I’m torn on this one as a Dipole DW owner. At first the ProTrek didn’t look appealing to me but I’m liking the newer pics. Can’t wait to see the demo/setup video. I absolutely love my Dipole. I was against extra poles/struts in the past, but they’re easy enough to pack and insert when setting up. They’re worth the weight to make the tent absolutely bombproof in winds and provide great head/foot room. Plus when using the solid inner it is toasty warm in the shoulder season. The Dipole has a very competitive footprint as well. It’s only 4 inches wider than ProTrek and 14 inches shorter. Maybe I’m being too harsh on the ProTrek footprint because I think for an intents and purposes you just judge the tent by widest width, even if only 40″ at the foot end. So 94×60 Dipole vs 108×56 ProTrek, which is still very competitive.
The few minor issues I have with the Dipole is the weight, that I tend to not use both doors/vestibules, and if using just the tarp the poles are in the way (though not super inconvenient). I was hoping the ProTrek could be double wall to make me consider ditching the Dipole, or have a tarp only option so I could alleviate the issues I have with the Dipole in the non bug/shoulder seasons. This would be an awesome tarp especially for someone like me who can’t seem to pitch a flat tarp well to save his life!
If it was double wall it would rival and beat the Solomid XL in my opinion. It would probably be similar weight, but much better internal living and venting/viewing. Most people are using two poles anyway so put that 2nd to use.
I can see why they went single wall to really differentiate from the others. It blows away any non-dcf trekking pole tent out there with all the features, materials, livability, and size for the weight. I’d rather have this than the Lunar Solo and the GG One (are listed specs wrong, how is this so wide?).
How do people think it will handle the winds? I see the two side panel tie outs which should help, as well as the lower foot end pole height. Also, is there going to be a discussion on the best angle for the peak guyout lines, with the ridgeline or offset?