Topic

Skurka and Sierra Designs team up for gear

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 201 through 225 (of 285 total)
Bob Moulder BPL Member
PostedFeb 25, 2015 at 5:20 pm

"Jim Woods' 'SUPERCAT'(TM)"

I've read this stuff before about the birth of the Supercat(TM), and I don't fret too much over it.

I did some tests in my laboratory (my deck) and the Supercat(TM) — constructed precisely according to Clelland/Skurka instructions (from Fancy Feast can) — and found it to be roughly 30% less fuel efficient than 12-10 and Starlyte stoves.

Nice to know it'd make do in a pinch if somebody stole my Starlyte, but based upon my testing I wouldn't knowingly pick this as my primary stove. My dog, however, did like the food, but that isn't saying much since he feasts on deer poop the way I did Milk Duds as a youth.

If the Supercat(TM) was un'can'nilly efficient and I was the person who came up with the idea, I suppose I'd be a little prickly about it.

John S. BPL Member
PostedFeb 25, 2015 at 5:36 pm

The Cat Stove (Roy Robinson, 2001) was around several years before the Super Cat stove (Jim Woods, 2005).

PostedFeb 25, 2015 at 5:51 pm

Yes it was,

but Jim Woods stove is a different (and better) design.

Jim Woods did not sinply use Robinson's stove design and them call it something else.

Only a bonafide gear expert would do something like that.;)

Randy Nelson BPL Member
PostedFeb 25, 2015 at 5:59 pm

"No I am not Jim Woods..but if I WAS, I'd sure as heck have more of a right to be a smartass on this thread than you do. That's a fact;)"

Ha! Hardly. I've been a smart ass in these forums for years. If Jim Wood came on and started being a smart ass, he'd have to apologize to me! :)

"Are you Andrew Skurka? you seem to really be upest by my posts."

I might as well be. We're practically identical twins. The only way people can tell us apart is he says "Fancy Feast" and I say "cat can". Well, that and I'm short, old, and fat. But other than that? Identical in every way. Although he has all his hair. And I couldn't run Leadville if I started at Quincy's. Otherwise, identical!

Randy Nelson BPL Member
PostedFeb 25, 2015 at 6:06 pm

"Jim Woods did not sinply use Robinson's stove design and them call it something else.

Only a bonafide gear expert would do something like that.;)"

His name is Jim Wood. You've got his name wrong in every post. It's just a name but I'd think you, of all people, would know what his name was and know how important it is to use the right name.

PostedFeb 25, 2015 at 6:26 pm

Mr Neilson,

Thanks for pointing out that mistake,I go from Wood to Woods in spelling his name.

At least I did not INVENT a totally new name for Mr Wood or pretend he never existed like some here prefer to do.

John S. BPL Member
PostedFeb 25, 2015 at 6:38 pm

I think we got us a genuwine Jim Wood fanboy.

lol Greg.

Randy Nelson BPL Member
PostedFeb 25, 2015 at 6:54 pm

Have you consider that some people, myself included, just didn't know the original name? As I mentioned earlier, I just thought it was called a cat can stove because that's how I first heard of it. I didn't go out and research it to find out who designed it or what it was really named. I punched some holes in a cat food can and didn't think about it again. Until today. I didn't know who Jim Wood or Roy Robinson was or that Robinson designed the first cat can stove that is very different from the Super Cat until today. I first heard of it as a cat can stove and that's what sticks. And probably still will even now that I know the real name. I still call a reciprocating saw by any manufacturer a Sawzall. Not consciously, that's just what comes to mind.

I have a really good friend who I first met in a work setting that introduced himself by his American sounding middle name. It was probably 2 years later when I learned what his actual first name was which is what his family and friends outside of work called him. I've made a concerted and conscious effort to call him by his real first name. I've know him for 30+ years now and I still sometimes fail to do so.

I doubt Skurka has any nefarious reason for calling it the Fancy Feast stove. Why would he? What would be his motivation to do so? He's not claiming it as his design and never has. It's more likely just a habit because that's how it was introduced to him and it stuck.

Why don't you email him and ask him why he calls it a Fancy Feast stove instead of a Super Cat? I doubt he means any slight to Jim Wood, if he even knows who he is. Maybe he'll even start calling it a Super Cat once he knows.

PostedFeb 25, 2015 at 7:22 pm

"The Supercat stove does not."

