Topic

Alcohol stove, stainless steel cookware, offensive odour – just me?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
Brad Clarke BPL Member
PostedMar 1, 2015 at 6:20 pm

I tried searching the forums to find an existing topic, but nothing was coming up.

Over the last two weekends I decided to get my alcohol stoves out (a Trangia burner and a Tatonka Trangia-style burner) to verify what I thought I had experienced last year when I had previously used them.

Both burners were used in a Critter CR2 stand and filled with a product called Bio-Flame.
It's 95% ethanol and 5% 2-Propanol. It's designed for indoor use with ventless fireplaces.

When burning without a pot over them, there is no odour at all.
As soon as I place a stainless steel pot or kettle over the flames, it gives off a horrendous smell that just makes the whole experience unpleasant.

The same pots and kettles used with canister stoves do not give off the odour.

I used a Fire Maple FMX-XK6 HE pot with the Trangia, and other than getting soot all over the bottom of the pot, there were no issues or odour.

The odd thing is that the Tatonka burner is made out of stainless steel, but it does not give off an odour when there is not a pot over the flame.

Is there something specific to stainless steel cookware and alcohol stoves that results in this offensive odour? Perhaps it's specific to the fuel I am using.

USA Duane Hall BPL Member
PostedMar 1, 2015 at 8:13 pm

Maybe that stuff isn't designed for what you are trying to make it do.
Duane

PostedMar 1, 2015 at 9:23 pm

No idea but have you tried holding the SS pot over the flame without using the stand ?

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedMar 2, 2015 at 1:02 am

I am guessing about this case, but we have had some experience with burning propanol.

First of all, when they (Bio-Flame) claim 95% ethanol and 5% propanol, I simply do not believe them. There WILL be other organics in there, albeit at a low level. What they are and how they burn … who knows?

Second, we KNOW that the combustion products of propanol can be nasty. To be sure, really complete combustion of propanol gives just CO2 and H2O, but that is the ideal case. Normally, you also get enough toxic by-products that you get a headache.

We also know that when any flame hits something 'cold', and 100 C (boiling point) is cold in this context, the flame is quenched and you get incomplete combustion. You will then get the odd often toxic by-products.

So I suggest that while Bio-Flame may be fine in a ventles fireplace where the flame does not hit anything, it is not so good when the flame does hit something. Try a different fuel.

Cheers

James Marco BPL Member
PostedMar 2, 2015 at 2:51 am

2-Propanol is ISO-propanol. As Roger said, it can and does produce all sorts of toxic byproducts when quenched. Switch to methanol (yellow HEET), SLX, or 190 proof EverClear for camping.

Soot on the HE fins can degrade them.

Brad Clarke BPL Member
PostedMar 2, 2015 at 6:49 am

Thanks for the feedback everyone, greatly appreciated.

The only other fuel I have on hand is Methyl Hydrate, which I have since learned is nasty, so I will not use that.
I also have some fondue fuel, but it indicates it's made with methyl alcohol, so also a no go.

Roger mentioned headaches; I had one yesterday afternoon, but had attributed it to hitting my head quite hard on a tree limb while out Geocaching Saturday afternoon.

I'd have to head south of the border to track down HEET, SLX, and EverClear.

The only other product I can easily obtain locally is Captain Phab marine stove fuel.
It's a 90/10 ethanol mix designed for pressurized and non-pressurized marine stoves.

Since I won't be heading to Ogdensburg anytime soon, I think I'll grab a bottle of that and give it a try.

PostedMar 2, 2015 at 7:41 am

MEC sells 99.9% pure methyl hydrate.

“Recochem 1L Methyl Hydrate Stove Fuel
Methyl hydrate for use with any model of alcohol stove.”

That’s what I used in my Super Cat Alcohol Stove for 6 trips last year. Worked fine for me. Good clean flame. No smell. No soot.

Brad Clarke BPL Member
PostedMar 2, 2015 at 10:30 am

I got the impression from one of the BPL articles on alcohol stove fuels that methyl hydrate was not a good fuel to use, at least from a toxicity perspective.

PostedMar 2, 2015 at 11:58 am

It does seem that methyl hydrate is more toxic. If you decide on denatured alcohol, I see folks here saying they found it at Shoppers Drug Mart and also Lee Valley. But I guess it depends on what they add to it. Dunno.

The various alcohols are also discussed here.

I’ll likely continue to use the Methyl Hydrate from MEC, and be careful with it.

James Marco BPL Member
PostedMar 2, 2015 at 12:22 pm

????HEET is methanol. It makes an excellent outdoors fuel. It burns faster than ethanol and a bit hotter.
Methyl hydrate is another name for methanol. Also called methyl alcohol, wood alcohol, wood spirits, etc.
SLX is about 50/50 methanol/ethanol. It is also recommended for marine stoves. I would guess your Captain Phab is 90/10 ethanol/methanol though I would also guess there is a bit of water in there too.

Hitting your head can cause a minor concussion, often with a headache up to few days after. Usually not serious.

Just stay away from Isopropinol.

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedMar 2, 2015 at 1:34 pm

Just so no-one gets confused:

Methyl Hydrate IS methanol. Exactly the same same chemical.

It is toxic if ingested, but it burns much cleaner than any form of propanol.

Cheers

PostedMar 2, 2015 at 1:52 pm

Pure ethanol burns hotter than pure methanol.
However if for example you use Everclear, there is water in it and that is why it burns "slower".
(Everclear 151 is 75% Ethanol the rest is water, the 190 version is 95% pure ethanol)
That Marine fuel mentioned above , the 90/10 mix, will burn hotter than Yellow Heat.
It is designed to work with alcohol stoves, the "marine" versions are just bigger stoves than the type we use .

PostedMar 2, 2015 at 3:56 pm

Ken T found the thread when I tried doing this, same type of 'fuel', different brand.

I talked via email to the enrg people and they noted the fuel burns clean IF you let it burn as it would in a fireplace, ie, not hitting the bottom of the pot, as Roger C noted.

Basically this stuff is SUPPOSED to burn with a yellow flame, so it looks like a fire in your fireplace, so the combustion needs to be complete, ie, the flame goes up without hitting anything, to burn off all the noxious compounds in there.

This is not stove fuel, pure and simple.

I was also on the quest for ethanol heavy fuels, but I now am cured, and am very pleased with the kleanstrip slx types, the non 'green' ones, which are roughly 50/50% ethanol/methanol, which is I think an ideal mix, methanol burns better at altitude, ethanol has a bit more energy content, it's easy to light, doesn't soot the pots (which ethanol in my tests did, sometimes badly).

In terms of sooting, these fireplace flame generators, which is what they are, not fuel, were in a league of their own, you could literally flake off the soot after a few tests.

Just go get some slx type, kleanstrip has changed the name, but it's the stuff that at my local Ace hardware costs $10 or so a gallon, and your stove issues are over.

Don't burn it inside unless you have a large fan to blow the exhaust out a window, but that goes for anything really, but methanol should be treated as poison in its liquid and burned exhaust states.

Brad Clarke BPL Member
PostedMar 7, 2015 at 8:25 pm

Yes, it definitely was bad fuel.

I picked up some Captain Phab 90/10 marine fuel and tested that out last night.

Much better flame; nice blue flame at the base of the jets, with some yellow flame higher up using the Trangia burner (which seems to be the norm with newer Trangia burners).
Very little odour, certainly nothing offensive.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
Loading...