“The running joke among some of my friends familiar with this site was that someone like Buck Nelson could post a trip report about traversing an entire desert and get 3 responses while the “What underwear should I use on the JMT?” thread gets 42 pages of discussion. What is it about us (me) that does this?”
“I’ve posted a ton of trip reports here. None of them have been met with the amount of discussion on this thread.”
I’ve often lamented the same thing. But the more I think about it, the more it makes sense (for this site) that trip reports would get less response than more gear-centric topics. After all, this is, at its core, a gear-centric site. Lots of engineer types and such, who seem more apt to be anal on gear-centric topics than any philosophical underpinnings of backpacking.
Additionally, the gear-centric topics engender discussion (everybody has an opinion and many like to share it, even if it repeats already posted opinions, it seems that at least some, and possibly many, threads that get lots of responses are loaded with responses that mimic others). Trip reports aren’t really asking any questions, so other than a ‘great trip!’ type of reply there isn’t much more to say, unless, of course, people start asking gear-centric questions about the trip or are looking for some specific information in case they decide to do such a trip themselves.
But there has always been a small core of folks here who were more interested in anything other than gear-centric stuff (myself included), so we inhabited chaff and had a jolly old time discussing philosophy, art, politics, music, etc. Anything other than gear. Since I have a very, very small social circle, and none of my good friends live anywhere near me, chaff was a fun (usually) way to interact with people on a variety of topics. I certainly miss it (though, unfortunately, I was one of the loudmouths calling for its demise. It’s complicated). We’d get lengthy threads there (including the longest thread ever on BPL), and at times there were more posts in chaff than there were in the main forums. We’d laugh about that as well.
Okay, enough of my prattling on. To the OPs original question, I haven’t really re-purposed anything for backpacking that I can think of. But like others have stated, I do find homes for gear I no longer want or need. I’ve given lots of gear away, and sold other gear for pretty low prices, so at least it didn’t end up in a landfill.