Topic

New to UL backpacking… shelter question

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
Adam Frizzell BPL Member
PostedSep 5, 2009 at 6:25 pm

Hello all,

This is my first post, but I've been lurking around for a month or so… basically soaking up all the info everyone has to pass on on this site. Amazing stuff and thank you!

Right now, I'm looking over the "standards" in light weight shelter options, and I'm really into an MLD tarp set up. I start thinking in oz. and $ and I have questions:

I could go for an MLD Grace Solo SilNylon Tarp and Serenity Shelter for ~$245a at ~18 oz. and have tons of pitching options, protection from the occasional mid-atlantic bug madness and 360 views. Pretty appealing.
I could also go for a Contrail for $200 at ~25 oz., and it's one piece easy.

So, I guess, I'm thinking… what am I missing here? $50 more for a tarp and bug shelter. I see a lot of the advantages and disadvantages here (more than listed below… this post is already a book.):

More money
More "stuff"
Less Weight
Almost infinite pitching options

I know that any way I slice it, I can't go wrong with either option, but I'd love to know which direction you would go and why.
Spend the extra $50 for the versatility of a true tarp set up or go the cheaper "idiot proof" (after learning curve) of a Contrail?
Pretty awesome that a decision between two amazing and scrappy manufacturers is my biggest concern at this point! :-)

Thanks in advance.

Adam

Doug Johnson BPL Member
PostedSep 5, 2009 at 7:26 pm

Adam,

Welcome to Backpacking Light! You've definitely come to the right place.

Your thinking is good here for a solo setup. Both ways have advantages.

Starting with the Contrail. Here you gain a lot of interior space. It's taller and wider and longer. It's going to be much larger inside. It's also easier to set up and will offer more protection from wind due to the near-ground level walls on all sides. Living in Washington where horrible bugs are the norm, this shelter gives a much more comfortable refuge as well.

The tarp/serinity combo is very versatile. No bugs? Leave the Serinity at home. Colder, nastier conditions? Bring a breathable bivy to put under the tarp and you're set. Set it high, set it low- the tarp gives lots of options. Light too. But it takes more stakes and more time to get it right.

Both are good options for sure.

Other choices?

How about the MLD Patrol/Serinity combo? Lighter and with more front and rear coverage.

Or go with the Tarptent Moment. 4 oz more and it's ready for more serious weather.

Lots of cool choices here. I gather from your post that you probably have not used a tarp before. If that is the case, you would have a blast with this combo. Tarps are really fun. But from a practical stance, the Tarptent might be a better call.

Last point: the Tarptent is less redundant. Single wall- no double layers around your body. Clean.

PostedSep 5, 2009 at 7:49 pm

Welcome Adam. The decision IMO that you have to make is really a personal one and not so much about $ or weight. That decision is whether or not you are comfortable sleeping under a tarp or would you prefer the feeling of enclosure that a tent would provide. If you are new to backpacking in general (and not just UL) you might be better off starting with a tent. You mentioned the Contrail but you could also consider GG's The One at about 18 oz. That would give you the weight comparable to a tarp with the full enclosure of a tent. I would also consider the SMD Lunar Solo. A bit heavier but with 27 sq. feet of sleeping area it might be worth it. Whatever you start with I can guarantee you it won't be what you end up with. If you get hooked like most of us here you will find that even though you own the equipment you are really just renting it.

Adam Frizzell BPL Member
PostedSep 5, 2009 at 8:35 pm

Hi Doug–
Thanks for the thorough reply! Happy to be here.
Yes, never used a tarp as shelter before. Always been double wall tents since I was a squirt. I definitely believe going to a tarp would be fun. And versatile. Like you said, one could ditch the bug layer or add a bivy for nastier weather, et al. I keep coming back to the variety of pitching options. And now you've got the MLD Patrol on my mind too. You also bring up some good counter points. A single wall tarptent (Contrail or other) is less redundant and clean. To go to a tarp with bug protection/bivy, one could argue that I didn't really get away from a convoluted (IMO) double wall set up.

Hi Jack–
Thanks for your reply and the welcome.
I think you're spot on when you say it's going to come down to a personal choice. I've been camping/backpacking my whole life, but haven't given much thought to the weight I've carried and the added value that getting my gear lean until just recently. I believe that I would love the idea of sheltering under a tarp as I typically feel shut out from the place I came to visit when in a tent. I've only skimmed over the GG The One thus far but will have to give it a hard look. You also mentioned the SMD Lunar Solo… this was actually the shelter that caught my eye first, but after a lot of research and thread searching here at BPL and elsewhere, I've found that it could be a tight squeeze for those over 6' (I'm 6'1" and use a 6'6" bag) and has a fairly large footprint. I understand the Vamp is coming sometime soon, so once that's out it will probably throw any decision I may have made out the window!
And, you make an excellent point:

"Whatever you start with I can guarantee you it won't be what you end up with. If you get hooked like most of us here you will find that even though you own the equipment you are really just renting it."

I can completely agree. I've rolled all my current gear over maybe 6 times in the past few years. It's good perspective to have though: Whatever decisions are made are not the be all and end all.

Jay Wilkerson BPL Member
PostedSep 5, 2009 at 8:37 pm

Going UL is some what of a addiction for me..I have tried out so many shelters over the years…I am a big fan of tarps but over the past 2 seasons I have slowly but surely gone to Tarptents..Easy set up, great bug and weather protection, less stakes and all for the same amount of weight that you have for a tarp and bug shelter…Tarps have a large footprint and Tarptents have smaller footprint which gives you more camp site options….But to each is there own and you have to fine that out for yourself…Comfort to me has become more important then being Spartan and saving 3 to 5 oz…..Goodluck and welcome to very cool website…..

