Great comprehensive review Ryan. I have a pair of Showa 281 fishermen gloves that fit over a pair of polar tech liner gloves if needed. They have great dexterity, grip, and, with the liners especially feel warm enough for extended rain and cool/cold shoulder season weather. They appear very water proof and feel pretty breathable with their textured microporous polyurethane shell, branded as Temres. Problem is, even though I have had them for 2 years, I have not had a chance to use them in a proper rainstorm here in the dry west. Would love feedback from the author and/or the BP Light community on their experiences.