Topic

Reapplying DWR Questions

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 20 total)
Lowell k BPL Member
PostedNov 14, 2026 at 11:27 am

I reapplied DWR using Nikwax TX wash followed by its DWR product. Does this look like the jacket is still wetting out? It was a gentle rain, and I didn’t take it in the shower or anything like that to test it under downpour conditions. I can’t say it fel damp inside, but I only was outside for while it rained briefly.1

Jerry Adams BPL Member
PostedNov 14, 2026 at 12:00 pm

I can see water beads, good

What are those darker patches?  Are they water? Do they go away if you let it dry, like for a day?

Lowell k BPL Member
PostedNov 14, 2026 at 12:45 pm

I’ve had if for 3 years, only wore it a few times. The dark patches go away with air drying.

Jerry Adams BPL Member
PostedNov 14, 2026 at 1:14 pm

If you washed and reapplied dwr you did what you could.  I assume you put it in drier – you need heat to get it to work

Maybe just try it in steady rain for a few hours and see if it works, does the inside of the jacket get wet

Lowell k BPL Member
PostedNov 14, 2026 at 2:21 pm

I did put it in the dryer, maybe I need to reapply the DWR multiple times to make sure all the areas are definitely covered. Kind of a pain, but the jackets are expensive. I can see the attraction of frogs togs.

Jerry Adams BPL Member
PostedNov 14, 2026 at 4:28 pm

just a speculation – I don’t think rewashing and re-applying would help.  That looks like degradation of the membrane.  That has happened to me before and it looked sort of like that.

Maybe just try using it and see how it works.  I could see water beading up on it.

You could ask the manufacturer.  It seems like it shouldn’t do that after a few uses in three years

Maybe someone else will have something better to say

JAshley73 BPL Member
PostedNov 14, 2026 at 7:18 pm

Lowell,

If that’s a 2.5L jacket especially, I wander if the “moisture” that you’re seeing on the inside isn’t actually your sweat condensing inside the jacket. It would make sense, if the outer layer is starting to wet-out and breathe less. I suspect a 2.5L jacket would be/feel worse, as by not having a true fabric inner, your skin is right up against the jacket fabric, and won’t “breathe” as well under the jacket.

 

As far as reapplying the DWR, the directions aren’t explicitly clear as to a best way. I’m seeing some evidence that it may be best to apply the DWR to the garment when it’s wet, or at least damp. Supposedly the garment being damp is supposed to help draw the DWR into the fabric. I’m still confused about this idea, so please don’t take this as expert advice, and do your own research there.

 

What I have done that seemed to work Ok, is to spray/soak the garment in DWR. Instead of wiping off, I’ve then scrubbed the garment to really “work in” the DWR into the fabric. If after a vigours scrubbing there’s still excess, I’ll gently wipe off. Let air dry. Then, place in the dryer on medium-high heat.

 

I don’t think the shower test is realistic nor helpful. Unless you have a water-saving shower head, I think most shower heads submit the garment to too much volume & pressure, that’s unrealistic to “real life” use of the garment.

Jerry Adams BPL Member
PostedNov 14, 2026 at 8:27 pm

Follow the directions :)

Wash it.  Maybe let water drip off it so it’s not too wet. Spray it on the outside.  Put in drier.

Bill Budney BPL Member
PostedNov 15, 2026 at 2:09 pm

In my experience, DWR is unimportant. It’s 90% marketing, 10% science. It looks fantastic, when it’s new, to see water bead up and roll off.

But, even when new, it won’t last more than a few minutes in moderate or heavy rain. Then it’s all about the membrane.

Which is why membrane-on-the-outside (Outdry, Frogg Toggs UL2, ShakeDry) are the best in heavy rain: They can never wet out (which makes them cold and encourages condensation inside).

If anyone could make good DWR, then we would be wearing windshirts instead of WPBs.

YMMV (maybe).

Tip: Regarding re-applying it, factory DWR is applied with precise heat close to the melting point of the membrane. You can’t replicate that at home. Maybe the warm dryer might help, maybe not.

Tip 2: It works best (not necessarily “well”, but better) to use the same kind of DWR as the jacket had originally at the factory. If that was a fluorocarbon DWR, then use Gear Aid or Granger’s. If it was wax-based, then NikWax.

