Topic

from boots to trail runners: will I get stuff in my shoes?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
Kevin Monagle BPL Member
PostedMay 1, 2015 at 1:47 pm

I have a pair of Inov-8 roclite 390s that I've loved.

I recently picked up some Hoka Challengers, trail running shoes and was thinking of taking them on my next outing but I have this nagging concern about having to dump out debris on a regular basis.

Anybody run into that issue when making the switch?

PostedMay 1, 2015 at 1:55 pm

That's what gaiters are for. They won't keep fine dirt particles from seeping in, but they'll keep the majority of the debris out.

Kevin Monagle BPL Member
PostedMay 1, 2015 at 2:09 pm

ah and that's a follow up…do most end up wearing gaiters with trail runners?

tom lakner BPL Member
PostedMay 1, 2015 at 2:12 pm

Yup, I've been using Dirty Girls for a while.Keeps the pebbles out

Lori P BPL Member
PostedMay 1, 2015 at 2:18 pm

Actually, I have found that they do keep quite a bit of dirt out. If the gaiters cover the laces it seems to make a big difference . I have Dirty Girls and the similar OR gaiters.

PostedMay 1, 2015 at 3:16 pm

I've just never had this problem, lucky I guess. Trail runners, no gaiters, only a rarely have to shake anything out.

George F BPL Member
PostedMay 1, 2015 at 3:34 pm

+1 on the dirty girls. What I like best is they keep those nasty bits of grass and what not from getting in my socks.

Todd T BPL Member
PostedMay 1, 2015 at 4:03 pm

+1 Dirty Girls. My shoes, socks, and feet last a lot longer than they used to before I discovered DGs. If your shoes are waterproof (mine are), very little dirt/dust makes it inside. I've got boots/shoes with several hiking seasons on them and the inners look just like they did brand new.

My theory on why some people don't see the need for scree gaiters is that they have fat (as in large, not blubbery) ankles. Mine are about as big around as mop handles, so without gaiters the tops of my shoes collect crud like funnels.

James Marco BPL Member
PostedMay 1, 2015 at 4:06 pm

While I use Chocorua mostly (Timberland mid hiking boot,) I also use Salomon. The Salomon were terrible with picking up dirt, sticks, pine needles and stones. Definitely use whatever gaiters. The weight is better but leave my ankles open to rocks/sticks.

With the scree collar on the Chocorua I don't need them. It really paws to keep my feet clean. About 7-8oz heavier, though. They protect my ankles from scrapes, pinches and bangs climbing through boulder fields, scree falls or over blowdowns much better, too.

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedMay 1, 2015 at 4:24 pm

Yes.
Gaiters!
Ankle-length for scrub, but shorties (like DGs) for trails.
MYOG is easy too.

Cheers

PostedMay 1, 2015 at 4:40 pm

Okay… It sounds like the question is answered. Gaiters fit for your terrain will keep stuff out of your trail runners.

Of course, some people will also tell you that you need the same gaiters for your old hiking boots so you may want to pay attention to whether you experience these same issues on the trail.

Now that we're all talking boots and trail runners… Which trail runners last the longest in mixed conditions including pavement? Why is it that none of the trail runners that can handle hard packed trail/loose gravel seem to handle mud well?

PostedMay 1, 2015 at 6:22 pm

"Why is it that none of the trail runners that can handle hard packed trail/loose gravel seem to handle mud well?"

I feel like my Altra Lone Peaks handle mud very well. Just slid down a mountain in constant rain last weekend and they worked well. I know some models will handle these things better than others, but I think it mostly comes down to the individual user and their skill/experience.

As far as gaiters go… just wear pants. :)

HkNewman BPL Member
PostedMay 1, 2015 at 7:36 pm

When I skip wearing them, I usually end up regretting it.

David Thomas BPL Member
PostedMay 1, 2015 at 10:49 pm

I fiddled around with running shoes in the 1970's and preferred them to the over-the-ankle full-leather hiking boots of the day, but once Nike came out with the Lava Dome (the first low-cut, purpose-built trail shoe), I've only used low-cut hiking shoes (unless the snow is over 6" deep).

Sand and gravel and dust don't fall from the sky. YOU cause air-borne dirt. When I was on staff at a Scout camp, all the campers remind me of Pigpen in Peanuts:

pigpen

there was always a cloud of dust around them because they dragged their feet as they walked the dusty trails. If I walked close to other people, my lower legs would be brown from the dust and a black pattern would infiltrate through my socks around my ankles. When I hiked by myself, that didn't happen. I don't drag my feet.

I have had a few pairs of shoes on which the back of the sole projected out past the heel like this (or even more so):

projecting heel

and those would flick sand and dust up into air and sometimes into my shoes. I'd relegate those styles to use on pavement.

Shoes where the rear of the sole is undercut like this:

Nike lava dome

don't flick dirt onto my lower legs nor into my shoes. It is one of the things Nike got right in the Lava Dome (pictured above). Another was the stiffness of the sole. The upper was somewhat over-stiff and newer trail runners have lighter, even more comfortable uppers.

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedMay 1, 2015 at 11:29 pm

> Why is it that none of the trail runners that can handle hard packed trail/loose
> gravel seem to handle mud well?
They tune the rubber composition and the tread design to suit the intended application. For instance, rock-climbing shoes have a smooth sole, but they grip like mad.

Cheers

Justin Baker BPL Member
PostedMay 1, 2015 at 11:51 pm

Depends on the trail. Sometimes you get hard packed trails with nothing to get in your shoes, sometimes the trails have lots of gravel and dust and you are constantly getting things in your shoes.
Hiking off trail in alpine areas with lots of granite and tundra, usually don't get stuff in your shoes.
Hiking off trail in forested areas with lots of duff and leaves on soft ground, tons of stuff will get in your shoes.

It's not really a problem, more of annoyance that can slow you down a little at times.

Around here in the summer we have dense grasslands (oak savaanah) and the grasses have little needle like seeds that will get into your shoes and terrorize you. The like to embed in the lining of shoes. If you head off trail at all you need to make sure that your shoes don't have open mesh that the seeds can poke through and that you have good fitting gaiters, or else you will be in a miserable situation. I've actually carried a pair of backup gaiters on a couple trips like this, no idea why it would happen but losing a pair of gaiters would be a disaster. It's hard for me to explain how serious of an issue these seeds can be.

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
Loading...