PostedSep 5, 2009 at 8:44 pm

I had to make a few similar decisions a few month ago.

As the previous poster noted, I didn't go with my original plan. I ended up with a gatewood cape that neutralized the current weight of my rain gear and kicked out my 2lb tent. I added a BMW bivy and felt great sleeping with bears, mosquitoes, and below freezing temperatures.

A very similar setup worked wonders against two fantastic and violent thunderstorms in the Texas panhandle. I believe I was misted twice.

Both experiences mocked my double wall two pounder so well that I've never looked back at traditional full shelter. The duh moment for me was when I started thinking in terms of efficiency.

Gatewood Cape – (pack cover+rain jacket) – shelterweight + bivy/bugnet versatility == I should've paid more than 130.

As a matter of the tarp versus tent and the weight, you'll kick yourself in the teeth later in your UL career when you realize you could have kicked a half pound for fifty bucks and wind up selling your tent to me for 75 less than you paid.

Jack

PostedSep 5, 2009 at 9:05 pm

It doesn't have to be an either/or proposition. Maybe initially due to finances (maybe not, there's always some great gear people sell on here for good prices), but not long term. I'm just getting into tarping, but I won't be giving up all my Tarptents, not by a long shot. I'm even buying a hammock to try that out.

I envision that I'll use all three depending on the trip. A longer trip will probably see me using the tarp. A shorter trip in warmer weather will probably see me in the hammock. A shorter trip in the cold weather will probably see me in the Tarptent.

They're all fairly light, comparatively. They all have their uses. Even the UL backpacking world isn't black and white. Don't cram yourself into just one stuff sack. :-)

And above all, enjoy!

Take care,

Doug

Stephen Barber BPL Member
PostedSep 5, 2009 at 9:16 pm

At this point, I've done a lot of tarp camping, mostly while canoeing the upper Midwest. I've paid my dues in blood taken by mosquitoes, sudden thunderstorms ripping nylon tarps, and nocturnal visitors.

I got a TT Contrail this summer, and am in love. Simple, easy to set up, enough versatility in set-up to deal with different weather conditions, super light, nice and airy, doesn't feel closed in.

Go ahead and get a tarp set-up if you haven't used on before – they can be a lot of fun. But eventually, when you get tired of fussing with it and trying to find just the right tree branch in the right position, you can pick up a good single wall tent (like the Contrail) and find bliss!

PostedSep 5, 2009 at 9:44 pm

I use the Duo when with my wife and at about the same height as you I have plenty of space. The LS is 2" shorter but at 88" I would think it would be fine. I have on occasion used the side tie-outs which are a nice feature. I did read a thread where someone also suggested to use your extra pole on the head-side tie-out to bring it up 6" or so and improve headroom.

+1 for what Doug said. Great points.

Adam Frizzell BPL Member
PostedSep 5, 2009 at 9:48 pm

Thanks to all for the added replies.
Based on the responses, I can definitely see that it's not a black and white decision. Over time, I'm sure it will not be a question of "Do I pick up a tarp or a tarptent?" but "Which one of my 15 shelters should I take this time?" :-)

I'm finding my natural course, just recently getting into the lighter side of backpacking, is that I want to go as spartan as possible. Surely not the answer, but I don't think it is "wrong" of me either.

So many options! A result of crazy smart and forward thinking manufacturers.

Drop all my rain gear and tent and get a Gatewood Cape? Damn appealing too.

Again, thanks for posting your opinions and suggestions! It's very helpful that you're willing to share your perspective.

Doug– I noticed you're in the Mid-Atlantic area too. I'd like to pick your brain sometime about some of the area trails you might frequent. I'm in Maryland, so anywhere from PA to WVA is an easy jaunt. I typically try to go out for as many "weekend warrior" (overnighters, 15-30 miles) trips as possible, with longer trips thrown in when I can work it out.

Adam

Adam Frizzell BPL Member
PostedSep 5, 2009 at 9:57 pm

Jack–

Thanks for the follow up about the Lunar Solo. I too saw the thread about being able to bring up your head side using your second pole.
Actually, now that I look at it again, the MLD Serenity Shelter (my idea for bug protection under a tarp) is only 82" long. It's a full silnylon foot end too, so if my bag is pushed against it, it could pull moisture in…
Hmm. I'm not going to discount the Lunar Solo. I do love the idea of a side entry shelter.
Thanks for the extra info.

Adam

PostedSep 5, 2009 at 10:31 pm

Adam, no problem. Glad to help. I am not sure if the same would be true of the LS but my Duo in the original stuff sack with the UL floor option (seam sealed and no mods.) is 35 oz., 4 oz. less than the listed weight. Just a guess but the LS might be less than the 23 oz. listed.

PostedSep 5, 2009 at 11:39 pm

If I am going on a trip where I will be hiking most of the day then I take a tarp setup. I am pretty much only sleeping in the shelter so I don't want to carry the weight. There are times, although rare, when I know there will be a lot of down time lounging around. If I know the bugs will be out, I take an older solo tent with me. Eventually I will get a tarptent for this type of trip to get the weight down. I haven't bought one yet but the new Moment from tarptent sure is tempting.

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
Loading...