Topic

Recommend some clothing options…

Viewing 22 posts - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)
JAshley73 BPL Member
PostedNov 13, 2026 at 9:48 am

I need some recommendations for some clothing options. Rather than spend hours upon hours google-searching, I figure you folks would have some much better directed options.

 

Down pants – Worth it or not? I feel like these would be nice when resting at camp, and/or sleeping in cold temps. I’m familiar with Mountain Hardwear & Cotopaxi’s offerings. I see that Rab & MontBell have options as well. Any others I should check out? I know these get pricey, so used and/or budget options would be welcome as well.

 

 

 

Long Underwear or Alternatives – Truth be told, I can’t stand wearing long underwear or “leggings.” I’m not sure if it’s because as a guy, I have hairy legs, but the tight-fitting nature feels extremely irritating on my lower legs, specifically knees & calves. I’m not sure if others feel this same way, but I don’t think I’m alone here.

Any comfortable options for long underwear? Any good alternatives, like “slim fit” fleece joggers, or something that can be layered under “regular” hiking pants that isn’t too bulky? I barely know where to start here.

 

 

 

 

Cold/Wet Gloves – I’m not sure if I need full-on ski gloves or not. I feel like my hands get very cold, and of course wet weather makes this worse. I often work outside, and cold hands is often the worst thing for me to try and keep warm. Something for 50*F & wet and/or down into freezing temps with mixed rain/snow.

Preference or recommendations? I’m not opposed to gloves and/or mittens layered, but I barely know where to begin.

 

 

 

 

Edit – I certainly don’t mind if this thread runs long & wide, and others post up their wanted recommendations as well. Thanks in advance.

 

 

Terran BPL Member
PostedNov 13, 2026 at 10:55 am

Check Critter Mountain Wear on Etsy for fleece pants. For an extra $30 they added 12″ ankle openings with snaps so I could get my shoes through.

https://www.etsy.com/listing/4402302991/polartec-mens-pants

MH GW down pants are a slim fit with nice features..

But, NatureHikes are cheaper, lighter, and warmer IMO. Fewer features. Their pockets s***.

Between the two, I prefer my Enlightened Equipment synthetic Torrids. No features. No sewn through baffles. MooseTrackPacks make a similar pair.

https://www.moosetrackpacks.com/products/insulated-pants/

Gloves. Waterproof Showa Temres 282-02 with the liner cut out as recommended here. I left about 3″ of liner on the cuff. Possum down fingerless gloves with possum down gloves used as liners. Mix and match.

For work gloves, I just use insulated work gloves . I prefer the cheap brown jersey gloves if you can keep them dry.

 

JAshley73 BPL Member
PostedNov 13, 2026 at 11:50 am

Terran great recommendations – thanks!

How small do the Torrid pants compress down, relatively? I’m always leery of synthetic-insulation items, as they’re usually bulky in the pack. Do you find these as warm as the down options, or not so much? For the price of the Moosetrack pants, I’d probably just stick to down pants bought on-sale.

The Torrid pants at the current $112 however, are pretty interesting. Do these retain a fair amount of insulation when sitting down, or is that insulation pretty soft/compressible? (Not the main criteria BTW)

 

 

Dustin V BPL Member
PostedNov 13, 2026 at 12:56 pm

+1 for the Naturehike down pants. They are very puffy, warm, pack down small and are a good budget option. Just be sure to size up a couple of sizes.

Terran BPL Member
PostedNov 13, 2026 at 1:14 pm

I tore my last pair of Torrid pants apart after four years of heavy use. The Apex stretched out in the knees and the rear. I’m sure it compressed in that time as well. I’ve had my current pair for two years. Not as resilient or long lasting as down. Easier to wash. Often when I think they’re loosing warmth, they’re just dirty. They’re warmer because they’re not sewn through every few inches. Less worry about rips and tears and water. No loosing down. Nice over a pair of down pants when it’s really cold. They fit into the same bag as my naturehikes taking up about another inch of length. I wouldn’t usually compress them that small. Down is more forgiving. Not overly compressed sitting down. $112 is a good price.

