the Silshelter that goes with it, also yellow, had I known of the Bivanorak before doing so. The Bivanorak is NOT a "comfortable" camp type of rig, but, it will save your azz if you get lost, injured or just run out of daylight when in the bush.

As with all Hilleberg products, it is built like a tank and will probably outlast the original purchaser.

PostedOct 5, 2009 at 7:06 am

Dewey Posted: "Obviously, this will be determined by the climate regime one is in, the degree of genuine "wildness" and other factors such as length of trip, personal comfort level and availability of rescue services, etc."

Unless you mean camping in your backyard or something, I gotta say it's never such a great idea to plan your gear based on how easy you can be rescued. That is a terrible way to start a trip and endangers many lives etc. etc.

Aaron originally asked about getting a bivy sack "for bugs and warm weather sleeping – and for adding a little extra warmth and sleeping warm – that's waterproof on the bottom, breathable on the top, and has a bug net in the hood."

Why are people suggesting ID eVent bivies for this? Does he really need some 18oz Alpine grade bivy just to keep bugs off and add a little warmth? Geez, get a MLD superlight or TiGoat Ptarmigan and call it a day man! If you want more netting than the Superlight has I'm sure you can ask Ron to add a larger section.

Either of these simple bivies will accomplish everything you want! No need to go overkill here. If you want to add full weather protection for 3 seasons than get the MLD Superlight with eVent top. If you want to keep it nice and simple, those are some of your best options. Either way, you definitely do NOT need an ID bivy for what you asked for and in my opinion it would be a waste of money and weight to get one.

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 44 total)
Loading...