Topic

Twelve Days in The Frank

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
Eli BPL Member
PostedAug 27, 2021 at 12:36 pm


Country United States
State Idaho
Area The Frank Church River of No Return Wilderness
Trip Month (08) – August

Report / Notes
Grapenut and I wanted a large remote area as a setting for a twelve day trip, and we decided that the cheapest way to get to Alaska was in fact to go to Idaho instead. The Frank Church River of No Return Wilderness is the largest contiguous designated wilderness area in the lower 48 and so seemed to be a good destination to explore.

Having hiked in numerous Western mountain ranges over the years we did shallow research on The Frank before going, assuming it would be simple to feel out a route on the fly. We marked a few highlights from Margaret Fuller’s guidebook in Caltopo and figured it’d be easy enough to hike between them. Wrong. There are a few things we learned the hard way about the area:

Nobody hikes here. Apart from one sheep hunter scouting near a road we saw no hikers in the backcountry at all. In fact we saw almost no human tracks on any trail off the Middle Fork, which we only hiked on briefly. Some maintenance had been done here and there, but generally you don’t walk with a normal gait in The Frank, you step over logs, through brush, between rocks, and onto game trails.
The primary terrain features are valleys with creeks, dense with brush, and steep ridges, thousands of feet tall, between them. Downed trees throughout. We considered ourselves “big mile” hikers but had to toss mile measures by the wayside and usually felt exhausted with even one log-ridden ridge up-and-over in a day. There are some nice ridge walks up high
Fortunately the heat broke by the very end of the trip, but it was easily 90 degrees in the sun most of the time. The creeks often had running water but the dry gravely soil and intense solar radiation gave the area the feel of a desert.
There’s constant small aircraft traffic and many rafters on the Middle Fork and Salmon. An odd presence of civilization in a backcountry area otherwise seemingly devoid of human travel. Plenty of water bucket-toting helicopters. Lucky for us the fires in wilderness were diminishing and ultimately not much of an issue during our trip.
I’ve hiked in Idaho on the CDT and in the Sawtooths, but this was different from other hiking I’ve done in the Rockies in terms of the character of the terrain and the wildness.

The trip was really made by Daniel Mathews’ Rocky Mountain Natural History, a luxury item absolutely worth carrying unless you’re already well-versed in Rockies ecology. It adds whole new perceived dimensions to the experience of being in the backcountry.

Leaving out route details, go check out The Frank.

Rex Sanders BPL Member
PostedAug 28, 2021 at 8:47 pm

Looks like you had a great trip – but slow, and strenuous! Hope you had a chance to soak in the many local hot springs during or after to help with the aches and pains.

I rafted the Middle Fork and Main Salmon a handful of times many years ago. Very hard to get private permits. Beautiful country. Saw the occasional horse packer near the river. Kept looking up and wondering what backpacking through the Frank might be like. Now I know.

Thanks for the trip report.

— Rex

PostedAug 30, 2021 at 1:15 pm

Cool TR and video, thanks for posting. Great music choice for the video as well, was a nice surprise (I’m a Will Oldham/Bonnie “Prince” Billy fan as well).  That’s awesome you guys were out for 12 days and I think it’s really cool that you took a vague approach to sharing route details.

You’re definitely correct about the trail conditions in the Frank Church-River of No Return Wilderness by and large being pretty primitive. It’s the same way for much of the Selway-Bitterroot Wilderness which is my local backpacking area (although I do get down to the Frank once a year or so usually). Once you  leave the mainline trails or those heavily used by outfitters, the dotted lines on the map basically turn into mere suggestions and I’ve found many of them can vary from faint, to faint and intermittent, to totally nonexistent. The USFS often doesn’t have much useful information on trail conditions, but I’ve noticed it has improved somewhat the last year or two in that regard.

These wilderness areas are definitely NOT the place to go for people wanting to “crank out big miles” which seems to be the default ultralight goal. Those that do usually end up leaving frustrated, so I’m glad you guys had a good trip and made the most of the admittedly lousy trail conditions. I think the rugged trail conditions, as well as the remoteness of the area, keep down on the crowds which I really like. I certainly enjoy the high-mileage days I hike, but I also like the “real” wilderness” experience of backpacking for days at a time in somewhere like the Frank or the Selway-Bitterroot where you really have to earn the miles.

If you’re ever back in the Frank or Selway-Bitterroot and want to coordinate logistics for a long point to point hike, let me know. There’s several that have been on my list for years but that I wouldn’t want to do with people who don’t know what they’re getting into.

PostedSep 23, 2021 at 11:49 pm

Love the entire style of your report. Devoid of details but capturing the essence of the FCW. It’s one of my favorite places to walk, for no reason other than the fact that the terrain, the environment, dictates what you do and how far you go. So incredibly satisfying and refreshing. Thank you.

Drew Smith BPL Member
PostedSep 30, 2021 at 4:44 pm

Nice report – you did a fantastic job of conveying the experience in just a few words and clips.

I hoped to hike this wilderness on my honeymoon (1987) but squandered my bride’s indulgence by spending too many days primitive camping on the Deschutes R on the Warm Springs Reservation during an absolute explosion of mayfly and caddis hatches. Not a fly-fisher, she was not thrilled to be swarmed by clouds of insects all day long.

Thanks for reminding me that I still need to hike this wilderness.

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
Loading...