 

PostedNov 16, 2026 at 9:47 am

If anyone could make good DWR, then we would be wearing windshirts instead of WPBs.

Here you’re wrong. A DWR, however perfect, is not a barrier. It’s a surface finish. The two layers do different jobs, and only one of them holds back water under pressure. A DWR’s job is to keep the face fabric dry so water beads and rolls off. If it were perfect and everlasting, you would eliminate wet-out, the saturation of the face fabric that kills breathability and adds weight. That’s genuinely the biggest practical complaint about modern shells. But that’s all it would do. The interstices between yarns in any woven face fabric are tens of microns wide. A DWR raises the contact angle so water needs pressure to push through, but pressure is exactly what rain provides: a raindrop’s impact, wind-driven rain, and above all static pressure from contact, kneeling on wet snow, a pack’s hip belt, an elbow on wet rock. A water column of just 10 cm is about 1 kPa; body weight through a strap is far beyond that. A membrane’s pores (~0.1 µm, orders of magnitude smaller than a droplet) turn that into a hydrostatic-head contest the fabric loses instantly. A DWR’d fabric might hold just a few centimeters/inches.

Which is why membrane-on-the-outside (Outdry, Frogg Toggs UL2, ShakeDry) are the best in heavy rain: They can never wet out (which makes them cold and encourages condensation inside).

Only they’re fragile, contain PFAS and/or have a poor MVTR to begin with.

BTW, AFAIK, Frogg Toggs have still a face fabric.

Bill Budney BPL Member
PostedNov 16, 2026 at 10:01 am

Not in real life.

I understand that DWR is different than membranes, obviously. My point is that we would wear windbreakers more if they resisted a bit more rain. Not that we would replace membranes with windbreakers.

Personally, I haven’t found Outdry to be any more fragile than light WPBs. If anything, it’s fairly robust, which is the common complaint about it (weight). It isn’t as strong as something with a 50D face fabric, of course. But it isn’t as flimsy as ShakeDry.

Outdry’s MVTR is higher when it’s raining than anything with a wet-out face fabric. Also, MVTR is not the only factor affecting comfort, and we’re not even sure that the charts we have correctly account for common combinations of membranes, climate, and weather.

Frogg Toggs UL2 is the original membrane-on-the-outside, before ShakeDry and Outdry. They don’t publish MVTR ratings, and nobody expects it to compete with the better WPBs, but they did it first. Their other products do have face fabrics, but UL2 is the fabric that the UL community uses. (I’m not saying that it’s better… just that it exists and is very inexpensive in the US).

Jerry Adams BPL Member
PostedNov 16, 2026 at 10:09 am

I just bought a frog  FROGG TOGGS Ultra-lite2 Waterproof Rain Poncho, Breathable and Reusable

At Bill’s suggestion

It appears to have the membrane on the outside

I think some frog toggs do have a face fabric on the outside, some don’t, but that’s just a guess

Everything that you said is correct.  But DWRs fail after a few hours of rain.  Some better, some worse.

I’ve used neoshell in steady rain for 2 hours where it kept me dry.  I’m waiting for an opportunity to test it for a longer period, I suspect it will get wet on the inside surface of the jacket at some point.  Consistent with what Bill said.

PostedNov 16, 2026 at 10:40 am

Well, it depends on how you use a windbreaker. Personally, I use it a lot and the WPB stays in my backpack till the very worst. But there are lot of users who don’t even have  a windbreaker and rely on their WPB for nearly everything.

For a windbreaker to behave better in rain, you don’t need better DWR, but a denser woven fabric but that then at the cost of lesser breathability.

That Outdry Extreme’s MVTR is higher when it’s raining than anything with a wet-out face fabric, is exactly what Stephen is researching now.

Jerry Adams BPL Member
PostedNov 16, 2026 at 11:51 am

I need WPB because it often rains.  So I use it for everything

PostedNov 16, 2026 at 12:58 pm

But I use my windbreaker also in lite to moderate rain. I even once wore  my windbreaker at the start of daytrip because of the grey, windy weather; didn’t add my WPB when it started to rain litely or moderately, only added my WPB when the rain got heavier … and then, after perhaps 15-30 minutes removed the WPB again as I felt comfier in just my windbreaker. In the end, I was soaking wet, but comfortable.

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 20 total)
Loading...