 

Jerry Adams BPL Member
PostedNov 13, 2026 at 2:52 pm

my regular pants are supplex, tough enough so they last pretty good

I made an apex pants with 10d fabric shell (or something) that goers over the pants.  That’s okay, but they’re easily damaged.

I made a smaller around apex pants that go under the supplex pants – much better, you can have fragile light weight fabric if it’s underneath

I’m sure you can buy something along that line.

When I wear my apex pants under supplex, then I overheat even when it’s as low as 20F.  I start sweating on my torso.  If I unzip my jacket and down vest then I’m okay.  I don’t do that much time at 20F so this is what works in that condition.  And normally when it’s really cold, it’s not that windy.

Putting on and taking off the apex pants is a pain.

Mark BPL Member
PostedNov 14, 2026 at 8:30 am

For non calf constricting long underwear bottoms I really like Mont Bell’s ZEO-LINE Middle Weight Knee-Length Tights Men’s.  I have been wearing them for a decade.

Dan Quixote BPL Member
PostedNov 15, 2026 at 5:28 am

Just a thought, if an odd one: Though I am a man, I picked up a down skirt at Costco about a decade ago and that thing has been absolute money when camping out in the cold. Not very good for hiking in, but it keeps some critical groin and thigh areas insulated, thus warmer, which in turn keeps my shins and feet warmer. It slips on and off really easily, and I have worn it inside my sleeping quilts when pushing their limits. I don’t think I’ve ever weighed it but I used the first one enough I decided to buy a spare when costco had them available again.  Those ones were like $15, but the quality (and price) can both go up. Bet you could find a variety of options on ebay or poshmark, as well as dynafit and some other brands. What I like about the costco ones include the price, the length (pretty long on my short frame), it can unzip completely on one side and halfway up the other, which allows me to adjust it for warmth/mobility, and the hand-pockets are okay but for my uses I could leave them out: if I’m wearing that thing I should have hand-pockets on my down coat that are at a more convenient height for my resting my hands.

I’ve only had a couple jocular threats from friends to disavow me for wearing a garment that is technically a women’s skirt, but the practicality in the cold outweighs mockery, and I’m almost always wearing it in the backcountry where function trumps form anyway. Again, just an idea.

Bill Budney BPL Member
PostedNov 15, 2026 at 1:32 pm

Puffy Pants: Yes. (EE Torrids work for me, but any should suffice).

Long Underwear Alternative: Fleece pajama pants. They’re warm, light, and dry quickly. If you could find them made of Alpha Direct, that would be even lighter.

Handwear: Layers.

  • DexShell and Frogg Toggs make WPB gloves that cover a wide range of conditons.
  • However, I really like the cheap fleece liner gloves sold at Walmart and dollar stores. They’re light, pack small, and dry quickly. Some work with my phone. Tip: women’s gloves are even smaller and lighter than men’s, and stretch to fit any hand.
  • Oversized nitrile gloves are waterproof and very light/small. Ansell sells them in 3x (on eBay) if you need a huge size. 2x are widely available. I get 5 mil or thicker: they last longer and go on/off more easily.
  • Fleece or wool knit mittens.
  • Shells. Any will suffice. Even Tyvek and tape will do: just trace your hand with thumb extended for a simple design.
Jerry Adams BPL Member
PostedNov 15, 2026 at 2:30 pm

I use fingerless mittens from fleece.  Good in some conditions.

If you want warmer hands put a hat on.  Or a jacket or pants.  If your body starts getting cold, blood to your hands is restricted so they’ll get cold.

Sometimes I have let my fingers get cold, then white and numb.  Short of frostbite.  I think that may produce effects like Raynaud’s syndrome.  It permanently makes my fingers more sensitive to cold and other problems.

I used to just ignore it and it I’m taking down my tent or whatever, just keep doing it.  Now, when my fingers start to get white I stop, put them in my pocket or next to my stomach and let them warm up.

