Topic

Which WP Bivy Should I buy

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 20 total)
PostedSep 22, 2009 at 12:51 pm

I'm looking for a fall/winter/spring wp Bivy to be used as a standalone shelter or w/a small poncho tarp. I would ideally like a storm proof, standalone shelter that I can fit my 15 degree bag and a small Neo-Air inside the bivy AND sleep on my side (more room needed for this usually).

I can't decide between these options, so wondering if someone w/them could give some advice:

ID Micro Bivy:
Pro's: Lightweight, durable
Cons: Doesn't seem to be stormproof? Also, not sure if it's big enough for side sleeping.

ID South Col:
Pros: Looks big enough!
Cons: A bit heavier.

Rab Alpine Bivi:
Pros: Looks Stormproof
Cons: No info on size or feedback from users on the web, so unsure about this option.

Oware PTFE Bivy:
Pros: 12 oz! Super lightweight and definitely big enough. (I like the fit of this bivy the best. Can have overhead views but still zip up to be stormproof.)
Cons: Not as breathable as eVent? Unsure again, because no one on web seems to have reviewed it.

Anyway……biviers help me take the plunge!

PostedSep 22, 2009 at 1:13 pm

I want a waterproof bivy. Want to sleep out under the stars in the Fall/Spring….I always use the TiGoat in the Summer, but you can't use it standalone. It's practicaly just nylon with a DWR finish.

PostedSep 22, 2009 at 1:41 pm

How about the MLD soul side zip (or something like that) bivy. eVent top and all. Or doesn't it zip closed over the mesh?

Tony Wong BPL Member
PostedSep 22, 2009 at 2:20 pm

Nate,

I have the MLD Soul Side Zip in Wide with the eVent top.

It is pretty bomber/waterproof and it has two sets of zippers for the head area.

One is for the large amount of bug netting and the 2nd set of zippers are for the bivy…..in theory, you could zip it up to the point that you have a blow hole for breathing.

I would still recommend having a small tarp to give some overhead protection in rainy weather. The "visor" that is on the bivy will help with minor rain drops, but in a heavy storm, water could get into the bivy.

In a pinch, you could easily sleep in it for the night in the rain and stay dry.

I use mine all year around with a MLD poncho tarp.

Mine is about 2 yrs old and the workmanship is fantastic and is 13 oz with the 1.5 oz metal wire for the hood, which can be removed.

Worth the money, but a bit pricey….maybe the only bivy you will need for the rest of your life. :)

I don't have a neo air, but I have used my 1.5" thick thermarest prolite 4 and 15 F sleeping bag inside and had plenty of room. (I am a back sleepers, not side sleeper).

I would suggest emailing or calling Ron to see if you would have enough room for side sleeping.

That said, I would definitely go for the large/wide option, which I have.

My friend, Jeremy, has a regular sized MLD bivy, superlight and he looked a bit snug in there with his 15 F bag…..so go Large/Wide.

Hope that helps.

Good luck in your gear quest.

-Tony

PostedSep 22, 2009 at 2:24 pm

Tony, I've seen the photos of yours and I have major gear envy!

Alas, the MLD is a bit pricey for me especially for one that wouldn't keep me absolutely dry….(I just don't think it's worth it (to me). Mammothgear.com and frontcountry.com have crazy good deals on eVent bivies right now, making them very affordable. ($150!)

I kind of want one where I can just plop it down, crawl in, go to bed, and if it starts raining not worry about it and not have to get out the 'ole poncho tarp. Of course, if it's raining to begin with I'll probably set that up first….

Tony Wong BPL Member
PostedSep 22, 2009 at 2:44 pm

Nate,

I hear you.

Scary, but I spent about the same money on my bivy as I did on my 15F 850 fill down bag….no regrets, but not cheap in any sense of the word.

When I was shopping for my bivy, I had never used a tarp before and I have slept in a wet down bag before, so I wanted a bomber bag that I could throw down without a tarp and survive.

If this adds a little perspective for you, in hind sight, I think that mine is overkill for most of what I am facing in the Sierras.

I have enough experience with the poncho/tarp that I think that what Jeremy has, the MLD Superlight in large/wide, would be fine.

Not bomber, but setting up the tarp is pretty easy to do and gives plenty of protection….the DWR on the Superlight is good enough for any rain driven spray that might get under the edges of the tarp.

Bonus is that it is lighter and cost less….not too far above your target price range.

