Topic

Stove Advice


Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Home Forums Gear Forums Gear (General) Stove Advice

Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #3617950
    Chad C
    BPL Member

    @chadc

    I have an original model MSR WindPro (10.2 oz) and a 1.3L Evernew REI Titanium Pot (6.4 oz) – so like 17 oz total. I really like this setup but would like to get another solo setup that is more compact and a little lighter. For basically boiling water.

    I am debating between a

    Jetboil MicroMo (12oz) and

    Toaks 700ML Pot (3.2 oz) + MSR Pocket Rocket Deluxe (3 oz) – total 6.2 oz.

    I’ve also been eying the tall skinny Toaks 750 but thought the wider one might be more stable on a little canister stove.

    The second setup is obviously lighter, but the MicroMo is a neat little unit.  I might be Ok with the weight, I do want something that is pretty compact. Never had a JetBoil. With sales right now I could get the MicroM for around $110 and the second setup for $96.

    Any advice to sway me one way or the other?

    #3617952
    Jerry Adams
    BPL Member

    @retiredjerry

    Locale: Oregon and Washington

    I don’t want to sway anyone any direction : )

    but, I’ve used the Pocket Rocket Deluxe on several trips and it’s worked good.  New product.

    but, most upright canister stoves work good, about the same

    the PRD has a piezo lighter that works good, but only after several trips, ask me again in a year.  Many people have a bad opinion about piezo lighters because they fail quickly.

    #3617954
    Chad C
    BPL Member

    @chadc

    I don’t factor the piezo in really because I’ll pack a lighter anyways, I wouldn’t ever trust it! But it might be kind of nice when it worked, I’ve never had a stove with one.

    #3617961
    David Thomas
    BPL Member

    @davidinkenai

    Locale: North Woods. Far North.

    You’re right not to trust or rely on the piezo, but it is nice when it does works to avoid fumbling around for the lighter.  It slightly magnifies one of the advantages of canister stoves over WG and alcohol: the on/off is so easy, you turn your stove off much more to let food hot-soak and between courses that you save a fair bit of fuel.

    If you haven’t used a heat-exchanger pot or an all-in-one like a JetBoil, I’d suggest going that route.  On short trips, the fuel savings don’t balance the heavier weight of gear but on longer trips, it can.  And you only buy the HX pot once and forever after, you save $7.99/canister fuel.

    It puts a different arrow in your quiver.  The lower, stable WindPro is nice for a frypan or larger pot, perhaps on a group trip.  The JetBoil is ideal when you just need boiling water for 1-2 people and want it fast.

    It’s kind of surprising how much faster the water boils in an HX pot.  That of course saves fuel in and of itself, but also, you’re less likely to walk away (since it only takes 40-80 seconds) and therefore you don’t come back after it’s been boiling for a minute, wasting fuel.

    #3617967
    Jenny A
    BPL Member

    @jennifera

    Locale: Front Range

    Toaks/PRD combo for the win at a significantly lighter weight.  I’m a little surprised no one has mentioned the effects of wind.  With its recessed burner head, the PRD strongly resembles the Soto WindMaster and does pretty good in a light breeze.  Even though JetBoil does use a heat exchanger pot, the burner itself is pretty exposed to wind.  I have never lost a boil to wind with my Toaks 750ml pot and WindMaster.  Of course, you could rig up a wind screen if you needed.  I really like the light weight of that combo.  (I got an Olicamp XTS heat exchanger pot at the end of last summer and will probably use that on trips that are longer than a night or two.  It is quite a bit more efficient than the regular non-HX Toaks pot, but heavier.)

    #3617968
    Chad C
    BPL Member

    @chadc

    Thanks all lots of good advice!  @jennifera so you have the Toaks 750ML I linked to? What do you think of it vs the 700ML – short wide vs narrow? is it stable on your Windmaster?

    #3617978
    Jim B
    BPL Member

    @leftovereggs

    Toaks 750 or 700 work great on canister stoves.  Ditch the MSR. It’s a knock off of the Soto Windmaster.  That said, go Soto for a canister stove. I use the Soto and it’s never failed and the thing is amazing in wind.  Really quick boil times for 2 cups too.

    #3617988
    Jenny A
    BPL Member

    @jennifera

    Locale: Front Range

    Chad C, I do indeed have the Toaks 750 ml pot because that’s what I could get from REI.  It replaced a Snow Peak 900 cookset – I came to dislike the fryingpan-like lid that I never fried anything in and would not stay on in a pack.  The Toaks is just fine on the Windmaster, and I have been very happy with the combination of performance, stability, light weight, compactness, and fit into my pack.  Honestly, I would have settled for an aluminum pot with similar volume, but those don’t seem to be all that common anymore.  (The Olicamp HX pot is hard-anodized Al, and it is a bit heavier than the Ti pots.  Must be the added weight of the heat exchanger dealios, the vinyl hand grips, and that silly plastic lid, which I dumped for a Four Dog Ti lid.)  For what it’s worth, the piezo on the Windmaster has always worked without a hitch, even at 11K ft.  I still keep matches at hand, though.

