Can’t speak to NYC from California. Over the decades I took WFR from a couple of different sources, then stuck with NOLS for ~20 years.
Why I like NOLS:
Excellent and consistent instructors
They are outdoors-active WEMTs or paramedics, have been teaching for a while, and you don’t get different recommendations from different teachers. Very “hands-on” – if you screw up a splint, they’ll let you know, then you try again until you get it right.
Evidence-based practices, frequently updated
Every time I recertify, some important guidelines change based on recent journal articles or field experience from thousands of NOLS students. And they cite their sources, in the course materials or in their excellent blog.
Good instructional materials
Long, long ago, in a galaxy far away, I routinely carried the heavy Medicine for Mountaineering in my 50-pound pack. Uggh. Now I carry a light NOLS Wilderness Medicine Pocket Guide plus a couple of home-made cheat sheets. The full instructional manual is also clear, to the point, and regularly updated. However, both are full of NOLS jargon, so much less useful if you haven’t taken their courses. “Not intended to substitute for hands-on first aid training.”
Good follow-up emails.
Periodic case studies: Here’s what happened, what would you do? Click on the link for the actual resolution, and a post-event analysis. Helps keep your knowledge fresh between recerts. Plus reminders to recertify.
Lots of opportunities to recertify.
I used to think that I didn’t need to recert, I knew this stuff. Wrong. Besides updated practices, refreshing both head and hands knowledge is also critical to keeping calm and doing the right thing when the brown stuff hits the fan.
Alumni discounts
I’ve rarely used these, and some are strange (Brooks Brothers?), but many are potentially quite useful. Currently includes Enlightened Equipment, GAIA GPS, Yama Mountain Gear, and 24 others.
Sorry this went long. Hope it helps.
— Rex