Frankly, now I am at a point that I like to sleep with the bivy opened up at night under my tarp or without the tarp to see the stars…to be more connected with the environment.

What I love most is that the bivy just takes up a rediculously small amount of room, so that I can camp just about anywhere.

Being lazy, I have even camped under a large tree with my head at the base of the tree trunk….hoping that the tree limbs/branchs would give me the shelter from the rain hitting my head area.

Guess my point is that bomber is nice, but you might find that will some practice with a tarp, you might not need the weight and expensive of something like that.

-Tony

PostedSep 22, 2009 at 4:46 pm

Well, I contacted Mammoth gear and got some pictures of the RAB Alpine bivy…RAB Alpine bivy

Rab Alpine bivy

I really like the opening because as a side sleeper it would cover me completely like a cocoon. Weight is roughly 22 oz. Price is 150 for eVent.

PostedSep 23, 2009 at 10:19 am

Looks like I will be making a larger bag for some. Will
have a girth over 80" and have side zipper. Some in 2 layer
PTFE as breathable as eVent and some in DWR ripstop for the
top.

PostedSep 23, 2009 at 12:39 pm

Nate,
I have the ID All-Event bivvy. I think it's the same dimensions as the Micro bivvy. I can fit a full length Downmat 7 and a winter bag (although i now mostly use a quilt) in it no problem. I'm a side sleeper, and there is plenty of room for me. I'm 5'10" and around 175lbs.

It has a drawcord on the top and bottom of the opening, so you can't fully close it, but i would carry a small torso tarp anyway.

Doug Johnson BPL Member
PostedSep 23, 2009 at 10:06 pm

I have a Rab Super Light- all eVent- and I love it. Great bivy!

No bug netting- mine has an alpine and winter focus in my kit.

PostedSep 23, 2009 at 11:58 pm

Thanks for the replies!

Dave, the wide girth bivy would be a great addition to your line….one with a cuben bottom and eVent top would be amazing.

Glad to hear the good feedback on the RAB. I think I'm going to take advantage of the wicked sales and get a RAB one. Looking forward to having the simplest shelter possible and walking past dark without worrying about soft soil for stakes and perfectly wind and are large enough to accomodate my Hut. Oh exciting!

PostedSep 24, 2009 at 5:34 am

Check my post at Backpacking Lightweight for a screaming deal on a NEW U.S. military Gore-Tex bivy. $99.
One post there has an even better dealon the same bivy. $64.!

Eric

PostedSep 24, 2009 at 6:35 am

Nate:
Check out the alpkit hunka bivy. Super waterproof. I've slept outside with it a couple of times when it was raining pretty hard and was fine inside the bag. You have to find a way to close up the entryway, because it has a cinch cord rather than a zipper, but that was OK for me – I just turned it to the side (I'm a side sleeper anyway).

Mine weighs about 13ozs, so it is not UL, but very durable and waterproof, and pretty cheap too! Anyway, even with shipping to the US the hunka came in at <$90. Their website is alpkit.co.uk.

Also, why not just bring a tarp and put it up, then sleep next to it. If it starts to rain, just shuffle under the tarp!? That way your UL tarp will work fine. Just my 2cs.

Good luck!

Peace, James.

PostedSep 24, 2009 at 6:54 am

Doug,
Is the Rab Super Light roomy enough for a winter bag? Something like WM Lynx?

PostedOct 1, 2009 at 12:42 pm

So I went ahead and pulled the trigger on the Rab Alpine Bivy. I love the simplicity of the design, and the lack of any overhead cinched area which would inevitably become a water source in a downpour.

My gripe so far is the girth is not enough for a 2.5" inflatable pad, a high lofting winter bag IF I side sleep. (I think the issue of side-sleeping and bivy girth is underexplored…those of us who curl into fetal balls don't need length, we need girth!)

Anyway,

Here's a link to a video of me in the bivy getting hosed down!. Bone-dry inside.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZVHgzpDHZbM

Roger B BPL Member
PostedOct 1, 2009 at 1:19 pm

Great video, now you need to try Quoddy’s snow and Tarptent Sublite test, found here

The thicker pads may challenge some bivy’s, that is why when I am looking at a bivy I always look at its girth.

PostedOct 1, 2009 at 1:44 pm

Could it work with the pad outside the bivy?

Mike suggests the Integral Designs overbag has room for a downmat 7 and winter bag and that he's a side sleeper. Does that mean it has a wider girth?

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 20 total)
Loading...