Used the earlier Tarptent Moment-not-DW for many years. Loved the design, but the tent had pros and cons.
PRO:
– Quick and easy to set up. Takes some practice putting the pole through the sleeve (tip: bunch up the fabric), but my setup time was about 1 minute. Never had problems with the struts left in place, or the stuff sack, if I put the pole in last.
– Small footprint fit in many more locations.
– Roomy enough if you aren’t 6’2” or taller, sleeping on a 3” thick pad :-(
– Roomy vestibule held pack, shoes, and more.
– Netting J-door much easier to open/close/in/out than traditional half-moon doors.
CON:
– I grew to hate silnylon because of this tent. The fabric absorbed too much water from rain or condensation, and stretched and flapped in the wind, then took forever to dry. Newer silnylons are supposed to be better, but I’m much happier with a silpoly tent.
– Had trouble with rain leaking through upper attachment points that I never solved despite repeated tries.
– Couldn’t sit up straight after a sleeping pad upgrade (see above).
– Not the best tent when the wind hits broadside.
Still, the single hoop design has many benefits for most conditions, and the 2019+ Moment DW is supposed to be better.
Decades ago owned another “single arched pole” tent, the Moss Solus (similar to TT Rainbow), and loved that until the PU coating rotted.
Hilleburg makes a couple of single hoop tents, the Akto and Enan. I think there are a few others on the market.
Unpopularity is another issue. There’s a lot of industry inertia. Wholesale purchasers for large retailers (cough-REI-cough) like to buy what sold last year, not something that looks different but performs better. Direct-to-consumer companies like TarpTent can be more creative.
— Rex