Wait! We're talking about stoves? Really? Darn, all this time I thought we were talking about our very own Kat, who knits hats, and while I could understand calling her super ('cause she is), I couldn't figure out why y'all kept misspelling her name!

It all makes sense now…..

bjc BPL Member
PostedFeb 25, 2015 at 8:11 pm

All this because a man signed on with a company that's in the midst of reinventing itself, so that he might help design some new equipment and make a living at the same time!

Ed Biermann BPL Member
PostedFeb 25, 2015 at 8:15 pm

What a train wreck of a thread. I can't look away. All that's missing is some international intrigue.

PostedFeb 25, 2015 at 10:05 pm

This thread isn't a total waste. I learned that the Cub Scouts can walk a route that surrounds three states, traverse 11 states, walk across a country, walk across a continent, walk all four seasons on a single trip while doing daily exertion and milage so far beyond normal it's national geographic worthy, and then they become Boy Scouts.

Presumably that's where they strap a boatload of crap to a pack and go scout other boys, because their trips don't come close to the stuff the Cub Scouts do.

I learned all of that in just one thread on BPL ! I used to be impressed by Andrew. Now I know most people here do those trips without planning ! I'm a total noob, and can't wait to learn more !

PostedFeb 25, 2015 at 11:18 pm

Only on BPL would we be treated to multiple pages of argument over what to call a homemade alcohol stove!

Unbelievable!

PostedFeb 26, 2015 at 3:48 am

Pretty sure I can't make this thread any worse, so…

The first name *I* knew from Scouts for a cat food can stove is "Buddy Burner" aka "Vagabond Stove".

That's Girl Scouts by the way. Pretty sure they predate Mr. Skurka's appearance on the planet.

(Yeah yeah, not the same thing…a Buddy Burner uses rolled corrugated cardboard with wax in a cat food can…but at this point in the discussion, who really cares?)

PostedFeb 26, 2015 at 4:57 am

"Pretty sure I can't make this thread any worse, so…

The first name *I* knew from Scouts for a cat food can stove is "Buddy Burner" aka "Vagabond Stove".

That's Girl Scouts by the way. Pretty sure they predate Mr. Skurka's appearance on the planet.

(Yeah yeah, not the same thing…a Buddy Burner uses rolled corrugated cardboard with wax in a cat food can…but at this point in the discussion, who really cares?)"

We called those hobo stoves.

If I make a stove from a vienna sausage can, can I call it something different? Like SuperSausage stove?

Sunny Waller BPL Member
PostedFeb 26, 2015 at 7:21 am

This post reminds me of something I saw on another site. There is a company that sells "buildings in a box". You order it and assemble it yourself. Somebody asked on the site if anybody had used this company. A rancher replied that he had just built one of these and it worked great. He already had a bunkhouse and an outhouse and built this for his grandaughters to stay in. He posted several pictures and mentioned the inside was not finished yet. In one of the pictures you see a toilet in the back corner in an unenclosed space. OMG. All the internet TROLLS came out and debated all the merits of that toilet in the corner..some criticizing the fact that it was not in an enclosed space but MANY criticizing the fact that there was a toilet in there in the first place. There were many comments about his grandaughters being to good to use the outhouse. After a few days of "toilet rage" this was posted by the rancher: "I SAID THE INSIDE WAS NOT FINISHED YET…I INSTALLED A BATHROOM IN THERE BECAUSE THE GIRLS DON'T LIKE STEPPING ON RATTLESNAKES WHEN THEY GO TO THE OUTHOUSE IN THE DARK."

PostedFeb 26, 2015 at 7:39 am

After reading all 11 pages I have nothing to add other than Mods should just remove this entire thread from existence

Dave G BPL Member
PostedFeb 26, 2015 at 7:49 am

"And remember, if your nose bleeds, it's because you're picking it too much……or not enough" – Officer Barbrady

PostedFeb 26, 2015 at 7:55 am

There just aren't any good threads right now, and people are starved for action. We're on page 12 with Skurka and cat can stoves for crying out loud!

I wish someone would start a thread that contains the controversial ingredients needed to get readers engaged (guns, sex, religion, animal attacks, etc). Then I could throw gasoline on it and set it ablaze.

It's funny how people complain about trolling threads, yet they keep replying to them – Officer Longstick.

Viewing 25 posts - 201 through 225 (of 285 total)
Loading...