JAshley73 BPL Member
PostedNov 16, 2026 at 12:28 pm

RE Gloves – I ended up purchasing these Outdoor Research Adrenaline 3-in-1 Gloves at a local outdoor gear shop this weekend. It’s a nicely paired set with a polyester liner glove, and a generous WPB outer glove. (I had forgotten what a frustrating endeavor Glove-shopping is – especially if you’re wearing a watch as well…)

They fit well & comfortably, and allow options, which should be nice. I can say, they were welcome this morning when scraping windows, after our first proper freeze of the year…

 

I had never thought about the super-large nitrile gloves before, but I like the idea. That would be really useful during extra-wet times.

From what I’ve heard as well, possum-hair gloves sound really nice & warm as well. I’ll keep an eye out for these.

JAshley73 BPL Member
PostedNov 16, 2026 at 12:39 pm

RE Pants – I’m thinking that it’s important to divide “warm” legwear into under-pants, or over-pants. What I mean by that, is that my “standard” layer is a pair of nylon hiking pants. Long underwear of course would be layered under, and down-pants would likely be worn over the “standard” layer.

Is that thinking correct?

Since I hate long underwear in the traditional sense (old school, tight fitting, waffle-knit)  because of the irritating fit & feel on the lower legs, a good under-layer wouldn’t be so tight-fitting. Perhaps some fleece “joggers” or “midweight baselayers” – whatever the correct term would be.

While hiking, these would pretty much be worn full-time, under the “standard layer” pants.

I’ve done the (standard wide-leg) fleece pajama pants under regular pants before. It works OK at keeping me warm while on a cold shop floor, but it’s not something that’s very comfortable for a lot of movement. Not something I’d want to wear when hiking or backpacking…

 

To contrast, the down-pants would be worn over the “standard layer” pants when at camp and/or resting, or while sleeping. I could also see pulling off the “standard layer” hiking pants when sleeping, especially if wet/dirty/muddy, and wearing the down pants over the “under layer” pants while at camp or sleeping.

 

Does that line of thinking make sense?

With that in mind, I’m not sure where the EE Torid pants fit. Are these worn under the “standard layer” pants, or over them? I handled a set this past weekend, and they seem fragile. They seem to be designed to fit over regular pants, but don’t look durable enough to trek through some tough, brushy terrain. So are these meant to be worn under your “standard layer” pants, or simply slipped over when sitting or resting?

Bill Budney BPL Member
PostedNov 16, 2026 at 12:44 pm

I have a pair of ZPacks Possum mittens. They’re 29% possum, 51% wool, and 19% nylon. They’re very light, but their Octa mittens are half the weight, about the same warmth, and quicker to dry.

I consider all of them “Florida mittens”. Nice and light, but not very warm for below freezing weather, and not large enough to layer over anything thick.

They would be nice as liners, though.

Bill Budney BPL Member
PostedNov 16, 2026 at 12:54 pm

Where are you hiking that requires puffy pants while moving? If you’re headed to Antarctica, then you might be asking the wrong questions. ;)

Puffies, including pants, are more commonly worn around camp, where light fabric is fine. Yes, they are normally worn over your regular pants. You might wear rain pants over them if it’s raining.

Speaking of rain pants, I have been wearing them more as cool-weather over-pants. I have been much happier with them for that purpose rather than trying to wear them when it’s raining and warm. A kilt/skirt works better in warmer weather

Full length 2-way zippers allow you to ventilate the thighs, which helps very much.

EDIT: I have light athletic warmup pants that work as you suggest: one layer for hiking pants, two layers for cold weather. The specific brand is no longer available, but anything light and stretchy should work.

JAshley73 BPL Member
PostedNov 16, 2026 at 1:41 pm

@Bill_Budney said…

Where are you hiking that requires puffy pants while moving?

I’m not planning on wearing the “puffy” pants while moving. I’m sorry if that wasn’t clear in previous messages.

That said, I’m still confused on the EE Torid pants. I’m not sure if these are supposed to be layered under one’s regular pants, or worn over, as down “puffy” pants would be.

 

For rain pants, I have Mountain Hardware Stretch Ozonic rain pants. I love them. My only complaint is that they only have (1) front zipper pocket. If they had (2), they’d be perfect. I can wear them as “regular” pants, with nothing underneath except my normal boxer-briefs. The zippers mean I can unzip a few inches from the top to vent the waist area, and unzip from the bottom hem a few inches so that they rest well and cover the top of the shoes.