    #3618018
    Jerry Adams
    BPL Member

    @retiredjerry

    Locale: Oregon and Washington

    pocket rocket deluxe – $70 – new product, reliability unproven – appears to be quite similar to Soto Windmaster

    windmaster – $65 – has been a round for a while, many people have good experience with it

     

    #3618019
    bradmacmt
    BPL Member

    @bradmacmt

    Locale: montana

    I am debating between a

    Jetboil MicroMo (12oz) and

    Toaks 700ML Pot (3.2 oz) + MSR Pocket Rocket Deluxe (3 oz) – total 6.2 oz.

    I’d go Jetboil.

    I’ve revisited using a separate stove/Ti pot several times over the years and always come back to the Jetboil (I have a variety but mostly use the Ti version).

    This year I went with the MSR Pocket Rocket Deluxe with a Snowpeak Ti-Minis Solo Combo… one trip, and I was right back to the Jetboil. In field conditions it’s faster and less fiddly.

     

    #3618024
    Jerry Adams
    BPL Member

    @retiredjerry

    Locale: Oregon and Washington

    I’m not arguing PRD is better than jetboil or anything : )

    but, what do you mean PRD is more fiddly?  It seems like they’re about the same – screw onto canister, put on pot of water, light…

    #3618025
    bradmacmt
    BPL Member

    @bradmacmt

    Locale: montana

    what do you mean PRD is more fiddly?

    It’s more susceptible to wind, more “tippy” with an unconnected pot, takes longer to boil… ie, “more fiddly.”

    #3618026
    Jerry Adams
    BPL Member

    @retiredjerry

    Locale: Oregon and Washington

    yeah, that makes sense

    I think Windmaster and PRD are more resistant to wind, but still need a windscreen, losing some of the weight savings compared to a jet boil

    #3618037
    DAN-Y/FANCEE FEEST
    Spectator

    @zelph2

    What David said:

    You’re right not to trust or rely on the piezo, but it is nice when it does works to avoid fumbling around for the lighter.  It slightly magnifies one of the advantages of canister stoves over WG and alcohol: the on/off is so easy, you turn your stove off much more to let food hot-soak and between courses that you save a fair bit of fuel.

    If you haven’t used a heat-exchanger pot or an all-in-one like a JetBoil, I’d suggest going that route.  On short trips, the fuel savings don’t balance the heavier weight of gear but on longer trips, it can.  And you only buy the HX pot once and forever after, you save $7.99/canister fuel.

    It puts a different arrow in your quiver.  The lower, stable WindPro is nice for a frypan or larger pot, perhaps on a group trip.  The JetBoil is ideal when you just need boiling water for 1-2 people and want it fast.

    It’s kind of surprising how much faster the water boils in an HX pot.  That of course saves fuel in and of itself, but also, you’re less likely to walk away (since it only takes 40-80 seconds) and therefore you don’t come back after it’s been boiling for a minute, wasting fuel.

    #3618038
    Chad C
    BPL Member

    @chadc

    It’s more susceptible to wind, more “tippy” with an unconnected pot, takes longer to boil… ie, “more fiddley.”

    That’s why I thought the short wide Toaks 700 might be the ticket

    #3618041
    Jerry Adams
    BPL Member

    @retiredjerry

    Locale: Oregon and Washington

    about the piezo failing, of course, bring a lighter just in case

    in the mean time, for the last couple years with Windmaster and last couple trips with PRD, I just use the piezo which is convenient

    it adds to the simplicity of using a canister stove vs other stoves

    #3618341
    Steve Thompson
    BPL Member

    @stevet

    Locale: Southwest

    For just boiling water I keep gravitating back to an alcohol burner.  I find that jet boils don’t simmer/cook, mostly they boil water really fast.  Pocket rockets, and similar cannister stove do adjust down better for cooking are probably the most versatile option.

    For stability lower profile, wider base pots are better.  Your Evernew 1.3L is the classic.

    All that said, my downsize for solo use, just boiling water I went with the caldera cone tri-ti and the 600ml Evernew pot.  Everything curls up inside the pot.  Good stability and wind resistance.  Only downside is the 8-10 minutes it takes to boil water vs about 2 with the jet boil.

    #3618367
    Chad C
    BPL Member

    @chadc

    Thanks all, seems to be about half and half on votes.  I have read up on the Soto Windmaster, I just didn’t like the idea of the separate legs and the PRD looked to be the same thing with connected legs. I was looking at the Soto Amicus too and that looks nice but it’s $40 at REI with two pots, and $40 everywhere else without pots so  I thought the pricing was kind of weird. And maybe it’s not in the same class as the other two.

    #3618414
    Jim B
    BPL Member

    @leftovereggs

    Soto Amicus is my primary stove now.  It has comparable wind performance as the windmaster, just no regulator.  But even without a regulator, the Amicus performs well in cold and with low fuel in the canister. Very efficient fuel usage too.  It’s worth the 40 bucks  imo.

Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Get the Newsletter

Get our free Handbook and Receive our weekly newsletter to see what's new at Backpacking Light!

Gear Research & Discovery Tools


Loading...