I fiddled around with running shoes in the 1970's and preferred them to the over-the-ankle full-leather hiking boots of the day, but once Nike came out with the Lava Dome (the first low-cut, purpose-built trail shoe), I've only used low-cut hiking shoes (unless the snow is over 6" deep).
Sand and gravel and dust don't fall from the sky. YOU cause air-borne dirt. When I was on staff at a Scout camp, all the campers remind me of Pigpen in Peanuts:

there was always a cloud of dust around them because they dragged their feet as they walked the dusty trails. If I walked close to other people, my lower legs would be brown from the dust and a black pattern would infiltrate through my socks around my ankles. When I hiked by myself, that didn't happen. I don't drag my feet.
I have had a few pairs of shoes on which the back of the sole projected out past the heel like this (or even more so):

and those would flick sand and dust up into air and sometimes into my shoes. I'd relegate those styles to use on pavement.
Shoes where the rear of the sole is undercut like this:

don't flick dirt onto my lower legs nor into my shoes. It is one of the things Nike got right in the Lava Dome (pictured above). Another was the stiffness of the sole. The upper was somewhat over-stiff and newer trail runners have lighter, even more comfortable uppers.