I bought my WPB gear for outside work in all-weather conditions, but I’ve been very pleased with these. I could, and have comfortably worn these as “regular” pants when weather looks foul – not just as an emergency, throw-over layer.

Terran BPL Member
PostedNov 16, 2026 at 4:27 pm

I order the 20D Torrids of of their custom page. Same price.

The Torrids are made to wear over your other clothes. I sized up partly  to help get them over my shoes.

Tipi Walter BPL Member
PostedNov 17, 2026 at 9:28 am

I used to carry down pants on all my winter trips but dropped them due to weight as my sleeping bag has all the down I need to keep warm in camp.

I love my merino Icebreaker leggings and wear them both in camp and as “pants” under shorts for most winter hiking—on cold trips I take a large pair under an extra large pair for camp warmth when sitting in the tent.  On the trail only one pair is used under shorts as pants.  (Of course in deep cold with high winds I wear OR Foray rain pants over the leggings for warmth—and usually put my shorts over the pants to have pockets for stuff like granola bars etc.

In winter I dispense with gloves and carry mittens only—two pair in case one gets wet.  Mt Hardwear makes a down mitt called Nilas which I use and they are very light and warm.  After I turned 70 I started carrying Hot Hands on all my trips and used on cold mornings to keep hands warm, esp when hiking and put inside my Nilas mitts.

Terran BPL Member
PostedNov 18, 2026 at 8:28 am

In how warm a temperature are you still wearing the leggings?

For my use, I need something that I can easily take off as the day warms up. Or easily put back on. With long johns underneath my shorts, I hesitate to strip down or even to take my shoes off.

 

Jerry Adams BPL Member
PostedNov 18, 2026 at 9:29 am

Me, I just wear single layer nylon pants down to 20F

I have tried long underwear or apex long underwear, but yeah, it’s a pain to remove.  And when I wear them I tend to overheat.

With a jacket or vest I can unzip the front and shed half my insulation, better with the vest.  I never use insulated arms.

Brad Rogers BPL Member
PostedNov 18, 2026 at 11:28 am

You really didn’t say what your goal was or the conditions that you want to be prepared for, so it’s hard to tell how applicable this advice is but here are my two cents.

 

I have a set of Mont-Bell down pants that I’ve had for years, I very rarely ever bring them on a trip.  I do tend to hike until about an hour before dark, stop to set up camp and cook dinner and then get under my quilt in my shelter, so I don’t sit around camp, so your mileage may vary depending on the conditions you expect and the style of your trips.

 

Long Underwear – I have something that you may like, I have a set of Senchi Designs Polartec Alpha bottoms that are not “tights” – they’re insanely lightweight and are very warm under a more windproof layer.  I use them mostly to sleep in but have used them under rain pants around camp when it was chilly.

Otherwise, if I need to wear something else hiking I have some Patagonia Cap 4 (now Expedition weight?) tights and a set of Patagonia R1 tights, but they’re both tighter fitting and heavier.   That being said, I almost never need another layer on my legs hiking as they tend to generate quite a bit of heat while hiking.

 

As for gloves – I have historically used a 3 layer system with a liner glove (I like MH Powerstretch Gloves) along with a 200wt fleece mitten, and a WP/B shell mitt – like the MLD eVent Rain Mitts.  That being said, you can’t really do anything except for operate trekking poles with the mitts and while you can always take them off and use just the liner glove for more intricate chores, the liner glove by itself is not super warm.

My other system is copying Andrew Skurka who suggested a commercial fishing glove, the Showa 282-02 – They’re a waterproof glove with integrated insulation that’s pretty tough for actual chores in the rain or snow and have a long cuff to help keep everything else dry.  They’re sized small though if I remember as I thin they’re a Japanese company, so size up.  You can probably google his review – and they are offered now in black rather than the blue he used years ago.   Bonus is they’re cheap.

Terran BPL Member
PostedNov 18, 2026 at 11:31 am

If it would only stay in one temperature range.

Viewing 22 posts - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)
Loading...